UK investigates whether Russell Brand broke prison rules with message from jail
His wife read a statement saying "I am not guilty" on their YouTube show, and the prime minister's spokesperson calls it "clearly appalling."
Britain's Ministry of Justice is investigating whether Russell Brand broke prison rules after a message from him was read on his family's YouTube channel. His wife, Laura Brand, read it on the Nov. 15 episode of "Sunday Service with the Brands." In it, Brand, 51, said he is not guilty of the offenses for which he was jailed.
He also said he had been moved from Wandsworth prison to HMP Littlehey in Cambridgeshire, which he called the biggest sex offenders' prison in Europe. Brand was convicted at Southwark crown court on Nov. 5 on four counts: one of rape and three of sexual assault. On Nov. 9, he was sentenced to 10 years and six months.
The prime minister's official spokesperson said the matter is being "urgently investigated" and that the government expects action if he broke the rules. Prisoners are forbidden from issuing statements that distress victims, and contact with journalists is permitted only in exceptional circumstances, the spokesperson said. Foreign Secretary Ed Miliband told Sky News the comments were "revolting" and showed no remorse.
The Guardian reports that prison sources say the rules may need updating to stop prisoners' comments reaching profit-making YouTube channels.
- 10 years and six monthsBrand's prison sentence for rape and sexual assaultDaily Caller
- Six peoplecame forward with similar allegations after sentencing, per the Daily CallerDaily Caller
Three sides of the story
7 news outlets reported this
Tap a color or swipe sideways to switch sides.
Liberal3 outlets
Official investigation and condemnation of Brand's jail message
The Guardian leads with the Ministry of Justice opening an investigation into whether Brand broke prison rules after his wife read his message claiming he is not guilty. It quotes the prime minister's official spokesperson calling the matter "clearly appalling" and Foreign Secretary Ed Miliband calling the comments "revolting" and "disgusting." It adds that prison sources say rules may need updating for profit-making YouTube channels.
The Daily Beast headlines its piece "Disgraced MAGA Comedian's Prison Plea Backfires Immediately" and calls Brand a "comedian-turned-all-MAGA preacher." It sets out the same official statements, including that prisoners "cannot get around these rules by having someone else publish their comments," and cites the Guardian on how the rules treat messages meant for publication. It also quotes the message's lines about Littlehey prison and about Christ.
NBC News runs a video segment titled "U.K. authorities investigating if Russell Brand's message from prison violates rules" and lists a separate report on his rape and sexual assault sentence of 10 years and six months.
Center2 outlets
Investigation into Brand's prison statement and his denial
NewsNation's headline says the UK is investigating Russell Brand over an "appalling" prison statement, and its report says officials are checking whether he broke prison regulations by sending a message he knew would reach the public. The Hill and NewsNation also carry a report headlined "Russell Brand declares 'I am not guilty' in new statement from prison." It says he was sentenced to 10.5 years after being convicted of rape and sexual assault.
Conservative2 outlets
Laura Brand's silence broken, accusers and public backlash
The Daily Caller leads with Laura Brand "breaking her silence" in a long Nov. 15 episode, leaning on her faith and promising the show will continue. It reports she shared a pre-taped conversation from the trial and then Russell's message saying he is not guilty. It gives space to online reaction, including one user's "How about some humility?" and another's claim that the broadcast was illegal.
It also notes that six people made similar allegations after sentencing and are being vetted. Breitbart News pairs Laura Brand's return with accuser Mia Latter identifying herself that same weekend and notes that Latter's allegations were not part of the criminal case behind his conviction. Citing TheWrap, it reports that Latter, now 37, alleges an oral rape when she was 16 and he was 30.
She told The Sunday Times she wants a staggered age of consent. Breitbart also quotes Brand's message from prison: "Please support my treasured wife and family."
- Conservative outlets did not mentionThe official investigation into whether Brand's message broke prison rules Reported by The Guardian, The Daily Beast, NBC News, NewsNation
Which side made the stronger case?
We will email you when the story continues. At most one email a day.
All sources: 10 articles from 7 outlets
Liberal (3)
- NBC News: U.K. authorities investigating if Russell Brand's message from prison violates rules
- The Daily Beast: Disgraced MAGA Comedian’s Prison Plea Backfires Immediately
- The Guardian: Ministry of Justice investigating Russell Brand message from prison claiming he is not guilty
Center (3)
- NewsNation: UK investigates Russell Brand over ‘appalling’ prison statement
- NewsNation: Russell Brand declares 'I am not guilty' in new statement from prison
- The Hill: Russell Brand declares 'I am not guilty' in new statement from prison
Conservative (4)
- Breitbart News: Nolte: British PM Wants Russell Brand Punished for Claiming He’s Innocent
- Breitbart News: Russell Brand's Wife Breaks Silence After Rape Conviction as Accuser Publicly Identifies Herself
- Daily Caller: Britain Investigates Russell Brand For Saying He’s Innocent Because It Might Upset His Victims
- Daily Caller: Russell Brand’s Wife Breaks Silence By Reading His Jailhouse Message
The evening briefing by email
One email a day, around 8:30 p.m. New York time: the seven main stories, each with its three sides, and the blind spot of the day. Unsubscribe with one tap.
A Telegram channel is coming soon.