ABRAnews Open the whole story. Sign in

Vance calls Oklahoma governor's bipartisan immigration push "morally and electorally disastrous"

Vice President Vance writes on X that to a lot of people the idea sounds like amnesty, while Trump has signaled openness to a deal.

Published 1 min read
Overview

Vice President JD Vance criticized Oklahoma Republican Gov. Kevin Stitt on Thursday over his call for bipartisan immigration reform. Vance wrote on X that he likes Kevin but asked what the phrase means. He said he would welcome steps making it harder for megacompanies to defraud the visa system or for employers to break immigration law.

But he said that to a lot of people it sounds like amnesty for people who broke the law, and called it "morally and electorally disastrous." Stitt had spoken on Wednesday at a Politico event in Park City, Utah, held alongside the National Governors Association's leadership forum for new governors. He urged a strong border and vetting, said Trump can lead on a fix, and renewed his support for letting governors issue work permits to unauthorized immigrants.

He blamed Washington, where he said each side raises money off the issue. Asked about Vance's post, Stitt told Politico he was glad the vice president is engaged and listening. Earlier in November, Trump told CBS's 60 Minutes that his policy was too tough and hurt Republicans with some voters.

He later said any deal would need to be tough, with no amnesty. He also named hardliner Stephen Miller as White House chief of staff.

Key figures
  • $2,500proposed employer payment per imported worker toward the national debt, as Breitbart reports Stitt's ideaBreitbart News

Three sides of the story

4 news outlets reported this

Tap a color or swipe sideways to switch sides.

Liberal1 outlet

Vance's rebuke and Trump's mixed signals

Politico's report opens with Vance's criticism, saying he "took aim at" Stitt and quoting his X post at length, including his question about what "bipartisan immigration reform" means. It then gives Stitt's remarks at the Politico Pub, where he said Trump "can fix this immigration policy" and blamed Washington for standing in the way.

Stitt's answer to Vance is quoted too: he was "super pumped" the vice president is engaged. Politico sets the exchange against Trump's position. It notes Trump said his deportation policy was "too tough" and named hardliner Stephen Miller chief of staff the same day.

It adds that Trump said a deal "would be wonderful, but we'll see," and that any agreement seems unlikely. It also notes Vance is weighing a 2028 run.

Center1 outlet

Vance's criticism of Stitt despite Trump's openness

Forbes titles its report "JD Vance Blasts Call For Bipartisan Immigration Reform" and adds in the title that Trump has said he is open to it. According to Forbes, Vance replied to calls by Oklahoma Republican Gov. Kevin Stitt for bipartisan immigration reform.

Conservative2 outlets

Vance's amnesty warning and Stitt's work-permit plan

The Washington Examiner reports Vance "condemned" Stitt, noting Stitt's pitch seems similar to Trump's recent pivot. It quotes Trump on 60 Minutes about letting people already here, in some cases for 10 and 15 years, "work a deal" and Stitt saying governors should issue permits when employers vouch for workers.

Breitbart News headlines Vance's rebuke over what it calls an "amnesty" plan to bring in workers for business executives. It quotes Vance's X post at length and says Stitt owns a regional bank and would personally benefit from permits. It also reports that Sens. John Curtis and Mark Kelly drafted a bill giving governors that power, and describes Stitt's proposal as a call for cheap labor.

It cites Oklahoma's newly selected Secretary of State, who criticized the proposal.

All sources: 4 articles from 4 outlets

Liberal (1)

Center (1)

Conservative (2)

Deportation

Forced removal from the US of a person with no legal right to stay. An immigration court usually orders it, but some people are removed faster, without a hearing.

All terms →
Midterm elections

US elections halfway through a president's four-year term. The whole House, a third of the Senate and many governors are elected. In 2026 Election Day was November 3.

All terms →