ABRAnews Open the whole story. Sign in

Trump urges reversal of Newsom's plan to commute California death sentences

Trump's Saturday Truth Social post cites 563 inmates, but Newsom's office counts 548, and the state Supreme Court must still approve many commutations.

Published 1 min read
Overview

President Donald Trump on Saturday attacked California Gov. Gavin Newsom's plan to , calling it "a disaster for Justice in America" in a Truth Social post. He wrote that he hopes the decision will be overturned and said the governor was "so incompetent and insensitive." Trump's post put the number of inmates at 563.

Newsom announced on Nov. 5 that he intends to commute the sentences to life in prison without the possibility of . Newsweek reports that his office identified 548 recipients and that the commutations have not yet taken effect. For 382 of them, a governor needs a recommendation from at least four state justices.

Newsom, who is term-limited, has requested that the court act by year's end. The Criminal Justice Legal Foundation says it intends to pursue "every legal challenge available." According to the New York Post, Orange Todd Spitzer is petitioning the state Supreme Court to halt the commutations.

U.S. Attorney General Todd Blanche, at a briefing Thursday, called the move "unfortunate." Victims' relatives are divided, and La Opinión reports that at least 50 of them asked the court to back Newsom.

Key figures
  • 548 peopledeath sentences Newsom plans to commute, per his officeNewsweek
  • 563inmates in Trump's post, a figure Newsweek says does not match Newsom's officeNewsweek
  • 382 of the 548 individualscases needing a recommendation from at least four state Supreme Court justicesNewsweek
  • nearly 30 percentcut in the national death-row population if approved, per NewsweekNewsweek
  • $150 millones anualesminimum yearly savings estimated by Newsom's administration, per La OpiniónLa Opinión

Three sides of the story

12 news outlets reported this

Tap a color or swipe sideways to switch sides.

Liberal6 outlets

Trump's attack set against Newsom's supporters and savings

La Opinión opens with Trump's criticism of Newsom and his Truth Social post, in which he again used a derogatory nickname for the Democratic governor, a possible 2028 presidential contender. It reports Trump's call for the decision to be reversed and his argument that it wounds victims' families. The outlet then turns to the measure itself: Newsom announced it on Nov. 5, replacing with life in prison without parole, after a moratorium begun in March 2019.

It reports that at least 50 relatives of homicide victims asked the state Supreme Court to back the governor, and that UN rapporteur Morris Tidball-Binz supported the measure. Newsom's administration estimates savings of at least $150 million a year, La Opinión says, while the police chiefs' group PORAC says the decision reopens families' wounds. The piece closes by noting that more than 1,700 people have received or commutations in Trump's second term, including defendants accused of assaulting officers at the Capitol on Jan. 6, 2021.

Center3 outlets

Trump's attack, the plan's details and legal hurdles

Newsweek headlines Trump's attack, "Disaster for Justice," and notes that his figure of 563 does not match the 548 recipients identified by Newsom's office. It then lays out the plan: 529 men and 19 women, no releases, no pardons, no parole, and, if approved, it would be the biggest batch of death sentence commutations in U.S. history. It quotes Newsom saying, "These offenders will die in prison but not by our hand."

Newsweek stresses that the commutations have not yet taken effect, since 382 of the cases need a recommendation from at least four state Supreme Court justices. It gives space to the Criminal Justice Legal Foundation, Los Angeles County District Attorney Nathan Hochman and Attorney General Todd Blanche, who compares the move to Joe Biden's federal commutations and says, "It's unfortunate." It closes with the long Trump-Newsom feud and the failed September execution of Christa Pike in Tennessee.

Conservative3 outlets

Victims' families and the killers Newsom would spare

Townhall's headline has Trump blasting Newsom "for Sparing California's Worst Killers." It adds that Trump said some inmates make Hannibal Lecter "look like a nice guy," then quotes Newsom's letter calling state-sanctioned killing "incompatible with California's values." Townhall names three inmates whose sentences it says Newsom commuted, Randy Kraft, Richard Allen Davis and Marcus Wesson, and describes their crimes.

It also argues there is irony in Newsom's appeal to California's values given the state's abortion laws. The New York Post calls Newsom's move "controversial" and says these were Trump's first remarks on it. It quotes Marc Klaas, whose 12-year-old daughter Polly was kidnapped and found murdered, saying her killer Davis is getting "this gift of life."

It also quotes Criminal Justice Legal Foundation head Anne Marie Schubert: "Clemency is an extraordinary act of mercy." Per the Post, Orange County District Attorney Todd Spitzer said he is pressing the state Supreme Court to halt the commutations.

What a side did not mention
  • Liberal outlets did not mentionThe Criminal Justice Legal Foundation plans legal challenges before the California Supreme Court Reported by Newsweek, New York Post
  • Conservative outlets did not mentionChrista Pike's failed execution in Tennessee on Sept. 30 Reported by La Opinión, Newsweek
  • Centrist outlets did not mentionNewsom's administration estimates savings of at least $150 million a year, and a UN rapporteur backed the move Reported by La Opinión
Where outlets disagree
All sources: 16 articles from 12 outlets

Liberal (7)

Center (3)

Conservative (6)

Clemency and commutation

Mercy a president or governor grants a convicted person. A commutation shortens the sentence but the conviction stands, a pardon forgives the crime, and a reprieve only delays the punishment.

All terms →
Probation and parole

Two ways of serving a sentence outside prison under supervision: probation is ordered instead of prison, parole is early release from it. Breaking the conditions can mean prison.

All terms →
Supreme Court

The highest US court: nine justices, appointed for life by the president with the Senate's approval. Its rulings bind every other court.

All terms →
County

A division of a state, the main unit of local government. Counties run local courts, the sheriff and the count of votes in elections.

All terms →
District attorney and US attorney

A district attorney is the local prosecutor, usually elected, who brings charges under state law. A US attorney is the federal prosecutor for a district, appointed by the president, who brings federal charges.

All terms →
Justice Department

The federal ministry that prosecutes federal crimes. The FBI is part of it, and its head is the Attorney General.

All terms →
Death row and lethal injection

Where prisoners sentenced to death wait, often for years, while their appeals are heard. The death penalty exists in about half the states and under federal law, and lethal injection is the usual method.

All terms →
Pardon

The president forgives a federal crime and cancels the punishment. For crimes under state law the governor does it in most states.

All terms →