Judge limits Agriculture Secretary's religious emails to staff, citing First Amendment
Judge Trina Thompson says Rollins' emails to 100,000 USDA employees could coerce them, and the USDA gave no reply when asked to comment.

A federal judge in San Francisco ruled Thursday against religious emails sent by Agriculture Secretary Brooke Rollins to all USDA employees. U.S. District Judge Trina Thompson granted a preliminary and found the messages likely violated the 's Establishment Clause. Rollins had written from her official account on holidays including Independence Day, Thanksgiving, Christmas and Easter, with Christian messages.
She did not mark other religions' holidays. Thompson pointed to Rollins' position of authority and said employees cannot realistically opt out of reading her emails. When communicating religious messages, Rollins must now stop if a colleague asks her to, may not make the workplace hostile through persistent unwelcome advances, and may not use official authority to pressure subordinates.
Those limits come from a USDA policy Rollins herself adopted. She may still discuss her faith with interested colleagues and politely invite co-workers to religious events. Courthouse News reports that the ruling runs 21 pages, that the injunction also covers employees who are not parties to the case, and that Thompson dismissed the plaintiffs' Administrative Procedure Act claim.
Six USDA employees and the National Federation of Federal Employees sued in May. Asked for comment, the USDA did not reply.
- 100,000USDA employees who received Rollins' emailsThe Guardian
- 19,000USDA workers represented by the National Federation of Federal EmployeesThe Guardian
- 21-pagelength of the judge's rulingCourthouse News
Three sides of the story
10 news outlets reported this · Little coverage from conservative outlets
Tap a color or swipe sideways to switch sides.
Liberal5 outlets
A judge telling Rollins to stop proselytizing staff
HuffPost opens by saying Rollins repeatedly sends staff openly Christian messages, and that "a federal judge is telling her to knock it off." It quotes her December Christmas note and her April Easter note to "Team USDA," and the plaintiffs' complaint, which says employees felt "coerced, unwelcome, excluded." Ashley Miller, a USDA employee among the plaintiffs, says they were "heartened and relieved."
HuffPost also names the plaintiffs' lawyers, Americans United for Separation of Church and State and Democracy Forward. The Guardian leads with the ruling that the emails were unconstitutional. It says Rollins sent Christian messages and images on holidays but none for other religions, and that Thompson pointed to her authority and her official account.
The Guardian runs the same text as The Seattle Times.
Center4 outlets
The judge's reasoning and Rollins' own policy
The Seattle Times, in the same text The Guardian runs, leads with the ruling that Rollins' emails to 100,000 employees were unconstitutional and that she must be careful to avoid proselytizing. Courthouse News opens with how Rollins began sending holiday emails invoking Christianity soon after taking office, then walks through the 21-page ruling. It quotes Thompson: "The buck stops with Secretary Rollins."
It reports that she dismissed the Administrative Procedure Act claim, and carries a statement from Rachel Laser of Americans United for Separation of Church and State. Reason quotes the judge's order and Rollins' Easter email at length, along with the plaintiffs' allegations. The Hill's headline says the judge found Rollins' messages "likely violated" the First Amendment, and it reports that four holiday-related emails prompted the lawsuit filed in May.
- The Seattle Times: Judge says agriculture secretary’s religious emails were unconstitutional
- Courthouse News: Judge blocks USDA secretary from sending religious emails from official account
- Reason: Expressly Christian Messages by Secretary of Agriculture to Employees Violated Establishment Clause,
- The Hill: Judge says Rollins' religious holiday messages likely violated First Amendment
Conservative1 outlet
A judge telling Rollins to cool it
The Washington Times headline says a judge ordered Agriculture Secretary Brooke Rollins to "cool it" with Christmas and Easter messages.
- The Washington Times: Judge orders Agriculture secretary to cool it with Christmas, Easter messages
Which side made the stronger case?
We will email you when the story continues. At most one email a day.
All sources: 11 articles from 10 outlets
Liberal (6)
- ABC News: Judge says agriculture secretary's religious emails were unconstitutional
- HuffPost: Judge Orders Trump’s Agriculture Secretary To Stop Sending Everyone Religious Emails
- HuffPost: Court Rules USDA Secretary's Religious Emails Were Unconstitutional
- The Guardian: Religious messages agriculture secretary emailed to staff deemed unconstitutional
- Yahoo News: Judge rules USDA chief's religious emails to 100,000 workers unconstitutional
Center (4)
- Courthouse News: Judge blocks USDA secretary from sending religious emails from official account
- Reason: Expressly Christian Messages by Secretary of Agriculture to Employees Violated Establishment Clause,
- The Hill: Judge says Rollins' religious holiday messages likely violated First Amendment
- The Seattle Times: Judge says agriculture secretary’s religious emails were unconstitutional
Conservative (1)
- The Washington Times: Judge orders Agriculture secretary to cool it with Christmas, Easter messages
The evening briefing by email
One email a day, around 8:30 p.m. New York time: the seven main stories, each with its three sides, and the blind spot of the day. Unsubscribe with one tap.
A Telegram channel is coming soon.