ABRAnews Open the whole story. Sign in

US and Russia expected to oppose talks on binding rules for autonomous weapons

Delegates from 128 states meet in Geneva through Nov. 20, and the consensus rule lets any single country thwart an agreement.

The Palace of Nations in Geneva in 2014
The Palace of Nations in Geneva in 2014. Photo: Vassil, CC0, Wikimedia Commons
Published 1 min read
Overview

Delegates from 128 states opened a weeklong United Nations conference in Geneva on Monday, Nov. 16, to decide whether to begin negotiating rules on lethal autonomous weapons, machines that can select and attack targets without human intervention. The meeting, held under the Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons, runs through Nov. 20. The United States and Russia are expected to oppose launching negotiations on a legally binding treaty.

The US has proposed five more years of expert work toward a nonbinding instrument, arguing existing humanitarian law already applies. Military Times reports the conference chair has proposed a two-year mandate to negotiate a binding protocol. UN Secretary-General Antonio Guterres and human rights chief Volker Türk urge binding rules.

Russian Foreign Ministry spokeswoman Maria Zakharova called it premature to say the time has come for restrictive or prohibitive measures. The convention works by consensus, so any single state can thwart an agreement. The Seattle Times reports that 163 states backed an October General Assembly resolution supporting binding negotiations.

No treaty is expected from the conference. Two diplomats speaking to Reuters said a compromise might be reached by week's end.

Key figures
  • 128 statesdelegations at the Geneva conferenceThe Seattle Times
  • 163 statesbacked the October UN General Assembly resolution, by The Seattle Times' accountThe Seattle Times
  • 130 countriessupport a legally binding instrument, according to Stop Killer RobotsNewsweek
  • five more yearswork the US proposes toward a nonbinding instrumentNewsweek
  • two-year mandateproposed by the conference chair for binding protocol talks, per Military TimesMilitary Times

Three sides of the story

6 news outlets reported this

Tap a color or swipe sideways to switch sides.

Liberal2 outlets

Campaigners worry the chance for rules is slipping away

NPR reports that talks in Geneva are aimed at setting rules for weapons that choose and strike targets with no person deciding. It says the US, Russia and Israel are resisting legally binding controls, and campaigners fear that time to act is running out. The New York Times describes a UN effort it calls uncertain to regulate lethal autonomous weapons, with delegates weighing limits on such systems while their development expands, and says Russia and the United States have resisted.

Center3 outlets

Binding treaty hopes meet US and Russian resistance

The Seattle Times, in a piece on the conference, says global efforts have reached a "crossroads" and notes that the consensus rule gives every state an effective veto. It recounts that late in the September expert talks the United States and Russia had language removed that many considered essential, and that 163 states backed an October General Assembly resolution. Military Times leads with US and Russian opposition, says Russia stalled the start of talks on Monday over a rule on observers speaking, and quotes Guterres: "The nature of warfare is changing."

Newsweek reports the US is expected to say no, lays out a Nov. 4 US working paper favoring nonbinding rules, and quotes Türk and Nicole van Rooijen of Stop Killer Robots. An Associated Press report in The Seattle Times opens with killer robots coming up for a "reckoning," cites Pope Leo XIV, and quotes Russia's Maria Zakharova calling talks on restrictions "premature."

Conservative1 outlet

Killer drones face a reckoning at the UN

The Washington Times reports that government envoys picked up the discussion on Monday at the U.N. conference. It says they could decide during the conference whether to open negotiations on rules for lethal AI weapons, or not. Its headline says killer drones face a "reckoning."

All sources: 7 articles from 6 outlets

Liberal (2)

Center (4)

Conservative (1)