US charges Irish man with destroying a $60 million US military plane in Ireland
A fundraiser by his self-described friends says he protested the US war with Iran and US support for Israel's war in Gaza.

Federal prosecutors in Manhattan unsealed an indictment on Tuesday, Nov. 17, charging Daithi O'Corrain, 48, an Irish man, with destroying US government property in an April 11 incident at Shannon Airport in County Clare, Ireland. Prosecutors say he broke the lock on the rear crew door of a US Air National Guard C-130 Hercules parked on a taxiway and barricaded himself inside. They say he cut hydraulic lines, crimped a liquid oxygen line, smashed every gauge in the cockpit and poured ball bearings into the fuel tanks.
Crew members who returned hours later saw him through a cockpit window and alerted airport security. Irish police arrested him. Prosecutors say the plane, worth about $60 million, is inoperable and will not fly again.
They also say he spent months preparing and ordered gallium capsules, a substance that can eat into steel and degrade aluminum. FBI New York head James Barnacle said: "This was not an act of spontaneous vandalism." O'Corrain is not in US custody and no arraignment date is set.
He faces up to 10 years in prison if convicted. In Ireland he was charged with criminal damage and trespassing. An online fundraiser by people calling themselves his friends says he protested the US war with Iran and US support for Israel's war in Gaza.
- $60 millionvalue of the C-130 Hercules, per prosecutorsCBS News
- up to 10 years in prisonmaximum penalty if O'Corrain is convictedCBS News
Three sides of the story
22 news outlets reported this
Tap a color or swipe sideways to switch sides.
Liberal9 outlets
The axe attack and the motive his supporters cite
The Guardian opens with an "axe-wielding man" who breached a security perimeter and destroyed a US military plane, as US prosecutors said. It adds that supporters describe him as an independent peace activist and that a fundraiser by people calling themselves his friends tied the act to the US war with Iran and US support for Israel's war in Gaza. CBS News runs a text also carried by The Seattle Times, headlined "Man with ax destroys $60M U.S. military plane, prosecutors say."
It quotes fundraiser organizer Tracey Ryan, who called the act "an inspiring act of direct action," and notes several earlier security breaches at Shannon. The Independent frames it around the Justice Department announcement, under the headline "Irish man indicted for allegedly destroying $60 million US military aircraft," and notes he is also known as David Curran. All three carry the FBI's line that it was "not an act of spontaneous vandalism," and The Guardian and CBS add Manhattan US Attorney Jamie McDonald's warning that such attacks "will not be tolerated."
Center6 outlets
The Justice Department's account of a planned attack
UPI's headline says the Justice Department charges an Irish national, and its report follows the department's account, including the FBI's description of "a deliberate, planned attack" and a series of similar incidents at the airport. Courthouse News headlines "effectively destroyed," cites a 12-page indictment and quotes McDonald's "clear and powerful message." It also says the government did not address a motive, that a crowdfunding campaign called the act "inspiring," and that he reportedly has since secured bail in Ireland.
The Seattle Times runs the same text as CBS News, opening with the ax-wielding man and ending with Shannon's earlier breaches. NewsNation's headline, "Irish man indicted for destroying US military aircraft: DOJ," says federal officials reported that he breached the airport's security perimeter.
- UPI: Justice Department charges Irish national for damaging U.S. military jet
- Courthouse News: Feds say Irish man ‘effectively destroyed’ $60 million Air Force jet
- The Seattle Times: Man destroyed $60M U.S. military plane at Irish airport, prosecutors say
- NewsNation: Irish man indicted for destroying US military aircraft: DOJ
Conservative7 outlets
The charges and the FBI's planned-attack line
Just the News headlines its piece "Federal prosecutors indict Irish national for destroying U.S. Air National Guard C-130H." It reports that Daithi O’Corrain is accused of breaking into and destroying the aircraft at Shannon Airport in County Clare, Ireland, and that Jamie McDonald, the US Attorney for the Southern District of New York, announced the charges Tuesday. It then quotes FBI Assistant Director in Charge James Barnacle Jr., who describes "a deliberate, planned attack against a U.S. military aircraft" and says the defendant allegedly spent months researching the aircraft.
The Washington Times headlines "DOJ says Irish man 'destroyed' $60 million U.S. military plane in runway attack." It reports that prosecutors announced charges Tuesday against a man they say "effectively destroyed" the plane through an ax attack and a corrosive substance.
- Conservative outlets did not mentionAn online fundraiser by people calling themselves his friends links the act to the US war with Iran and, separately, to US support for Israel's war in Gaza Reported by The Guardian, CBS News, The Seattle Times, Courthouse News
- Conservative outlets did not mentionO'Corrain is not in US custody and no arraignment date has been set Reported by The Guardian, CBS News, The Seattle Times
Which side made the stronger case?
We will email you when the story continues. At most one email a day.
All sources: 23 articles from 22 outlets
Liberal (9)
- ABC News: US Military jet wrecked while parked in Irish airport: Feds
- Al Jazeera English: Prosecutors allege man ‘destroyed’ US military plane at Irish airport
- CBS News: Man with ax destroys $60M U.S. military plane, prosecutors say
- MS NOW: Irish man charged with destroying U.S. military aircraft with axe
- The Guardian: Man accused of destroying US military plane at Shannon airport in Ireland
- The Independent: Irish man indicted for allegedly destroying $60 million US military aircraft at Shannon Airport
- Time: Irish Man Charged With Destroying U.S. Military Plane Becomes Protest Symbol
- Yahoo News: Man with axe accused of destroying $60 million U.S. military plane in Ireland
Center (6)
- BBC News: Irishman charged with destroying US military aircraft with axe
- Courthouse News: Feds say Irish man ‘effectively destroyed’ $60 million Air Force jet
- NewsNation: Irish man indicted for destroying US military aircraft: DOJ
- Newsweek: Photos Show Damage to $60M US Military Aircraft As Irish National Charged
- The Seattle Times: Man destroyed $60M U.S. military plane at Irish airport, prosecutors say
- UPI: Justice Department charges Irish national for damaging U.S. military jet
Conservative (8)
- Daily Caller: ‘Peace Activist’ Allegedly Hacks Apart $60 Million American Military Plane In Ireland
- Fox News: Hometown of accused US military plane saboteur is a known magnet for anti-Israel activism
- Fox News: Irish activist indicted in US over alleged destruction of $60M military plane
- Just the News: Federal prosecutors indict Irish national for destroying U.S. Air National Guard C-130H
- New York Post: Anti-Israel activist allegedly destroyed $60 million US military aircraft at Irish airport: feds
- The Washington Times: DOJ says Irish man 'destroyed' $60 million U.S. military plane in runway attack
- Townhall: Irish Man Charged in US With Destroying $60 Million Military Aircraft at Shannon Airport
- Washington Examiner: Man arrested after allegedly destroying US military C-130 at Irish airport
The evening briefing by email
One email a day, around 8:30 p.m. New York time: the seven main stories, each with its three sides, and the blind spot of the day. Unsubscribe with one tap.
A Telegram channel is coming soon.