Appeals court refuses to rehear Rep. McIver's bid to avoid assault charges
The 3rd Circuit keeps its August ruling that the New Jersey Democrat is not immune, and she says she is weighing "every possible option."

The U.S. for the 3rd Circuit on Thursday declined to reconsider its August ruling against Rep. LaMonica McIver, a New Jersey Democrat. She faces charges tied to a confrontation with federal immigration agents at Delaney Hall, a detention center in Newark, during an oversight visit in May 2025. The 2-1 August opinion, written by Judge Cindy Chung, held that two of the three charges are not covered by the legislative immunity McIver claimed.
The third charge went back to the lower court. Judge Thomas Ambro partly . Three judges voted to have the full court hear the case, and Judge Emil Bove did not take part in the vote.
Prosecutors allege McIver struck agents during a scuffle around Newark Mayor Ras Baraka. McIver said she and her lawyers are looking at "every possible option." She blamed a "weaponized " and said she faces 17 years in prison.
She could next ask the to take the case.
- 17 yearsprison term McIver says she facesRoll Call
- 2-1split in the August panel ruling the court left standingRoll Call
- Three judgesjudges who backed a full-court rehearingRoll Call
Three sides of the story
6 news outlets reported this
Tap a color or swipe sideways to switch sides.
Liberal1 outlet
Outlets on the left gave the story little coverage.
Center3 outlets
The court's refusal and McIver's next options
Roll Call reports that McIver "faced a setback" when the appeals court declined to reconsider and let the case go forward. It quotes her saying she and her lawyers are looking at "every possible option." It details the judges: Chung wrote the majority opinion, Ambro partly dissented, and Bove did not take part in the vote.
It adds that the case began after the May 2025 visit and that charges against Baraka were later dropped. Courthouse News reports that the court denied her request to reconsider its August ruling denying legislative immunity, and notes the charge that she struck immigration officers. The Hill reports that the court turned down her request for review by the full court of her effort to have the charges dismissed.
Conservative2 outlets
A win for Trump administration over progressive
Fox News leads with "Trump scores key win over House progressive accused of assaulting agent," calling the ruling "another win" for the administration. It notes that the August 2-1 decision came from Biden-appointed Judge Cindy Chung and Trump-appointed Judge Stephanos Bibas. Two of the three counts cannot rely on legislative immunity, and the third was sent back to a lower court.
Fox quotes court documents alleging McIver "slammed her forearm" into an officer trying to arrest Newark Mayor Ras Baraka, and that she struck an officer with both forearms as she returned inside the secured area. It gives Judge Thomas Ambro's dissent, which says that blocking a lawmaker from entering a facility denies effective access to an oversight inspection. McIver's statement calls the result "disappointing" and accuses a "weaponized Department of Justice."
Fox closes by noting the case could reach the Supreme Court.
Which side made the stronger case?
We will email you when the story continues. At most one email a day.
All sources: 6 articles from 6 outlets
Liberal (1)
Center (3)
- Courthouse News: 3rd Circuit won’t rehear Rep. LaMonica McIver’s immunity claim
- Roll Call: Appeals court stands by LaMonica McIver ruling
- The Hill: Appeals court denies full panel review of McIver bid to toss case
Conservative (2)
The evening briefing by email
One email a day, around 8:30 p.m. New York time: the seven main stories, each with its three sides, and the blind spot of the day. Unsubscribe with one tap.
A Telegram channel is coming soon.