ABRAnews Open the whole story. Sign in

Supreme Court declines to hear challenge to Maryland limits on carrying guns in public

Justice Clarence Thomas agrees with the decision but writes of "serious doubts" about many of the restrictions and says the court should take a narrower case later.

The U.S. Supreme Court building in Washington in 2024
The U.S. Supreme Court building in Washington in 2024. Photo: 颐园居, CC BY-SA 4.0, Wikimedia Commons
Published 1 min readMoney and daily life
Overview

The on Monday, Nov. 16, declined to hear a challenge to Maryland laws that limit where people can carry guns in public. The case, Novotny v. Moore, was brought by Maryland residents and gun rights groups.

The laws bar guns in places such as schools, mass transit, parks, bars and healthcare facilities, and some were added in 2023. The 4th Circuit had ruled that all the challenged restrictions are consistent with the , and that ruling stays in place. The court gave no reason for turning the case away.

Maryland Anthony Brown, a Democrat, had urged the justices not to take it. Justice Clarence Thomas wrote a statement agreeing with the decision because the breadth of the challenge would complicate review. But he wrote that he has "serious doubts" that the nation's tradition of firearm regulation supports many of the restrictions.

He said the court should consider such laws in a more narrowly focused case. The refusal comes before the court hears arguments on Dec. 2 over bans on AR-15 and similar rifles in Cook , Illinois, and in Connecticut.

Key figures
  • 6-3the court's conservative majorityNBC News
  • 10 categories of placestargeted in the two lawsuits against Maryland's limitsCBS News
  • four gun rights groupschallengers, along with individual Maryland residentsNBC News
  • Dec. 2date of oral arguments on AR-15 bansWashington Examiner

Three sides of the story

12 news outlets reported this

Tap a color or swipe sideways to switch sides.

Liberal4 outlets

Thomas's doubts and what the ruling leaves

MS NOW leads with Thomas, saying he has "serious doubts" about bans on carrying guns in sensitive places such as mass transit and hospitals. It says his statement adds to his standing as the justice most strongly committed to gun rights, and adds that Thomas and Justice Samuel Alito have faced retirement speculation, especially since Democrats won a majority. NBC News leads with the refusal itself, saying the court "sidestepped a chance" to define a sensitive place and the Maryland rules remain.

It quotes the challengers' lawyers calling Maryland officials "openly hostile" to gun rights and Attorney General Anthony Brown pointing to "vast areas of shared consensus." CBS News lays out the case's path through a federal district court and the 4th Circuit, and quotes Brown's reference to a "rich American tradition" of barring guns in some places. ABC News runs the same text as The Seattle Times, with Thomas's skepticism and the coming AR-15 arguments.

Center2 outlets

Court's refusal, with Thomas eyeing a narrower case

The Seattle Times runs an Associated Press report, the same text ABC News carries. It starts with the Supreme Court refusing Monday to take up the Maryland challenge, and says the law bans concealed weapons in schools, on transit, in bars and other areas deemed sensitive. The court gave no comment, but in a separate statement Justice Clarence Thomas voiced skepticism toward Maryland's law and similar ones and said he would back revisiting the question in a "more narrowly focused case."

The report places the refusal beside the court's coming arguments over state AR-15 bans, which are often called assault weapons bans. It adds that the conservative-majority court has issued several rulings favoring Second Amendment rights, including a recent decision voiding broad limits on carrying guns in Hawaii, and has also upheld a law that shields domestic violence victims.

Conservative6 outlets

Thomas's call for review of sensitive-places laws

The Washington Examiner and The Federalist put Thomas in the headline, while The Epoch Times and Just the News headline the court's refusal, though Just the News opens with Thomas's skepticism. The Examiner says the court "punted" on sensitive-places laws, quotes Thomas saying lower courts have "largely blessed these ahistorical ventures," and notes the Dec. 2 arguments over assault weapons bans, with gun rights activists optimistic. The Federalist quotes Thomas at length, including that the Second Amendment right "admits of only historically grounded exceptions," and walks through the Bruen test.

The Epoch Times adds that Gov. Wes Moore signed the 2023 law, and quotes Attorney General Anthony Brown's filing that the laws pass the Bruen test. Just the News, by reporter Misty Severi, says the court gave no reason for the denial and that the lower court's ruling stays in place.

Money and daily life

In Maryland, the restrictions stay in force, NBC News reports. The rules cover state parks, schools, public transportation, health care sites and businesses that sell alcohol. NBC News names California, New York, New Jersey and Hawaii as other states with similarly broad limits.

All sources: 13 articles from 12 outlets

Liberal (4)

Center (2)

Conservative (7)

Supreme Court

The highest US court: nine justices, appointed for life by the president with the Senate's approval. Its rulings bind every other court.

All terms →
Appeals court

A court that reviews a lower court's decision for legal mistakes. It does not hear witnesses again, and above the federal appeals courts there is only the Supreme Court.

All terms →
Second Amendment

The part of the US Constitution on “the right of the people to keep and bear arms”. The Supreme Court reads it as a personal right to own guns while allowing some limits, and where the limits lie is fought over in court.

All terms →
Attorney General

The head of the Justice Department and the government's chief lawyer. Each state has its own attorney general too.

All terms →
County

A division of a state, the main unit of local government. Counties run local courts, the sheriff and the count of votes in elections.

All terms →
Senate

The upper chamber of Congress: 100 senators, two per state, elected for six years. It confirms judges and ministers and approves treaties.

All terms →