ABRAnews Open the whole story. Sign in

Senate defeats resolution directing Trump to end Iran war, 51-48

Three Republicans voted for it and Democrat John Fetterman voted against, in the first Senate vote on the war since the Nov. 3 midterms.

The U.S. Capitol in Washington
The U.S. Capitol in Washington. Photo: Architect of the Capitol, Public domain, Wikimedia Commons
Published 1 min readMoney and daily life
Overview

On Thursday, Nov. 19, the Senate rejected a measure that would have instructed President Donald Trump to stop the war in Iran or secure congressional approval to continue it. The vote was 51 to 48, largely along party lines. The House passed the measure in September, 220 to 204.

Republican Sens. Susan Collins of Maine, Lisa Murkowski of Alaska and Rand Paul of Kentucky voted yes with Democrats. Democratic Sen. John Fetterman of Pennsylvania voted no. Sen. Thom Tillis, a North Carolina Republican, had backed an earlier resolution but voted no this time.

He said the measure would not reach the president, so it only states a view of Congress. Democratic Sen. Chris Murphy of Connecticut did not vote after a stroke. It was the first Senate vote on the war since the midterm elections on Nov. 3.

The measure would have been largely symbolic. Sen. Tim Kaine, a Virginia Democrat, said the election results made the war's unpopularity clear. Sen. Tim Sheehy, a Montana Republican, said the US should finish the job.

According to Reuters, leaders of the Democratic Party, who will control both chambers next year, have promised that ending the war will be a leading goal when they assume power on Jan. 3.

Key figures
  • 51 to 48Senate vote defeating the resolutionYahoo News
  • 220-204House vote passing it in SeptemberYahoo News
  • 31%Americans who approve of the war, in a Reuters/Ipsos pollYahoo News
  • over $47 billionspent on the war, by Pentagon data in late OctoberYahoo News
  • Dec. 11government funding deadlineFox News

Three sides of the story

14 news outlets reported this

Tap a color or swipe sideways to switch sides.

Liberal5 outlets

Republicans back the war despite midterm losses

Yahoo News, running a Reuters report, opens with Republicans backing the president "weeks after sweeping defeats in midterm elections." It adds a Reuters/Ipsos poll showing 31% of Americans approve of the war and Pentagon data of over $47 billion spent. Al Jazeera English cites a Reuters/Ipsos finding that 71 percent of Americans support Congress passing legislation to end the war, and calls the resolution largely symbolic.

The Guardian says Republicans were "once again defending a conflict" tied to their losses, links the war to higher gasoline and diesel prices, and adds that Democratic Sen. Chris Murphy missed the vote after a stroke. CBS News quotes Kaine's floor speech at length and remarks Tillis gave to the network. Kaine calls the conflict an "illegal, catastrophic war," while Tillis says "this one doesn't go to the president" and calls Defense Secretary Hegseth "a failure."

Yahoo News, Al Jazeera English and CBS News also carry Kaine's remarks that the election results showed the war's unpopularity.

Center4 outlets

Symbolic measure fails as Fetterman breaks with Democrats

Newsweek puts Fetterman first, headlining that he "breaks ranks" with Democrats. It reviews his past defense of the military campaign, including his remark "I'm the only Democrat in the Senate" who supports the war, and notes the measure would likely have faced a veto. The Seattle Times, running an Associated Press report, opens with Republicans blocking a Democratic effort and quotes Kaine saying "The American public is tired of it."

Republican Sen. Tim Sheehy argues the US should "finish the job." The report cites the AP Voter Poll, in which about 6 in 10 voters said the US made the "wrong decision," and notes Collins lost her reelection bid. The Hill reports that Senate Republicans blocked a measure that would have directed Trump to end hostilities in Iran, and that Democrats hoped for success after a midterm in which many voters backed them.

Conservative5 outlets

Symbolic rebuke fails, bigger funding fight looms

Fox News leads with Democrats and "rebel Republicans" failing to pass a non-binding resolution, then turns to the Dec. 11 funding deadline. Senate Majority Leader John Thune says he is "increasingly concerned" that Democrats may try a third government shutdown in 2026. Kaine counters that Republicans are the ones who would "shut the government down to maintain an illegal war."

The Washington Examiner calls it the first "unity test" for Senate Republicans since the election and notes the party lost nine seats. It adds that lame-duck senators complicated GOP vote-counting. Just the News stresses the resolution carried no legal authority and quotes Tillis saying he does not "need to vote on a Democrat resolution" to make his statement.

The Epoch Times names House Concurrent Resolution 93 and quotes Sheehy: "Iran is not a war of choice. It's a war of necessity."

Where outlets disagree
Money and daily life

According to Fox News, the deadline to fund the government or extend current funding is Dec. 11. Senate Majority Leader John Thune said he is concerned Democrats may try to start a third government shutdown in 2026. The Guardian reports the war has pushed up gasoline and diesel prices across the US.

All sources: 14 articles from 14 outlets

Liberal (5)

Center (4)

Conservative (5)