US, China and Russia issue a peace declaration that skips Ukraine and Iran
The leaders back United Nations reform, more refined petroleum, nuclear-risk talks and limits on the International Criminal Court, but announce no arsenal cuts.
President Donald Trump, China's Xi Jinping and Russia's Vladimir Putin met on Thursday in Shenzhen, China, on the sidelines of the APEC summit. It was the first sit-down of the leaders of the three countries. Afterward they released a symbolic four-point "peace declaration."
It calls for reforms of the United Nations, more production and supply of refined petroleum products, and a dialogue on reducing nuclear risks. It also says the International Criminal Court and similar bodies must not "abuse their jurisdiction." The declaration never mentions Russia's war in Ukraine or the Iran war led by the US, and it does not spell out the type and extent of the UN reforms.
The leaders affirmed that nuclear war must never be fought but announced no commitments to cut their arsenals. Trump said he and Putin had a long discussion about Ukraine. Xi called the talks "positive, constructive and fruitful," according to DW, and Trump said they were "really making history."
ABC News and an Associated Press report say Trump showed no sign of winning pledges from Xi or Putin that could help end the Iran conflict. According to ABC News, Trump walked away without fielding questions and said a news conference at the White House was planned for Friday.
- four-pointpeace declaration released after the meetingABC News
- around 500 warheadsChina's estimated nuclear arsenal, per DWDeutsche Welle
- more than 5,000 warheadsbelieved held by each of Moscow and Washington, per DWDeutsche Welle
- nine monthslength of the US war with Iran, per ABC NewsABC News
- over an hourlength of the talks, per the Associated PressYahoo News
Three sides of the story
14 news outlets reported this
Tap a color or swipe sideways to switch sides.
Liberal8 outlets
A historic summit with no tangible breakthroughs
ABC News leads with Trump heading home after a historic meeting "with no tangible diplomatic breakthroughs in hand," then goes through takeaways on nuclear arms, Ukraine, energy and the ICC. It quotes Trump saying the US will not let Iran have a nuclear weapon. Yahoo News carries an Associated Press report saying the readouts reflected "more symbolism than substance."
It profiles each leader: Xi gaining stature by hosting, Trump claiming a place in history, Putin signaling he heads a superpower. It quotes Ruby Osman of London's Tony Blair Institute: "Beijing wanted to be seen as the adult in the room." The Guardian's "Troublesome trio" item has Patrick Wintour explaining to Lucy Hough why the summit is causing alarm in the west and elsewhere, with Europe absent from the talks.
NBC News's Meet the Press lists a segment, "Putin is no friend," on lawmakers reacting to Trump's praise of Putin and Xi.
- ABC News: Trump China trip: Iran and Ukraine not in 'peace declaration' and more takeaways
- Yahoo News: Key takeaways from the historic summit between Trump, Xi and Putin
- The Guardian: Troublesome trio: Trump, Xi and Putin hold historic meeting - The Latest
- NBC News: ‘Putin is no friend’: Lawmakers react to Trump’s praise of Putin and Xi Jinping
Center2 outlets
Putin's gain and the limits of the summit
Deutsche Welle asks in its headline what the leaders achieved and answers through analysts. Emma Chanlett-Avery of the Asia Society Policy Institute says Putin had the most to gain, and Chim Lee of The Economist Intelligence Unit calls the meeting a "major outcome for Russia." DW says the declaration commits only to "dialogue" on nuclear risks, and that Beijing has so far been reluctant to accept limits because its estimated arsenal is far smaller.
It adds that the summit raised worries the three powers could try to reorder the world into competing spheres of influence and recalls Zelenskyy's warning of a "second Yalta," which Ying-Yu Lin of Taiwan's Tamkang University calls "a bit of a stretch." The Journal calls the meeting a "coup" for Putin that left him with few concrete gains, and its headline says his friendships have their limits.
Conservative4 outlets
Trump's case for dialogue and four agreed areas
Breitbart News leads with Trump saying past leaders avoided talking to nations they disagreed with, quoting him: "No problems were ever solved under the old school, refusing to talk about them." It builds the report on the White House press release listing four areas of cooperation: UN reform, refined petroleum supply, the ICC and nuclear dialogue. It also quotes Trump on Ukraine, saying he and Putin talked for a long while and "things are happening."
The Washington Times headline says Trump, Xi and Putin agreed on energy and on targeting the ICC, with no breakthrough on Iran or Ukraine. It says the meeting placed Trump opposite his "chief rivals," Xi and Putin, and that the three reached accord on raising energy output and lowering the danger of nuclear war.
Which side made the stronger case?
We will email you when the story continues. At most one email a day.
All sources: 21 articles from 14 outlets
Liberal (12)
- ABC News: Trump China trip: Iran and Ukraine not in 'peace declaration' and more takeaways
- ABC News: China and Russia say they and US agree on UN reforms, boosting fuel supplies, dialogue on nuclear
- NBC News: Trump’s historic summit with Xi, Putin
- NBC News: ‘Putin is no friend’: Lawmakers react to Trump’s praise of Putin and Xi Jinping
- PBS NewsHour: 3 takeaways from Trump, Xi and Putin's historic summit
- Semafor: Trump, Xi, and Putin pledge to boost oil production
- Semafor: Trump, Xi and Putin hold landmark talks in Shenzhen
- The Boston Globe: Trump flaunts camaraderie with Xi and Putin but has little to show for it
- The Guardian: Troublesome trio: Trump, Xi and Putin hold historic meeting - The Latest
- Yahoo News: Key takeaways from the historic summit between Trump, Xi and Putin
Center (2)
- Deutsche Welle: Xi Jinping, Donald Trump and Vladimir Putin have held trilateral talks ― but what did they achieve?
- The Wall Street Journal: Trump-Xi Summit Shows Putin’s Powerful Friendships Have Their Limits
Conservative (7)
- Breitbart News: 'Constructive and Fruitful': Putin and Xi Jinping Pleased with Trump Summit
- Breitbart News: Trump at Putin-Xi Meeting: No Problems Were Ever Solved by Refusing to Discuss Them
- Breitbart News: Joint Statement Promising U.N. & I.C.C. Reform, Nuclear Counterproliferation Published After Trump-Xi-Putin Talks
- The American Conservative: Trump, Xi, and Putin End Summit With ‘Joint Declaration of Peace’
- The Epoch Times: NTD Evening News Full Broadcast (Nov. 19)
- The Washington Times: Trump, Xi, Putin agree on energy and targeting ICC; no breakthrough on Iran, Ukraine
- The Washington Times: U.S., China, Russia agree to U.N. reform, nuclear talks, boosting energy supplies
The evening briefing by email
One email a day, around 8:30 p.m. New York time: the seven main stories, each with its three sides, and the blind spot of the day. Unsubscribe with one tap.
A Telegram channel is coming soon.