Israel's parliament elects opposition ally Matan Kahana speaker, defeating Netanyahu's candidate
Gadi Eisenkot's bloc won with Arab-led parties' votes, 66 to 52, and Netanyahu's Likud called the result "an eternal disgrace," UPI reports.

Israel's parliament elected Matan Kahana as its new speaker on Tuesday, Nov. 17. Kahana is an ally of Gadi Eisenkot, the party leader tasked with trying to form the next government to replace Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu. He won 66 votes in the 120-member , backed by the Jewish-led opposition parties and the Arab-led parties.
Ofir Katz, the candidate of Netanyahu's bloc, received 52 votes after a debate of about seven hours. Kahana replaces Amir Ohana, a Netanyahu ally. The vote came weeks after the Oct. 27 election, in which Netanyahu and his allies lost their majority.
Eisenkot has up to five more weeks to assemble a coalition. Bills capping the prime minister's term, creating a government-led probe into the Oct. 7, 2023 attacks and undoing laws curbing the judiciary's powers have already been tabled by his bloc and the Arab-led parties. Eisenkot called the vote "a worthy democratic move."
In his first remarks, Kahana said he intends to be "the speaker of everyone." According to UPI, Likud called the result "an eternal disgrace" and accused Kahana of relying on Arab lawmakers' votes. Netanyahu remains until a government is formed.
- 66 votesfor Kahana in the 120-member KnessetThe Guardian
- 52 votesfor Likud's Ofir KatzThe Guardian
- up to five more weeksEisenkot's time to secure a coalitionThe Guardian
Three sides of the story
7 news outlets reported this
Tap a color or swipe sideways to switch sides.
Liberal3 outlets
A step toward undoing Netanyahu's legacy
Al Jazeera English leads with the vote as "a step towards reversing domestic policies" of Netanyahu's outgoing government. It says Kahana is expected as soon as Wednesday to begin undoing much of Netanyahu's domestic agenda, especially the judicial changes, and that Netanyahu has refused an independent inquiry into Oct. 7. A second Al Jazeera piece, written before the vote, quotes Ahmad Tibi of the Joint List: "We need to get rid of the Netanyahu coalition as soon as possible."
It adds that a two-term limit would bar Netanyahu from becoming prime minister again. The Guardian ran the same text as The Seattle Times and the New York Post. It quotes Eisenkot's praise of the vote and Assaf Shapira of the Israel Democracy Institute on how the speaker controls the pace of lawmaking.
According to The New York Times, Kahana will assume charge of the lawmaking agenda while the opposition seeks to pressure Netanyahu "on multiple fronts."
- Al Jazeera English: Israel parliament elects Gadi Eisenkot ally Matan Kahana as new speaker
- Al Jazeera English: As Knesset readies for new speaker, Israeli opposition holds powerful role
- The Guardian: Israeli parliament elects new speaker backed by Netanyahu’s opponents
Center2 outlets
A blow to Netanyahu and obstacles ahead
UPI leads with the vote as a blow to Netanyahu and gives Likud's reaction, calling the result "an eternal disgrace." It also reports criticism from Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich and National Security Minister Itamar Ben Gvir. UPI notes Kahana's promise to respect court rulings and his call to move away from "extremism, hatred, and division."
It then turns to the obstacles for Eisenkot. A minority coalition would depend on Arab parties, Avigdor Liberman of Yisrael Beitenu rejects that, and Naftali Bennett has reportedly favored a unity government with Likud. The Seattle Times ran an Associated Press report.
It quotes Kahana's conciliatory first remarks and Eisenkot's praise of the vote. It also quotes Assaf Shapira of the Israel Democracy Institute on the speaker's role, and describes a shouting match between Likud's Talik Gvili and the Joint List's Ahmad Tibi.
Conservative2 outlets
An opposition speaker as a step toward rolling back policies
The New York Post ran an Associated Press report headlined "Israeli parliament elects new Knesset speaker backed by Netanyahu's opponents." It opens with the election as "a key step toward rolling back policies" of the outgoing government. It reports the 66 to 52 result and Kahana's first remarks, in which he said he intends to be "the speaker of everyone."
It quotes Eisenkot on a "worthy democratic move" and Assaf Shapira of the Israel Democracy Institute on the speaker's power over timing. It also describes the debate in the chamber, where Likud's Talik Gvili, whose son was killed on Oct. 7, shouted "Who killed my son?" at Ahmad Tibi of the Joint List. Tibi answered that Hamas committed the murder and that the prime minister is responsible.
- Liberal outlets did not mentionShouting match between Likud's Talik Gvili and the Joint List's Ahmad Tibi during the debate Reported by The Seattle Times, New York Post
- Conservative outlets did not mentionLikud's "eternal disgrace" reaction and criticism from Smotrich and Ben Gvir Reported by UPI
Which side made the stronger case?
We will email you when the story continues. At most one email a day.
All sources: 9 articles from 7 outlets
Liberal (5)
- Al Jazeera English: Eisenkot ally elected Knesset speaker with Arab bloc’s backing
- Al Jazeera English: Israel parliament elects Gadi Eisenkot ally Matan Kahana as new speaker
- Al Jazeera English: As Knesset readies for new speaker, Israeli opposition holds powerful role
- The Guardian: Israeli parliament elects new speaker backed by Netanyahu’s opponents
Center (2)
- The Seattle Times: Israeli parliament elects new Knesset speaker backed by Netanyahu’s opponents
- UPI: Israeli Knesset elects Matan Kahana speaker in blow to PM Benjamin Netanyahu
Conservative (2)
The evening briefing by email
One email a day, around 8:30 p.m. New York time: the seven main stories, each with its three sides, and the blind spot of the day. Unsubscribe with one tap.
A Telegram channel is coming soon.