Appeals court rules Trump administration wrongly withheld $73.5 million from New York
The 2nd US Circuit found the hold over immigrant truckers' licenses lacked legal basis, while the Transportation Department says its efforts will continue.

Friday, a federal said the Trump administration's withholding of $73.5 million in New York highway funds was wrongful. The Transportation Department announced the hold in April. The department said New York unlawfully refused to cancel commercial driver's licenses for certain immigrant drivers, and it threatened to withhold another $147 million in future years.
The 2nd US Circuit Court of Appeals said the department's position "runs afoul of fair notice principles" and departs from the regulation's text. Judge Allison Nathan, a Joe Biden appointee, wrote that the department tried to set tougher standards for noncitizen truckers "out of regulatory silence." Judge Sarah Merriam, also a Biden appointee, joined her.
Judge Matthew Schwartz, a Trump appointee, agreed with the judgment but wrote separately, saying the majority went too far in its analysis. New York Governor Kathy Hochul said in April that the cuts were "nothing more than political payback." Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy had charged the state with leaving Americans exposed to unvetted, unqualified foreign drivers.
In a statement Friday, a department spokesperson said the administration will keep using every resource to stop illegal immigrants who cannot properly operate a truck. California has a similar case pending at the D.C. Circuit, which heard arguments in September.
- $73.5 millionhighway money the department withheld from New YorkThe Independent
- $147 millionfurther yearly funding the department threatened to freezeThe Independent
- nearly 33,000questionable commercial licenses in the audit, by PBS's accountPBS NewsHour
Three sides of the story
5 news outlets reported this
Tap a color or swipe sideways to switch sides.
Liberal3 outlets
An administration overstepping its powers, losing in court
The Independent leads with the ruling that the administration "overstepped its statutory powers" by withholding $73.5 million, and quotes the court saying the department's position "runs afoul of fair notice principles." It reports that New York warned revoking licenses would hurt industries that depend on commercial drivers and might leave schools short of bus drivers. It places the case among other court losses for the administration on transportation money, including the Hudson Tunnel rail project, New York City's congestion pricing and Chicago rail funds.
It also says New York, California and other states have cited political bias in suing. Spokespeople for Duffy and Hochul did not immediately comment. PBS NewsHour reports that the department wrongly withheld nearly $74 million after New York refused to revoke nearly 33,000 questionable licenses for immigrants, which an audit flagged last year.
Center1 outlet
The court's reasoning and the judges' separate opinions
Courthouse News opens with the Second Circuit blocking the department's move and finding New York was unlawfully punished. It builds the report on the judges: Allison Nathan, a Biden appointee who wrote that the effort "falls flat," Sarah Merriam, also a Biden appointee, who joined, and Matthew Schwartz, a Trump appointee who agreed with the result but thought the majority went too far.
It gives New York's lawyer, who called the department's argument "a textbook post hoc rationalization," and Hochul's April words, "political payback." It also carries the Transportation Department's statement that it has put a stop to "the madness," and Duffy's accusation about unvetted foreign drivers. It adds that California has a similar case pending at the D.C. Circuit.
Conservative1 outlet
Outlets on this side gave the story little coverage.
Which side made the stronger case?
We will email you when the story continues. At most one email a day.
All sources: 5 articles from 5 outlets
Liberal (3)
- PBS NewsHour: U.S. wrongly withheld New York highway funds over immigrant licenses, appeals court rules
- The Boston Globe: Appeals court says US wrongly withheld highway funds to NY over immigrant licenses
- The Independent: Federal appeals court rules against Trump in battle over trucker licenses in New York
Center (1)
Conservative (1)
- The Washington Times: New York triumphs in case over issuing truck driver's licenses to illegal immigrants
The evening briefing by email
One email a day, around 8:30 p.m. New York time: the seven main stories, each with its three sides, and the blind spot of the day. Unsubscribe with one tap.
A Telegram channel is coming soon.