South Carolina board unanimously denies parole to Susan Smith, who drowned her sons
Smith, 55, was also refused in 2024, and her ex-husband David Smith urged the board to keep her imprisoned.
A South Carolina board unanimously denied parole on Thursday, Nov. 19, to Susan Smith, who killed her two young sons in 1994 by letting her car roll into John D. Long Lake. A jury convicted her and she was sentenced to life in prison. Under the state law in force then, she could ask for parole after 30 years, and every two years after that if refused.
The board also turned her down in 2024. She needed two-thirds support from its seven members and appeared by video from prison. Agency statistics show the board grants parole in only 4% of cases before it.
Smith told the board she has changed and is "very, very sorry." Her ex-husband David Smith, the boys' father, and the original prosecutors asked the board to keep her in prison. He said she acted deliberately.
Prosecutors have long argued she killed the boys because she believed they were the reason her lover ended their affair. Her defense has blamed her mental health. Smith first claimed a Black carjacker had taken her sons before she confessed.
Newsweek reports the board also received statements from citizens opposing her release.
- 4%share of cases in which the board grants parole, by agency statisticsABC News
- two-thirds supportvote share Smith needed from the boardABC News
- seven-member boardsize of the panel that decidedABC News
- 10,845 statementsopposing parole, received by the board, per NewsweekNewsweek
Three sides of the story
11 news outlets reported this
Tap a color or swipe sideways to switch sides.
Liberal3 outlets
The father's plea against release
The Independent leads with the unanimous denial and David Smith's "tearful plea" to keep his ex-wife jailed. It quotes him saying she took life "deliberately" and notes he traveled to Columbia with the original trial prosecutors. It adds that the board approves parole in just 4% of cases and calls her release chances slim.
It also recounts her 1994 carjacker story, which it says relied on a centuries-old racist trope. ABC News headlines that she was "denied parole again," in a text also run by other outlets. It gives Smith's own words, "I'm not the same person I was 32 years ago," and a psychologist, Jessie Hill, saying medication, menopause and family deaths eased her mental illness.
It quotes prosecutor Tommy Pope warning that "there are people out there that idolize Susan." Both end on the investigators' re-creation of the car sinking in six minutes.
Center5 outlets
The hearing itself, with voices from both sides
BBC News opens with the second denial and Smith's hearing words, "I got to my lowest when I let that car go into that lake." It also quotes her saying the crime did not happen "because of a man," and explains how US parole works. Newsweek builds an explainer around the hearing.
It reports 10,845 opposing statements and the testimony of David Smith's wife Tiffany and daughter Savannah. It also gives the mental health case from Dr. Jesse Hill and the opposition of Tommy Pope, Kevin Brackett and Union Sheriff Jeff Bailey. The Seattle Times ran an Associated Press text, the same one ABC News carried, ahead of the hearing, under a headline saying she would ask for parole again.
It says the odds are against her and notes the board's 4% grant rate.
- BBC News: Susan Smith denied parole again 32 years after drowning her two sons
- Newsweek: Susan Smith Denied Parole as Sons' Father Pleads To Keep Her Behind Bars
- NewsNation: Susan Smith denied parole again 32 years after drowning her sons
- The Seattle Times: Susan Smith to ask for parole again 32 years after drowning her sons in a South Carolina lake
Conservative3 outlets
The ex-husband wants her imprisoned until she dies
Fox News and the New York Post, both published the day before the hearing, lead with David Smith telling CNN he wants his ex-wife "in prison until she dies." Both quote him saying "32 years hasn't changed the heartache" and recall that he believed her carjacking story. The Post calls the killings "heinous" and describes her as a "disgraced mother."
Fox adds that the state changed the law shortly after her conviction, so life sentences for murders after Jan. 1, 1996 no longer allow parole. It also gives the defense claim of a failed suicide attempt. Just the News reports that she was denied parole Thursday morning, citing Fox News for the prosecution's theory of winning back a lover.
It recalls that she expressed regret for the crime by Zoom at her first hearing, in November 2024, quoting her: "I would give anything if I could go back and change it."
- Fox News: Susan Smith's ex-husband wants her ‘in prison until she dies’ after killing sons in alleged bid to win lover
- New York Post: Susan Smith, who drowned her 2 young boys, is up for parole — and kids’ dad wants her ‘in prison until she dies’
- Just the News: Susan Smith, who was convicted of drowning her two sons in 1995, denied parole again
- Conservative outlets did not mentionThe board's vote to deny parole was unanimous Reported by The Independent, ABC News, BBC News, Newsweek
Which side made the stronger case?
We will email you when the story continues. At most one email a day.
- Year of the murders
- Just the News: 1993
- ABC News, BBC News: 1994
All sources: 11 articles from 11 outlets
Liberal (3)
- ABC News: Susan Smith denied parole again 32 years after drowning sons in a South Carolina lake
- The Boston Globe: Susan Smith to ask for parole again 32 years after drowning her sons in a South Carolina lake
- The Independent: Susan Smith denied parole request after ex-husband’s tearful plea to keep her in jail
Center (5)
- BBC News: Susan Smith denied parole again 32 years after drowning her two sons
- NewsNation: Susan Smith denied parole again 32 years after drowning her sons
- Newsweek: Susan Smith Denied Parole as Sons' Father Pleads To Keep Her Behind Bars
- The Seattle Times: Susan Smith to ask for parole again 32 years after drowning her sons in a South Carolina lake
- UPI: Susan Smith denied parole again, 32 years after drowning sons
Conservative (3)
- Fox News: Susan Smith's ex-husband wants her ‘in prison until she dies’ after killing sons in alleged bid to win lover
- Just the News: Susan Smith, who was convicted of drowning her two sons in 1995, denied parole again
- New York Post: Susan Smith, who drowned her 2 young boys, is up for parole — and kids’ dad wants her ‘in prison until she dies’
The evening briefing by email
One email a day, around 8:30 p.m. New York time: the seven main stories, each with its three sides, and the blind spot of the day. Unsubscribe with one tap.
A Telegram channel is coming soon.