Judge signals she may block Trump's planned Sunday closure of East Potomac Park
Judge Ana Reyes questioned the Justice Department's seawall safety rationale on Friday, and its lawyers said there are no current plans for work after closing.
A federal judge in Washington, D.C., is set to rule on whether the Trump administration can close East Potomac Park and its public golf course on Sunday, Nov. 15. U.S. District Judge Ana Reyes, appointed by former President Joe Biden, held a lengthy hearing on Friday. She indicated she was not poised to let the closure proceed, at least for now, and could order the park to stay open.
She did not say when she would issue an order. President Trump wants to rebuild East Potomac Golf Links as a "World Class Championship Golf Course." lawyers told the court the park is closing for safety reasons, citing deterioration of the seawall.
They also said National Links Trust's agreement to run the golf course ends effective Sunday. Reyes noted that the seawall has had documented problems for a decade and that thousands of runners used the park for the Marine Corps Marathon. DOJ lawyers said there are no current plans for any work on the seawall or the course once the park closes.
Reyes had earlier barred the administration from removing trees from the course. She has also launched a distinct probe testing whether administration officials deceived the court and broke professional ethics rules.
- 30,000 peoplerunners Reyes cited at last month's Marine Corps Marathon around the courseWashington Examiner
- Nov. 15date Trump said the current golf course would closeWashington Examiner
Three sides of the story
26 news outlets reported this
Tap a color or swipe sideways to switch sides.
Liberal12 outlets
A judge who may keep the park open
NPR asks whether a judge will step in to stop the government from closing the "beloved" D.C. park on Sunday. It reports that on Friday Judge Ana Reyes pressed the government over its intentions for East Potomac Park. NPR says she signaled she might order the park kept open even though President Trump wants to renovate it.
Center7 outlets
The fate of Trump's golf course makeover
The Hill reports that a federal judge will decide whether Trump's planned overhaul of the East Potomac Park golf course can move ahead. It says a ruling is expected on whether the administration can proceed with closing the park and its historic public course. After a long hearing Friday, the judge signaled she was not ready to let it proceed, at least for now.
Conservative7 outlets
A skeptical judge grilling DOJ lawyers on closure
The Washington Examiner's headline has the judge grilling Trump administration lawyers on the "sudden upcoming closure" of East Potomac Park. It reports that Reyes, "an appointee of former President Joe Biden," questioned the Justice Department's lawyers for hours and appeared likely to halt the closure. DOJ lawyers cited safety concerns over seawall deterioration and noted that the National Links Trust contract ends effective Sunday.
The paper quotes Reyes asking why all of Hains Point must shut over the seawall when "30,000 people" ran around the course for the Marine Corps Marathon. It says the lawyers had no current plans for work once the park closes. It also states Reyes earlier prohibited the administration from removing trees from the golf course and launched a distinct probe on whether officials in the administration deceived the court and broke professional ethics rules.
She warned DOJ lawyers of severe consequences if they mislead her or try to destroy documents about the renovation.
Which side made the stronger case?
We will email you when the story continues. At most one email a day.
All sources: 40 articles from 26 outlets
Liberal (16)
- CBS News: Federal judge blocks Trump from closing historic D.C. golf course, for now
- HuffPost: Judge Temporarily Blocks Trump From Moving Ahead On Washington Public Golf Course Redevelopment
- La Opinión: Una jueza federal suspende cierre de parque vinculado a proyecto de golf de Donald Trump
- MS NOW: Judge temporarily blocks Trump’s push to overhaul municipal golf course in D.C.
- NBC News: Judge temporarily blocks Trump’s plan to redevelop East Potomac golf course in D.C.
- NPR: How the East Potomac golf course became a D.C. landmark — and what could happen to it
- NPR: Judge temporarily blocks Trump from moving ahead on Washington public golf course redevelopment
- NPR: The government says it will close a beloved D.C. park Sunday. Will a judge step in?
- PBS NewsHour: Trump blasts judge's 2-week halt to his Washington golf project and says administration will appeal
- PBS NewsHour: Judge temporarily blocks Trump from moving ahead on D.C. public golf course redevelopment
- The Boston Globe: Trump administration signals plan for seawall work at Washington golf course as legal fight drags on
- The Boston Globe: Judge temporarily blocks Trump from moving ahead on Washington public golf course redevelopment
- The Daily Beast: Judge Smashes Trump’s Golf Course Dream Into the Rough
- The Guardian: US judge blocks Trump’s plan to renovate historic DC golf course
- Yahoo News: Judge temporarily blocks Trump from moving ahead on golf course redevelopment
Center (13)
- BBC News: Judge temporarily blocks Trump from closing Washington DC golf course for renovation
- Deseret News: Trump, D.C. golf course fight centers on access
- Newsweek: East Potomac Gives Away Clubs For Free as Golfers Defy Trump Closure
- Newsweek: Judge Blocks Trump Administration From Closing Park in Golf Course Battle
- The Hill: Trump fumes after judge blocks DC golf takeover while courses sit empty
- The Hill: Trump says Interior will appeal ruling delaying golf course renovations
- The Hill: Federal judge temporarily blocks Trump administration from closing East Potomac Park
- The Hill: Fate of Trump's DC golf course makeover at East Potomac Park hangs before federal judge
- The Seattle Times: Judge temporarily blocks Trump from moving ahead on Washington public golf course redevelopment
- The Wall Street Journal: Trump Administration Can’t Close D.C. Golf Course for Now, Judge Rules
- The Wall Street Journal: A federal judge temporarily barred the Trump administration from closing a Washington, D.C. public golf course to begin work on an extensive overhaul that the president has touted
- UPI: Trump says Interior will appeal ruling keeping East Potomac Park open
- UPI: Judge temporarily blocks Trump's plan to close D.C. golf course
Conservative (11)
- Breitbart News: Biden-Appointed Judge Stops Closure of D.C. Golf Course Trump Wants Renovated
- Just the News: Trump says he will appeal judge’s decision to halt ‘Trash Island’ DC golf course renovations
- Just the News: Federal judge blocks effort to close DC-area golf course so Trump can renovate
- New York Post: Federal judge blocks Trump from moving ahead on Washington public golf course redevelopment
- RedState: Judge Reyes Keeps Trump's Golf Course Open to the Public, but Not Necessarily for Golf
- The Epoch Times: Judge Blocks Trump Administration From Closing East Potomac Park
- The Washington Times: Trump administration signals plan for seawall work at Washington golf course as legal fight drags on
- The Washington Times: 'She hates Trump': President unloads on judge who is blocking East Potomac golf course renovation
- The Washington Times: Judge blocks Trump from shutting down East Potomac Park to pursue his golf course renovation
- Washington Examiner: Judge temporarily blocks Trump’s redevelopment of DC golf course
- Washington Examiner: Federal judge grills Trump administration on sudden upcoming closure of East Potomac Park
The evening briefing by email
One email a day, around 8:30 p.m. New York time: the seven main stories, each with its three sides, and the blind spot of the day. Unsubscribe with one tap.
A Telegram channel is coming soon.