Forensic expert says Epstein was killed, but medical examiner stands by suicide ruling
Michael Freeman, who reviewed the autopsy file from Epstein's brother, has not had his findings published in a peer-reviewed journal so far.
A forensic scientist, Michael Freeman, says Jeffrey Epstein's 2019 death in a New York jail cell was a homicide and not a suicide. Freeman, who edits the Journal of Forensic and Legal Medicine, spent about a year examining the autopsy file, which Epstein's brother Mark gave him. On Monday he gave his findings at the Middle Temple, a legal society in London, and told BBC Newsnight he believes Epstein was strangled, most likely from behind.
He points to a deep hemorrhage in the left shoulder, injuries that appear consistent with being struck in the face, and what appear to be fingernail marks above the ligature mark on the neck. Freeman did not see the body, says he was not paid by Mark Epstein, and says he has no idea who might have killed Epstein. His work has not been peer reviewed, and journals have rejected it so far.
The New York City medical examiner's office says it stands by its determination of suicide. The medical examiner who did the autopsy told federal investigators there was no evidence of defensive wounds. Epstein was awaiting trial on sex trafficking charges when he was found dead on August 10, 2019.
Three sides of the story
14 news outlets reported this
Tap a color or swipe sideways to switch sides.
Liberal7 outlets
A credentialed expert challenges the suicide ruling
The Independent's headline says Epstein "may have been killed" and quotes Freeman saying he is certain the injuries did not all come from a self-inflicted hanging. It adds that a review backed the ruling, while Dr. Barbara Sampson, then the city's chief medical examiner, is quoted: "I stand firmly behind our determination." The Daily Beast calls it a "Bombshell Report" and presents Freeman as the second forensic expert to question the ruling, after Dr. Michael Baden, who told 60 Minutes the neck injuries fit homicide better.
The Boston Globe, running the same text as The Seattle Times, opens with Freeman's first reaction to a photo: "Wait a minute, that doesn't look like a hanging mark." It says several investigations found no evidence anyone else was involved, and that some forensic pathologists called the neck mark atypical but said the images could still fit suicide. The New York Times headline reads "Challenging Consensus, Scientist Says Epstein Autopsy Photos Show Homicide."
Center4 outlets
Freeman's claims alongside the medical examiner's standing ruling
BBC News states that Freeman believes Epstein was strangled. It sets his claims beside the 2019 finding of no defensive wounds and Sampson's statement, and quotes Freeman, asked about conspiracy theory, inviting others to show where he went wrong: "I'm wide open to that." Newsweek's headline says Freeman "Lists Reasons"
Epstein's death "May Be Homicide." It carries the medical examiner's statement to Newsweek, "Cause of death: Hanging. Manner of death: Suicide," and quotes retired police captain Michael Johnston: "We cannot jump to facts and conclusions based on a singular set of information."
It also notes Oversight Committee's November 10 report. The Seattle Times carries identical copy to The Boston Globe, beginning with Freeman's response to the autopsy photo and ending with him telling the room, "I tried not to sound like a kook." NewsNation's headline states Epstein's death "may not have been a suicide," and it notes outrage that a prisoner this well known could have gone unwatched.
- Newsweek: Forensics Expert Lists Reasons He Believes Epstein's Death May Be Homicide
- The Seattle Times: Challenging consensus, scientist says photos show Epstein was killed
- BBC News: Forensic expert says his analysis of autopsy photos suggests Epstein was killed
- NewsNation: Epstein's death may not have been a suicide, says forensic expert: Report
Conservative3 outlets
The scientist's credentials and his disputed claim
The Daily Caller's headline says the scientist "Risks It All To Say What Others Won't" and that photos "Show He Was Killed." It builds on the New York Times report, quoting Freeman: "The pattern and distribution and multitude of injuries are not explained by a suicidal hanging." It lists his credentials, citing his Trial Guides profile for expert testimony more than 1,200 times and his website for more than 220 papers and books.
It notes the medical examiner's office stands by its determination and that Mark Epstein posted the photos online. The New York Post's headline says the expert "stunningly claims" Epstein did not kill himself.
It cites the Times on the Middle Temple talk and notes Freeman testified against Derek Chauvin at his murder trial. It details his claims of fingernail marks, a bruise near the neck's base, and a deep bleeding wound in the left shoulder muscle. It says conspiracy theorists have long argued Epstein was killed, but several investigations turned up no evidence anyone else was involved.
Both report that journals have rejected his findings so far.
- Conservative outlets did not mentionFreeman says he has no idea who might have killed Epstein Reported by The Independent, The Daily Beast, The Boston Globe, The Seattle Times, Newsweek, BBC News
Which side made the stronger case?
We will email you when the story continues. At most one email a day.
All sources: 18 articles from 14 outlets
Liberal (10)
- Al Jazeera English: Why a trio of experts alleges Jeffrey Epstein did not die by suicide
- Al Jazeera English: Epstein’s death more likely homicide than suicide, forensic expert says
- Al Jazeera English: Forensic experts claim Epstein was strangled to death
- La Opinión: Epstein habría sido asesinado en prisión, afirma experto tras analizar fotos de su autopsia
- The Boston Globe: Challenging consensus, scientist says photos show Epstein was killed
- The Daily Beast: Epstein's Brother Demands Murder Probe After Forensics Bombshell
- The Daily Beast: Bombshell Report Raises New Questions About Epstein’s Death
- The Independent: Epstein may have been killed in his New York prison cell, claims leading forensic expert
- Yahoo News: Jeffrey Epstein's death may not have been suicide, new analysis suggests
Center (4)
- BBC News: Forensic expert says his analysis of autopsy photos suggests Epstein was killed
- NewsNation: Epstein's death may not have been a suicide, says forensic expert: Report
- Newsweek: Forensics Expert Lists Reasons He Believes Epstein's Death May Be Homicide
- The Seattle Times: Challenging consensus, scientist says photos show Epstein was killed
Conservative (4)
- Daily Caller: Scientist Risks It All To Say What Others Won’t About Epstein: Photos Show He Was Killed
- Just the News: Forensics expert reviews Jeffrey Epstein's autopsy and concludes he didn't kill himself
- New York Post: Jeffrey Epstein’s brother posts gruesome autopsy photos while calling for ‘true homicide’ probe
- New York Post: Forensic expert stunningly claims Jeffrey Epstein didn’t kill himself after reviewing autopsy
The evening briefing by email
One email a day, around 8:30 p.m. New York time: the seven main stories, each with its three sides, and the blind spot of the day. Unsubscribe with one tap.
A Telegram channel is coming soon.