ABRAnews Open the whole story. Sign in

Supreme Court turns away Trump's appeal over canceled University of California research grants

The justices gave no reason and no one dissented, leaving in place a ruling that the cuts likely violated the First Amendment.

The U.S. Supreme Court building in Washington
The U.S. Supreme Court building in Washington. Photo: Photo by Mr. Kjetil Ree., CC BY-SA 3.0, Wikimedia Commons
Published 1 min read
Overview

The on Monday, Nov. 16, declined to hear the Trump administration's appeal over research grants it canceled for University of California researchers. The order came with no explanation, and no justice . It leaves in place a 9th Circuit ruling that the terminations likely violated the 's ban on viewpoint discrimination.

The grants came from the National Science Foundation and the National Endowment for the Humanities. They were cut after President Trump's in January 2025 against diversity, equity and inclusion programs. Researchers allege agencies used keyword searches for words such as "diversity" and "climate change."

Six UC researchers sued, and U.S. District Judge Rita Lin ordered grants reinstated in June 2025. The 9th Circuit upheld that order in May. Federal officials attempted to terminate $324 million of UC institutions' funding, NBC News reports, and some has resumed.

About $150 million was at issue in this appeal, according to the Los Angeles Times. D. John Sauer argued for the that the government has significant discretion over taxpayer funding. Berkeley Law Dean Erwin Chemerinsky, who urged the Court to deny the appeal, said he is delighted it did.

Key figures
  • $324 millionfunding to UC institutions the government tried to end, per NBC NewsNBC News
  • about $150 millionUC research grants at issue in the appeal, per the Los Angeles TimesLos Angeles Times
  • approximately $59 millionremaining on the grants, per the Trump administrationCBS News
  • more than $4 billionfederal grant money the UC system took in during 2024, per SauerThe Seattle Times

Three sides of the story

16 news outlets reported this

Tap a color or swipe sideways to switch sides.

Liberal8 outlets

Court leaves intact ruling against Trump's grant cuts

CBS News opens with the Court turning away the appeal and what that leaves intact: a lower court finding that the cancellations likely violated the First Amendment. It gives the Justice Department's warning that letting the ruling stand would clear the way for taxpayer money to go to DEI projects. It also cites University of California lawyers who say agencies ran keyword searches and cut more than $324 million to the system from January to June 2025.

NBC News says the Court rejected Trump's move to "abruptly" cancel funding, describes a "nationwide purge" and notes that some money has resumed. It adds that the sent the question of recouping lost funds to the Court of Federal Claims. The Los Angeles Times runs the same text as The Seattle Times.

It calls the action "a significant win for the embattled professors and a defeat for Trump" and quotes Solicitor General D. John Sauer's warning that "vast sums of taxpayer money are at stake."

Center5 outlets

Court's silent refusal, with both sides' arguments

The Seattle Times carries the Los Angeles Times text, which opens with the Court refusing the appeal "without a comment or dissent." It puts the amount at issue at about $150 million, quotes Solicitor General D. John Sauer on the taxpayer money at stake, and quotes Berkeley Law Dean Erwin Chemerinsky calling attempts to suppress a viewpoint "presumptively unconstitutional in funding." UPI leads with the rejection and sets the filings side by side.

The plaintiffs wrote that lost funding becomes "expressive harm," a "quintessential First Amendment violation." Sauer's petition argued that viewpoint neutrality does not oblige taxpayers to keep paying for projects the government decides no longer serve the public interest, even if that decision rests partly on the viewpoint the projects advance. UPI adds that researchers said the cuts may lead to lab closures and the end of projects, and that the Court gave no reason and no justice dissented.

Conservative3 outlets

Appeal declined over Trump's DEI grant cuts

The Epoch Times headlines that the Court "Allows Block on Trump's DEI Grant Cuts." It presents the cuts as part of a Trump drive to lower federal spending and pull government backing from programs on diversity and gender ideology. It traces Judge Rita Lin's June 2025 and the 9th Circuit's ruling affirming it in part.

It quotes Chemerinsky, "I am obviously delighted," and says the Justice Department did not reply to its request for comment. Just the News runs two short items. One, citing NBC News, says the ruling leaves in place decisions that the government violated First Amendment protections, and that some funding has been restored.

The other says the Monday order gave no explanation and, citing The Hill, that the Ninth Circuit found the cancellations amounted to viewpoint suppression. It adds that DEI "has become a hot-button topic," with many conservatives arguing that such programs give unfair advantages by race and promote negative narratives about white people.

What a side did not mention
  • Conservative outlets did not mentionThe appeals court said plaintiffs seeking lost funding must file in the Court of Federal Claims. Reported by NBC News, Los Angeles Times, The Seattle Times
  • Centrist outlets did not mentionU.S. District Judge Rita Lin issued the district court ruling ordering grants reinstated. Reported by CBS News, The Epoch Times
All sources: 21 articles from 16 outlets

Liberal (9)

Center (8)

Conservative (4)

Supreme Court

The highest US court: nine justices, appointed for life by the president with the Senate's approval. Its rulings bind every other court.

All terms →
Dissent

The written opinion of the judges who disagree with the court's majority. It has no legal force, but it spells out the other side and is often quoted later.

All terms →
First Amendment

The part of the US Constitution that bars the government from limiting speech, the press, religion, peaceful assembly and petitions. It restrains the government, not private companies or employers.

All terms →
Executive order

A president's written order to federal agencies. It cannot override a law passed by Congress, courts can block it, and the next president can cancel it.

All terms →
Solicitor General

The lawyer who argues the federal government's cases before the Supreme Court. The post is part of the Justice Department.

All terms →
Justice Department

The federal ministry that prosecutes federal crimes. The FBI is part of it, and its head is the Attorney General.

All terms →
Appeals court

A court that reviews a lower court's decision for legal mistakes. It does not hear witnesses again, and above the federal appeals courts there is only the Supreme Court.

All terms →
Injunction

A court order that stops a government or a company from doing something, or makes it act, often while the case is being decided. A temporary restraining order is the quick, short version.

All terms →