Landfill drilling in Los Angeles County triggers gas eruption and evacuation warnings
Crews hit a pocket of methane at Chiquita Canyon Landfill in Castaic, and the fire department says air monitoring shows no danger.
A crew drilling a new well at the Chiquita Canyon Landfill in Castaic, in Los Angeles , hit a pressurized pocket of methane about 150 feet underground on Monday, Nov. 16. The gas escaped through the hole and carried decomposing garbage with it, sending a dark plume 500 feet into the air. Los Angeles County Fire Capt. Aaron Katon said there was no fire and that air monitoring showed no danger to residents.
Six workers were decontaminated by hazardous materials crews, and some were taken to hospitals as a precaution. The landfill operator said no liquids were released, work stopped at once and the area was secured. Also, the operator said no injuries had been reported, and a fire department spokesperson stated six persons went to a hospital with slight injuries.
Residents of Val Verde, Hasley Hills, Industry, Cambridge and Hillcrest received evacuation warnings and were told to stay indoors, and all advisories were lifted by Monday night. The county public health department ordered the operators to provide hotel stays and other help to affected residents. It said the strong odors could cause headaches, nausea, dizziness, or eye, nose or throat irritation.
County Supervisor Kathryn Barger said she wants answers and that those responsible will be held accountable.
- 500 feetheight of the plume of trash and gasThe Independent
- 150 feetdepth of the methane pocket the drill hitNewsweek
- six workersdecontaminated by hazardous materials crewsThe Independent
- 639-acresize of the landfill, per California's toxic substances departmentThe Seattle Times
Three sides of the story
11 news outlets reported this
Tap a color or swipe sideways to switch sides.
Liberal3 outlets
A geyser of trash and the health risks
The Independent opens with a "geyser of trash and methane" that shot 500 feet into the air and raised health concerns for residents. It reports the county health department's order that operators provide hotels and emergency help, and its warning that odors may cause headaches, nausea or dizziness. It quotes Fire Capt. Aaron Katon, "No one is at risk," and gives fire officials' account of a pressurized pocket about 150 feet down.
The piece says six workers were decontaminated and four went to hospitals, and gives the operator's description of a routine drilling operation to install a new well. CBS News titles its piece "Absolutely our worst nightmare" and describes a high-pressure blast from a trash heap that resembled a volcano erupting, with correspondent Carter Evans. The Guardian's video item reports six people taken to hospital with minor injuries and air monitors showing no hazard to the community.
Center4 outlets
Eruption, official reassurances and Barger's demand for answers
Newsweek's headline calls it a "Violent Eruption" that sparked evacuation warnings, and its first paragraph says a methane eruption hospitalized six people and shot rotting garbage skyward in a 500-foot spout. It quotes Katon explaining that escaping gas carried small pieces of garbage, and says crews capped the leak by 11 p.m. Supervisor Kathryn Barger says she was "not pleased" and "I want answers." Newsweek adds that California's sued Waste Connections on Oct. 27, that the ordered added air controls, and that the company disputes many allegations.
The Seattle Times carries an Associated Press report, which leads with the gas cloud released when drilling crews disturbed the landfill. Jonathan Torres, a fire department spokesperson, says six people with minor injuries went to the hospital, without identifying them. Katon says the air poses no hazard, and Gov. Gavin Newsom's office says it is monitoring.
Santa Clarita told some nearby residents to be ready to evacuate.
Conservative4 outlets
Video of the eruption and officials' no-danger statements
Breitbart News headlines it "Watch: Geyser of Rotting Garbage Erupts" and builds on KTLA's report, with Katon describing a hole "about 150 feet deep and three feet wide." It carries his line "There was no fire at any point," the operator's statement that "No injuries have been reported," and the health order for hotels and filtered-air refuge centers. The New York Post leads with an "Explosion rocks SoCal landfill," gives 4:01 p.m. as the report time and quotes the Santa Clarita Valley Sheriff's Station: "All air monitoring negative at this time."
It adds that the landfill closed on Jan. 1, 2025, after more than 50 years. RedState opens with "Garbage Volcano?" and calls the eruption a metaphor for Los Angeles. It says the drilling was meant to relieve pressure from hot garbage, quotes Barger calling the incident "unacceptable," and calls her an "utterly clueless officeholder."
Which side made the stronger case?
We will email you when the story continues. At most one email a day.
- How many people were taken to hospital
- The Seattle Times, The Guardian, Newsweek, RedState: six taken to hospital
- The Independent, Breitbart News: four taken to hospital
For residents of Val Verde, Hasley Hills, Industry, Cambridge and Hillcrest, the county health department ordered the landfill operators to provide hotel stays, air purifiers and transportation help right away, according to Newsweek. Newsweek says the department advised residents to limit exposure and consider temporary relocation. Breitbart adds that filtered-air refuge centers were ordered. The fire department says air monitoring found no danger, and evacuation advisories were lifted Monday night.
All sources: 13 articles from 11 outlets
Liberal (5)
- CBS News: Mountain of trash explodes in Los Angeles County: "Absolutely our worst nightmare"
- The Guardian: ‘Plume’ of decomposing garbage, gas prompts emergency health order for LA county residents
- The Guardian: Smoke spews from landfill in California after gas release – video
- The Guardian: Large plume of gas seen at California landfill after explosion – video
- The Independent: Geyser of trash and methane spews 500 feet into the air at California landfill and sparks health concerns
Center (4)
- BBC News: Watch: Eruption at California landfill sends black substance spewing into the air
- Euronews: Huge plume of gas erupts from Los Angeles landfill after drilling accident
- Newsweek: Violent Eruption Blasts Garbage Into Sky, Sparking Evacuation Warnings
- The Seattle Times: Large plume of gas billows out of California landfill
Conservative (4)
- Breitbart News: Watch: Geyser of Rotting Garbage Erupts in Los Angeles County
- New York Post: Explosion rocks SoCal landfill sending workers scrambling and smoke billowing into the air
- RedState: Garbage Volcano? California Landfill Eruption Sends Massive Black Plume Skyward
- The Post Millennial: Rotting trash geyser erupts from LA landfill as residents flee
The evening briefing by email
One email a day, around 8:30 p.m. New York time: the seven main stories, each with its three sides, and the blind spot of the day. Unsubscribe with one tap.
A Telegram channel is coming soon.