ABRAnews Open the whole story. Sign in

Pakistani man gets over 27 years for plot to kill officials including Trump

Prosecutors say Asif Merchant acted for Iran's Revolutionary Guard, but he testified he was forced into it to protect his family.

Published 1 min read
Overview

A federal judge in Brooklyn sentenced Asif Merchant, a 48-year-old Pakistani man, to 330 months in prison on Tuesday, Nov. 17. A jury convicted him in March of attempted terrorism transcending national boundaries and murder for hire. Judge Eric Komitee, a Trump appointee, called it an "exceptionally severe crime."

Prosecutors say Merchant, working for Iran's Revolutionary Guard, came to the United States to arrange the killing of US officials, in revenge for the 2020 US strike that killed Guard commander Qassem Soleimani. By his testimony, he believed the target was Donald Trump, with Joe Biden and Nikki Haley as other possible targets. He lined up men he thought were hit men but who were undercover agents.

On July 12, 2024, he was arrested, one day before an unconnected attempt on Trump's life in Butler, Pennsylvania. Merchant testified he joined the plot unwillingly to protect his family in Iran. Prosecutors disputed that.

The judge said Merchant may have had some concern for his family but was highly motivated to do harm. Iran has denied plotting to kill Trump or US officials. Todd Blanche said Merchant was "justly sentenced."

Merchant's lawyers say they will appeal.

Key figures
  • 330 monthsprison sentence, as announced by the Justice DepartmentUS Department of Justice
  • $5,000advance Merchant paid the purported hitmen, per prosecutors as UPI reports. CBS News reports $5,000 to each of the two menUPI
  • approximately 15 timesMerchant's meetings with his Guard handler in Tehran, per the Justice DepartmentUS Department of Justice

Three sides of the story

13 news outlets reported this

Tap a color or swipe sideways to switch sides.

Liberal3 outlets

The sentence, plus Merchant's duress claim and defense

The Guardian opens with the sentence of more than 27 years and says the plot was meant to avenge the US killing of Guard commander Qassem Suleimani, citing the . It describes Merchant as having "alleged ties to Iran" and reports his testimony that he was forced into the plot to protect family in Tehran and that his Iranian contact mentioned Trump, Biden and Haley. It then gives Attorney General Todd Blanche's statement that the plot was against Trump.

CBS News headlines the sentencing of a man "convicted in Iran-backed plot" and adds courtroom detail: Merchant in shackled ankles, Judge Eric Komitee calling it "an extreme instance of terroristic violence," and prosecutors saying there was no evidence he had "fear for relatives." CBS also quotes defense lawyer Christopher Neff, who said Merchant is "not the monster" the government describes and that the outcome shows "our judiciary remains independent."

Center5 outlets

The sentencing hearing and the trial's key evidence

Deutsche Welle headlines a "foiled plot to kill Trump, Biden" and places the case against the Iran war, noting the trial began in late February and that Tehran denies targeting US officials. UPI, with a Nov. 17 dateline, leads with the 330-month sentence and relies on the 's Office release and Blanche's statement. The Seattle Times runs an Associated Press report headlined around a plot "he said was steered from Iran," which recounts the napkin demonstration and quotes defense lawyer Christopher Neff: "This plot was incompetent from the very beginning."

Courthouse News, reporting from Brooklyn, describes the hotel video with an orange vape on a napkin, the defense memo comparing the case to "Inspector Clouseau," and the judge's reasons for a sentence below the guidelines, including Merchant's lack of a criminal record. It ends with U.S. Attorney Joseph Nocella's warning to Iran.

Conservative5 outlets

An Iranian agent's plot against Trump and its punishment

The Washington Examiner headlines an "Iranian agent" sentenced for a plot to assassinate Trump, and The Daily Wire calls Merchant an "Iranian Operative" and an "intelligence officer." Both quote Blanche's statement that he was "justly sentenced." Both also follow the Justice Department's account of his recruitment during pilgrimages to Iran and his meetings with a Guard handler, and the Washington Examiner adds his training in "counterintelligence measures."

The Daily Wire adds Judge Komitee's words in court, the Butler shooting by 20-year-old Thomas Matthew Crooks and the Google Maps search for a New Jersey rally. It also quotes Justice Department official M. Scott Proctor calling the sentence a "stark warning." Just the News leads with the sentence and says Merchant said he was forced to work for the Guard to protect family in Iran.

It gives the last word to U.S. Attorney Joseph Nocella's message to Iran.

What a side did not mention
Where outlets disagree
Official statements
All sources: 13 articles from 13 outlets

Liberal (3)

Center (5)

Conservative (5)

FBI

The Federal Bureau of Investigation: the main federal police and counterintelligence agency, part of the Justice Department.

All terms →
Attorney General

The head of the Justice Department and the government's chief lawyer. Each state has its own attorney general too.

All terms →
Justice Department

The federal ministry that prosecutes federal crimes. The FBI is part of it, and its head is the Attorney General.

All terms →
District attorney and US attorney

A district attorney is the local prosecutor, usually elected, who brings charges under state law. A US attorney is the federal prosecutor for a district, appointed by the president, who brings federal charges.

All terms →