California voters reject one-time 5% billionaire tax after costly campaign
The AP called the race on Monday, and the sponsoring union says it will seek a billionaire tax again in 2028 if healthcare problems are not addressed.
California voters rejected , a one-time 5% tax on the net worth of billionaires living in the state. The Associated Press called the race on Monday, with 52.8% voting against and 47.2% in favor, according to the New York Post and Just the News. The healthcare union SEIU-United Healthcare Workers West sponsored the measure.
Most of the money would have gone to healthcare to offset federal funding cuts, with the rest for education and food assistance. Backers estimated it would raise about $100 billion. Opponents far outspent supporters, and Google co-founder Sergey Brin was the biggest donor to the committee fighting the tax.
Two other measures on the ballot, Propositions 41 and 42, could have blocked the tax even if it passed. Gov. Gavin Newsom, a Democrat, opposed the tax. Sen. Bernie Sanders and Rep. Ro Khanna supported it.
The union says it will seek a billionaire tax again in 2028 if state leaders do not better support the public health sector. The Los Angeles Times reports Sanders and Khanna are pushing a federal tax on billionaires.
- 52.8%voters who rejected Proposition 40New York Post
- 47.2%voters who supported itNew York Post
- more than $333 millionraised by Building a Better California, the committee fighting the tax, per APThe Seattle Times
- around $100 billionrevenue the tax would have generated, per SEIU-UHWNew York Post
- $38.9 billionpossible net loss to the state, per Stanford economists' paperReason
Three sides of the story
32 news outlets reported this
Tap a color or swipe sideways to switch sides.
Liberal17 outlets
Billionaire money, split Democrats, and what defeat means nationally
Business Insider opens on the billionaires' win: California's 200-plus billionaires are "officially in the clear." It tracks the donors, noting Brin gave more than $100 million per CalMatters, and quotes Nvidia's Jensen Huang saying "I'm perfectly fine with it." The Guardian calls the campaign the most expensive in state history, puts opposition spending near $425m, and says the result "could hamper nationwide momentum" on taxing the ultra-wealthy.
CBS News, which projects the outcome, centers on how the measure split Democratic allies. Newsom and Katie Porter opposed it, while the state party and unions backed it. It also sets one study's $30 billion estimate against the $100 billion backers cited.
The Los Angeles Times headlines concern for the economy, cites the AP's roughly 53% to 47% split and quotes SEIU-UHW's Suzanne Jimenez on "billionaire-funded propaganda."
- Business Insider: Californians reject Prop 40, the billionaire tax tech elites spent millions trying to stop
- The Guardian: California voters fail to pass proposed one-time tax on billionaires’ wealth
- CBS News: California voters reject billionaire wealth tax, CBS News projects
- Los Angeles Times: Billionaire tax rejected on concern squeezing California's ultra-rich would harm the economy
Center7 outlets
A long, expensive fight ends in rejection
BBC News opens with its headline, "Californians reject wealth tax for billionaires," and notes the projection took nearly a week of counting after the election. It quotes union head Dave Regan saying the billionaires' efforts created "a lot of confusion," and his pledge to seek the tax again in 2028. The Seattle Times, running an AP report, calls the result a win for Democratic leaders such as Newsom, who is deciding on a 2028 presidential run.
It quotes the opposing coalition's "reckless experiment" statement. Reason reports 52.8% against, citing The New York Times, and adds October polls, the Legislative Analyst's Office projection of "tens of billions of dollars," and the Stanford paper's possible $38.9 billion net loss. The Journal's headline marks an end to "a heated and expensive fight" over a possible first modern wealth levy for the nation.
- BBC News: Californians reject wealth tax for billionaires
- Reason: California Voters Reject 5% Billionaire Wealth Tax
- The Seattle Times: California voters reject measure to tax the wealth of billionaires
- The Wall Street Journal: California voters rejected a proposed billionaire tax, ending a heated and expensive fight over what could have been the nation’s first modern tax on wealth
Conservative8 outlets
A setback for the progressive wealth-tax push
The New York Post calls the result a "setback for progressive agenda" and gives the picture. San Francisco (56.2%) and Los Angeles (55%) were in favor, while Orange County (59.3%) and San Diego County (54.3%) voted no. It says Newsom backed Proposition 42 and cites Forbes for Brin spending nearly $102 million.
The Washington Examiner says the failure is "dashing liberal dreams." It describes the measure as a trial balloon some on the Left saw for a national wealth tax, and cites six Nobel-winning economists' letter. It also cites a Stanford working paper finding revenue estimates "grossly oversold."
Just the News reports the AP's call on Monday night, gives nearly six million votes against and 5.28 million for, and notes that members of both parties opposed it. The Washington Times says voters rejected a "one-time" wealth tax.
- New York Post: California voters officially reject controversial billionaire tax in setback for progressive agenda
- Washington Examiner: California billionaire wealth tax fails, dashing liberal dreams
- Just the News: California voters reject billionaire tax measure
- The Washington Times: California voters reject measure to tax the wealth of billionaires
Which side made the stronger case?
We will email you when the story continues. At most one email a day.
- Share of voters against Proposition 40
- New York Post, Just the News, Reason: 52.8%
- Washington Examiner: 53.8%
Business Insider reports backers pitched the tax as a way to help cover looming federal cuts to Medi-Cal, the state's program. SEIU-UHW's Suzanne Jimenez warns of reduced hospital services and lost access to care, saying "Californians will see for themselves what was at stake." The Los Angeles Times writes that lawmakers seem unlikely to find a way to cover an estimated $100 billion in federal healthcare cuts.
All sources: 40 articles from 32 outlets
Liberal (20)
- ABC News: California's Prop 40 'billionaires' tax' measure is rejected, AP projects
- ABC News: California voters reject measure to tax the wealth of billionaires
- Al Jazeera English: California voters reject billionaire tax
- Business Insider: Californians reject Prop 40, the billionaire tax tech elites spent millions trying to stop
- CBS News: California voters reject billionaire wealth tax, CBS News projects
- HuffPost: California Voters Reject First-Of-Its-Kind Billionaire Tax
- HuffPost: California’s ‘Billionaire Tax’ Is Still Trailing After A Week Of Vote Counting
- La Opinión: Votantes de California rechazan la Proposición 40 para un impuesto a multimillonarios
- Los Angeles Times: Billionaire tax rejected on concern squeezing California's ultra-rich would harm the economy
- Mother Jones: Oligarchs Got Crushed on Election Day, But Still Managed to Kill California’s Wealth Tax Dreams
- NBC News: California voters reject new tax on billionaires in a blow to the left
- NPR: Why did California's billionaire tax fail to surf the blue wave?
- NPR: California voters defeat billionaire tax proposal that divided Democrats
- PBS NewsHour: California voters reject tax on net worth of billionaires
- The Guardian: California voters fail to pass proposed one-time tax on billionaires’ wealth
- The Independent: Tech billionaires dodge massive wealth tax as California voters decisively reject controversial Proposition
- The New Republic: California Billionaires Got a Tax Break for Fighting the Wealth Tax
- The Philadelphia Inquirer: California voters reject billionaire tax
- Yahoo News: California voters reject billionaire tax after opponents argued it would harm the economy
Center (11)
- BBC News: Californians reject wealth tax for billionaires
- Deseret News: Billionaire tax fails in California, deepening Democratic divide
- Euronews: California voters reject one-off billionaire wealth tax US media predicts
- Newsweek: California’s Proposition 40 Fell Victim to the Billionaires Paradox
- Newsweek: Poll Of The Day: Does America Need a Billionaire Tax?
- Reason: California Voters Reject 5% Billionaire Wealth Tax
- The Seattle Times: California voters reject measure to tax the wealth of billionaires
- The Wall Street Journal: Progressives’ yearslong quest to tax wealth failed its test in California. That doesn’t mean the idea is going away.
- The Wall Street Journal: Opinion | The California Wealth Tax Goes Down (opinion)
- The Wall Street Journal: California voters rejected a proposed billionaire tax, ending a heated and expensive fight over what could have been the nation’s first modern tax on wealth
- The Wall Street Journal: California voters rejected a proposed billionaire tax, ending a heated and expensive fight over what could have been the nation’s first modern tax on wealth
Conservative (9)
- Breitbart News: California Voters Reject Punitive One-Time Tax on Billionaire Wealth
- Just the News: California voters reject billionaire tax measure
- New York Post: California voters officially reject controversial billionaire tax in setback for progressive agenda
- RedState: California Voters Side With Sanity, Reject 'One-Time' Billionaires Tax
- The Blaze: Bernie-backed tax on billionaires is TOO extreme even for California
- The Daily Wire: Voters Shoot Down Bernie Sanders-Backed Billionaire Tax
- The Washington Times: California rejects pioneering wealth tax
- The Washington Times: California voters reject measure to tax the wealth of billionaires
- Washington Examiner: California billionaire wealth tax fails, dashing liberal dreams
The evening briefing by email
One email a day, around 8:30 p.m. New York time: the seven main stories, each with its three sides, and the blind spot of the day. Unsubscribe with one tap.
A Telegram channel is coming soon.