Fiona the hippo can't have surgery after swallowing a hat, Cincinnati Zoo says
The zoo says its best chance is that she passes the knit hat on her own, and staff are monitoring her around the clock.

Fiona, the famous hippo at the Cincinnati Zoo, swallowed a knit hat that ended up in her enclosure, and she is now being cared for around the clock. Zoo spokesperson Michelle Curley said a visitor threw the hat in the air, a ceiling fan caught it, and the fan sent it through a small opening above the viewing windows. She stressed it was an accident.
The New York Post, citing CNN, dates the incident to Nov. 8. In a statement on Monday, Nov. 16, the zoo said her care team is "cautiously optimistic" that she will pass the hat. Her appetite dropped days after she swallowed it.
Staff have given her fluids, sedated her for ultrasounds and performed a colonoscopy with a 9-foot scope. The Independent reports the scope did not reach the hat. Mike Wenninger, the zoo's director of animal health, said an ultrasound showed some bunching of her intestines, which points to her still trying to pass the obstruction.
Specialists told the zoo that surgery is not an option for full-grown hippos, so her best chance is passing the hat on her own. Until then she receives supportive care, pain medicine and her favorite foods, the zoo said. She stays off public view until the matter is resolved.
- 29 poundsFiona's weight at birth in January 2017The Seattle Times
- 9-foot scopeused for her colonoscopy, per the zoo's animal health directorThe Seattle Times
- 2,400 poundsFiona's weight now, according to the Associated Press as cited by the New York PostNew York Post
Three sides of the story
22 news outlets reported this
Tap a color or swipe sideways to switch sides.
Liberal9 outlets
Fiona's recovery, with surgery ruled out
The Independent's Nov. 18 piece leads with caretakers ruling out surgery. It quotes a zoo official from a video update late Monday: "At this point, what we can do is supportive care." It adds that a 9-foot scope borrowed from the Columbus Zoo failed to reach the hat, and that caretakers think something is moving through her small intestine.
Its earlier piece, headlined around an item "tossed" by a visitor, centers on the zoo's statement that the team is "cautiously optimistic." The Guardian, running the same text as The Seattle Times, opens with the zoo saying Fiona is under veterinary care. It quotes Curley saying "We probably couldn't make [it] happen again if we tried," and notes that Timothy, the San Antonio zoo's hippo, sent well wishes on Instagram.
ABC News, in an item headlined "WATCH: Fiona the hippo gets a super-sized tummy ache," reports the zoo will monitor her around the clock after she "ingested an object that a visitor accidentally tossed into her habitat."
- The Independent: Fiona the hippo’s caregivers rule out surgery after she ate hat flung into zoo enclosure
- The Independent: Cincinnati Zoo’s world-famous hippo receiving care after eating item ‘tossed’ by visitor
- The Guardian: Fiona the hippo under veterinary care after eating hat at Cincinnati zoo
- ABC News: WATCH: Fiona the hippo gets a super-sized tummy ache
Center8 outlets
Fiona's medical updates and what the zoo says
BBC News opens with the zoo saying Fiona is in emergency medical care. It says she showed no symptoms at first, then her appetite fell. It reports the latest ultrasound showed the hat passing through her small intestine, though she is still a bit dehydrated.
It quotes a zookeeper saying surgery isn't an option, and Curley on how the hat got in by accident. The Seattle Times, running an Associated Press report, headlines on the zoo saying Fiona can't have surgery. It leads with the colonoscopy and fluids, and quotes Mike Wenninger, the zoo's director of animal health, on intestinal bunching, around-the-clock monitoring and her favorite foods.
Its Nov. 16 piece, the same text The Guardian ran, carries the zoo's Monday statement, with the "cautiously optimistic" line and Curley's account of the ceiling fan. BBC closes on the zoo's hope that she proves "as strong and resilient as she was" at birth, and The Seattle Times recalls her first-year progress followed online worldwide.
Conservative5 outlets
A freak accident, with Fiona under watch
Townhall, headlined "Fiona the Hippo Is Back in the News After Swallowing a Hat," opens with her 2017 fame and embeds tweets from the zoo and CNN. It calls the episode "a freak accident and not intentional," noting social media users blaming a child and parents. It lists anti-nausea medication, "laxative-like supplements" and the Columbus Zoo's scope and technician.
The New York Post leads with her "24-hour medical supervision" and cites CNN for a Nov. 8 date and a one-foot opening. It quotes the zoo's Facebook post and Ron Magill of the Zoo Miami Foundation, who told CNN the main worry is an obstruction leading to infection and sepsis. Magill adds that Zoo Miami has removed items such as sunglasses from an alligator.
The Post says Fiona is now 9 years old and, citing the Associated Press, that she weighs 2,400 pounds.
Which side made the stronger case?
We will email you when the story continues. At most one email a day.
- How premature Fiona was at birth
- Townhall: seven weeks
- BBC News, The Seattle Times: six weeks
All sources: 37 articles from 22 outlets
Liberal (16)
- ABC News: Fiona the hippo dies at Cincinnati Zoo after swallowing hat
- ABC News: WATCH: Fiona the hippo gets a super-sized tummy ache
- La Opinión: Muere Fiona, la famosa hipopótama del zoológico de Cincinnati, tras tragarse una gorra
- MS NOW: Fiona the hippo dies days after ingesting visitor’s hat, Cincinnati Zoo says
- The Boston Globe: Cincinnati Zoo’s famed Fiona the hippo dies days after eating a visitor’s hat
- The Boston Globe: Cincinnati Zoo says Fiona the hippo has died, days after ingesting a visitor’s hat
- The Daily Beast: Zoo Reveals Frantic Failed Attempt to Save Tragic Hippo
- The Guardian: Fiona the famous Ohio hippo receives care after swallowing a hat – video
- The Guardian: US zoo staff monitor Fiona the hippo’s rear end for signs of hat she ate
- The Guardian: Fiona the hippo under veterinary care after eating hat at Cincinnati zoo
- The Independent: Fiona the hippo dies 11 days after swallowing visitor’s hat, Cincinnati Zoo says
- The Independent: Fiona the hippo’s caregivers rule out surgery after she ate hat flung into zoo enclosure
- The Independent: Cincinnati Zoo’s world-famous hippo receiving care after eating item ‘tossed’ by visitor
- The Independent: Fiona the hippo receiving care after eating visitor’s hat at Cincinnati Zoo
- Yahoo News: Former global sensation Fiona the hippo dies after eating a visitor's hat
Center (14)
- BBC News: From premature baby to social media star - Famed hippo Fiona dies
- BBC News: Fiona the hippo dies after swallowing a hat at Cincinnati Zoo
- BBC News: Fiona the hippo undergoing care after swallowing a hat at Cincinnati Zoo
- Las Vegas Review-Journal: Cincinnati Zoo says Fiona the hippo has died, days after ingesting a visitor’s hat
- NewsNation: Fiona the hippo dies after eating hat that entered her enclosure
- Newsweek: 'Beloved' Fiona the Hippo Dies After Swallowing Hat: What We Know
- Newsweek: Fiona the Hippo’s Care Team Takes New Step After She Swallowed a Hat
- The Hill: Fiona the Hippo dies days after ingesting hat, Cincinnati Zoo announces
- The Seattle Times: Fiona’s death gives parents a chance to teach kids about grief — and life
- The Seattle Times: Cincinnati Zoo hopes a little shake will help Fiona the hippo pass a swallowed hat
- The Seattle Times: Cincinnati Zoo says Fiona the hippo can’t undergo surgery after swallowing a hat
- The Seattle Times: Cincinnati Zoo says Fiona the hippo is undergoing care after eating a hat that got into enclosure
- The Wall Street Journal: Cincinnati’s Famous Hippo Fiona Dies After Ingesting a Visitor’s Hat
- UPI: Famed Cincinnati Zoo hippo Fiona dies at 9
Conservative (7)
- Fox News: Beloved hippo Fiona dies at Cincinnati Zoo after swallowing visitor's hat
- Just the News: Cincinnati Zoo announces death of beloved 'Fiona the Hippo' after she swallowed knitted hat
- New York Post: Beloved Fiona the hippo dies days after swallowing knitted hat, Cincinnati Zoo announces
- New York Post: World famous Fiona the hippo under 24-hour medical supervision after eating knitted hat
- The Daily Wire: Fiona, Beloved Miracle Hippo, Dies After Ingesting Knit Hat
- Townhall: Fiona the Hippo Dies After Swallowing a Hat
- Townhall: Fiona the Hippo Is Back in the News After Swallowing a Hat
The evening briefing by email
One email a day, around 8:30 p.m. New York time: the seven main stories, each with its three sides, and the blind spot of the day. Unsubscribe with one tap.
A Telegram channel is coming soon.