ABRAnews Open the whole story. Sign in

Judge extends block on Trump's planned triumphal arch near Arlington cemetery by two weeks

Judge Tanya Chutkan keeps the order in place while she weighs a longer-term injunction, as Virginia, D.C. and Kennedy relatives challenge the project.

Judge Tanya Chutkan in 2022
Judge Tanya Chutkan in 2022. Photo: United States District Court for the District of Columbia, Public domain, Wikimedia Commons
Published 1 min read
Overview

On Wednesday, Nov. 18, a federal judge extended her order blocking the Trump administration from starting construction on a 250-foot triumphal arch near Arlington National Cemetery in Washington. U.S. District Judge Tanya Chutkan added 14 days to the , which was due to expire Thursday. It now holds into early December, or until she rules on a request for a longer-term injunction, whichever is earlier.

Chutkan said nothing significant had changed in the litigation since she first issued the order on Nov. 5, shortly after the National Capital Planning Commission approved the arch in an 8-4 vote. Four lawsuits oppose the project, and three are consolidated before Chutkan. Three veterans and an architectural historian sued in February.

The District of Columbia and Virginia filed Oct. 31, and Kennedy family members filed Nov. 10, citing relatives buried at Arlington. The Arlington Board sued separately in federal court in the Eastern District of Virginia. Plaintiffs argue the administration needs approval from .

The administration says Congress opened the way for a monument at Memorial Circle decades ago.

Key figures
  • 14 dayslength of the extension of the restraining orderThe Seattle Times
  • 8-4planning commission vote giving the arch final approvalThe Seattle Times
  • 250-footheight of the planned archThe Seattle Times
  • four lawsuitsfiled against the arch, three of them consolidatedNew York Post
  • 57%of Americans oppose the arch and 22% support it, in a poll The Washington Post reportedUPI

Three sides of the story

14 news outlets reported this

Tap a color or swipe sideways to switch sides.

Liberal5 outlets

The extended order and the lawsuits against the arch

HuffPost runs an Associated Press report that opens with the extension: Chutkan "temporarily extended" the order keeping the Trump administration from breaking ground on the arch. It walks through the lawsuits, from the veterans' original case to the Kennedy family's Nov. 10 filing, and notes the planning commission's 8-4 approval over dozens of opposing witnesses. Critics, including the plaintiffs, argue Congress must approve the arch, while the administration says Congress cleared the way for a monument at Memorial Circle decades ago. The same text ran at The Seattle Times and the New York Post.

ABC News headlines the judge extending the temporary restraining order and notes the original was set to expire Thursday. The New York Times calls it a "Triumphal Arch" and says Chutkan barred the government from beginning work for another two weeks.

Center3 outlets

The court order, the plaintiffs and public opinion

The Seattle Times, in a piece of its own, leads with the judge keeping the block in place and describes a five-page order in which Chutkan sees good reason to preserve the status quo. It calls the arch one of Trump's few Washington ideas with no work begun in earnest, while the White House, the Kennedy Center and the Lincoln Memorial reflecting pool projects are underway. UPI quotes her finding of "good cause" and adds a poll reported by The Washington Post, with 22% in support and 57% opposed.

It sets that beside Trump's remark that the arch is popular with "the real people, not, you know, the paid protestors." The Hill reports that Chutkan, an Obama appointee, extended the block through at least the first week of December. The Seattle Times also ran the AP text, which quotes a Public Citizen attorney as "gratified" by the pause.

Conservative6 outlets

The extended ban and the dispute over Congress

The Epoch Times leads with the judge extending the "temporary ban" through Dec. 3 and says she could rule earlier on the injunction motions. It quotes Rep. Don Beyer, a Virginia Democrat: "We will keep fighting Trump's vanity arch for as long as it takes." It adds the Kennedy family's grave-site objections and Trump's plan to dedicate the arch to military veterans.

The Washington Examiner calls Chutkan "Obama-appointed" and says she must decide whether Congress must authorize the project, a question the administration disputes, citing a 1925 statute. It adds that the justified the project on national security grounds, suggesting a military facility with drones, snipers and munitions, and that a Virginia judge is set to hear the Arlington County case Friday. The Washington Times says Chutkan "renewed her blockade" with another two-week pause.

The New York Post ran the AP text.

Where outlets disagree
All sources: 15 articles from 14 outlets

Liberal (5)

Center (4)

Conservative (6)

Injunction

A court order that stops a government or a company from doing something, or makes it act, often while the case is being decided. A temporary restraining order is the quick, short version.

All terms →
County

A division of a state, the main unit of local government. Counties run local courts, the sheriff and the count of votes in elections.

All terms →
Congress

The US parliament: the Senate and the House of Representatives. A bill becomes law when both pass it and the president signs it.

All terms →
Justice Department

The federal ministry that prosecutes federal crimes. The FBI is part of it, and its head is the Attorney General.

All terms →