Child dies of measles in New York, state's first such death in 30 years
Hochul says Washington "deliberately erodes decades of progress" against preventable illnesses, while a federal health spokesperson says the CDC sent experts at New York's request.
A child from Lewis County, in the state's rural north, has died of measles, New York officials announced on Monday, Nov. 2. Gov. Kathy Hochul called it New York's first measles-related death in 30 years. The child's age was not disclosed, and it was not immediately clear whether the child had been vaccinated.
Hochul said she was heartbroken. She called the death "a devastating reminder of what's at stake when Washington deliberately erodes decades of progress" in protecting Americans from preventable illnesses. The state health department and Lewis County Public Health issued a joint statement urging residents to keep their measles vaccinations current.
Newsweek, citing the state health department, reports 178 cases in New York as of Oct. 24, with 170 of them outside New York City. Newsweek also cites the county for 15 confirmed cases as of Oct. 14, all in unvaccinated people. Hochul declared a state disaster emergency in October.
It widened the group allowed to give measles vaccines and let nurses order testing. A Department of Health and Human Services spokesperson said the CDC sent epidemiologists and other experts to New York at the state's request. Pennsylvania has also reported measles deaths.
- 178 measles cases in New York as of Oct. 24, per the state health department — Newsweek
- 170 of those cases outside New York City — Newsweek
- 15 confirmed measles cases in Lewis County as of Oct. 14, per the county — Newsweek
- $100 million CDC funding nationwide for measles and similar diseases, per an HHS official — Washington Examiner
- $2.36 million CDC money to New York state, per an HHS official — Washington Examiner
Three sides of the story
Liberal5 outlets
A child's measles death amid the outbreak
ABC News reports that a child has died in Lewis County in connection with New York's ongoing measles outbreak, according to health officials. Its headline calls it a measles-associated death in a child.
Center5 outlets
First state measles death in 30 years
Newsweek and UPI lead with the death of a child in Lewis County, the state's first measles death in "more than 30 years." The Seattle Times, in a shorter report, calls it the state's first such death in "30 years." UPI and The Seattle Times quote Hochul's line about Washington "deliberately" eroding progress.
Newsweek adds her post on X saying she was "heartbroken," the county's count of 15 cases among unvaccinated people, and a Vanderbilt doctor's warning about pockets of unvaccinated children. UPI quotes the joint health statement and Hochul's words as "a mother and grandmother." It also sets the death against national criticism of the CDC and Trump's August order to reduce recommended childhood vaccines.
The Seattle Times notes that vaccination rates have fallen below the 95% coverage needed to prevent outbreaks. It adds that the CDC has confirmed three US deaths, while state counts are higher.
Conservative3 outlets
New York's death, with HHS and CDC response
The Washington Examiner reports the death as Hochul's announcement and notes the child's age was not disclosed. It quotes her "heartbroken" statement and her line about "when Washington deliberately erodes decades of progress." It then gives the federal answer at length.
An HHS spokesperson says the agency and CDC are working with Hochul's office, and that the CDC sent epidemiologists and other experts at New York's request. The spokesperson adds that Secretary Kennedy and CDC Director Dr. Erica Schwartz keep stressing MMR vaccination as the top defense. An HHS official says the CDC provided roughly $100 million nationwide for measles and other preventable diseases, including $2.36 million to New York state and $2.07 million to New York City.
The Examiner also notes the CDC lists only three of Pennsylvania's deaths on its website.
- Washington Examiner: New York reports first measles death in 30 years, Hochul says
Which side made the stronger case?
For New Yorkers, the state health department says it is working with counties to provide MMR vaccines to unvaccinated people who request them, and it urges residents to check that their vaccinations are current. Hochul's disaster order widened who can give measles vaccines. Newsweek reports, citing health officials, that the MMR vaccine gives 93 percent protection after one dose and 97 percent after two.
All sources: 14 articles from 13 outlets
Liberal (6)
- ABC News: New York state reports measles-associated death in child amid outbreak
- The Boston Globe: Child dies of measles in New York’s first such death in 30 years
- The Boston Globe: Child dies of measles in New York’s first such death in 30 years
- The Guardian (US): New York child dies from measles in state’s first fatal case in 30 years
- The Independent (US): Child dies of measles in New York's first in 30 years
- Yahoo News: New York state reports first measles-related death in 30 years
Center (5)
- Newsweek: New York Hit by First Measles Death in 30 Years as Virus Takes Child
- Straight Arrow News: New York child dies of measles amid worst outbreak in 35 years
- The Hill: New York reports first measles-associated death in more than 30 years
- The Seattle Times: Child dies of measles in New York’s first such death in 30 years
- UPI: Child in Lewis County, N.Y., dies after contracting measles
Conservative (3)
- New York Post: NY child dies of measles, marking state’s first death from the disease in 30 years
- The Epoch Times: New York Reports 1st Measles-Related Death in Over 30 Years
- Washington Examiner: New York reports first measles death in 30 years, Hochul says
The morning edition by email
One email a day: the three main stories, each with its three sides. No ads. Unsubscribe with one tap.
A Telegram channel is coming soon.