ABRAnews Open the whole story. Sign in

Federal judge strikes down Trump rule capping foreign students' stays at four years

Judge F. Dennis Saylor finds the rule arbitrary and beyond the authority Congress gave Homeland Security, in a suit by education groups and unions.

Published 1 min readMoney and daily life
Overview

A federal judge in Boston overturned a Trump administration rule that would have capped how long international students can stay in the United States. U.S. District Judge F. Dennis Saylor vacated the Department of rule on Monday, Nov. 16. DHS issued it in July.

The rule would have ended the longstanding "duration of status" system. Most F and J visa holders, meaning students and exchange visitors, would have been admitted for no more than four years. Students in longer degree programs and others needing more time would have had to seek an extension.

Saylor found the rule arbitrary and capricious and beyond the authority gave the agency. A coalition of higher education groups and labor unions sued in August. The rule was due to take effect in September, and Saylor temporarily blocked it that month.

DHS had said the rule was intended to combat visa abuse and strengthen national security. The Epoch Times reports the ruling is a final judgment in the case. Miriam Feldblum, who leads plaintiff group the Presidents' Alliance on Higher Education and Immigration, described the ruling as "a clear and important victory" for international students and scholars.

Key figures
  • four yearsmaximum initial stay the rule set for most F and J visa holdersNewsweek
  • eight-page orderlength of the judge's order, per The Epoch TimesThe Epoch Times

Three sides of the story

7 news outlets reported this · Little coverage from liberal outlets

Tap a color or swipe sideways to switch sides.

Liberal1 outlet

The judge's block and warnings about student impact

The Boston Globe, in a short breaking report, opens with the Boston judge blocking the plan and calls the proposed change "unlawful" in Saylor's view. It describes the rule as one that would have limited the years international students could study in the US and required an extension request after four years. The paper gives space to what higher education leaders and immigration lawyers said: that the change was unnecessary, would deter enrollment and would critically affect current students, especially doctoral candidates trying to finish their degrees.

It notes the August lawsuit by nonprofits and unions. The one quote is Saylor's: "Put bluntly, DHS is seeking to prevent or discourage the very activity." The Globe marks the report as a breaking story to be updated.

Center1 outlet

A rule tossed out as arbitrary and unauthorized

Newsweek reports a federal judge has voided the rule, which it says would have capped how long many foreign students could stay and forced some to get government clearance before finishing studies. It reports that Saylor found the rule "arbitrary and capricious" and beyond the authority Congress gave the agency. Most of the piece explains the mechanics: the "duration of status" system the rule would have replaced, the four-year limit for most F and J visa holders, extensions for longer programs and new limits on changing programs or pursuing certain additional degrees.

It lays out the timeline, from the July rule and a September start date to the August lawsuit and a temporary block in September. Newsweek marks it as a developing story.

Conservative5 outlets

The court's finding and DHS's stated case against the loophole

The Epoch Times leads with the judge vacating the final rule, then gives DHS's case in its own words, which describe a "duration of status" loophole letting students stay indefinitely. It quotes DHS Secretary Markwayne Mullin from July and DHS General Counsel James Percival, who said in a September post on X that the earlier ruling meant must permit "rampant abuse." It sets out Saylor's reasoning: DHS did not weigh costs and benefits or consider less burdensome measures, and its national security and fraud reasons did not support the rule.

It quotes Saylor that the statute "simply does not grant DHS such broad and open-ended authority." Miriam Feldblum of the Presidents' Alliance, a plaintiff, has the last word. A second Epoch Times version carries the eight-page order's quote.

Money and daily life

International students and exchange visitors on F and J visas keep the current "duration of status" system, which Newsweek says generally lets them remain while they comply with their visa conditions. They do not face the rule's four-year limit and extension applications. Newsweek reports the rule would have required some students to seek government approval to finish their studies.

All sources: 9 articles from 7 outlets

Liberal (1)

Center (1)

Conservative (7)

DHS (Department of Homeland Security)

The federal ministry in charge of borders and immigration enforcement. ICE, CBP and USCIS belong to it, as do the Coast Guard, the Secret Service and the disaster agency FEMA.

All terms →
Congress

The US parliament: the Senate and the House of Representatives. A bill becomes law when both pass it and the president signs it.

All terms →
ICE

Immigration and Customs Enforcement: the federal agency that arrests, detains and deports people who are in the US without legal status.

All terms →