Vance blames Iran war for Republican midterm losses, Trump defends it
Trump says Vance's view is largely true, but he would do it again, as Democrats won both the House and the Senate.
Democrats won control of both and the in Tuesday's elections. On Wednesday, Vice President JD Vance wrote a long post on X saying the war with Iran is why Republicans lost. "The reason we lost is the war," he wrote.
He said many people who voted for Trump in 2024 voted for Democrats this time because they were angry. He also challenged anyone who thinks the war was worth losing the Senate for the next six years to say so. Asked about the post at the White House, President Trump called it "largely true."
He said the war drove gasoline up "a little bit short term." But he said that if he had it to do again, he would, because "long term, it's the only answer." He called Vance's post "fine."
According to Deutsche Welle, Trump also said he is not considering firing Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth, and that he is willing to work with Democrats but warned them against . The ABC News Voter Poll found 34% of House voters called the war "crucial" to their vote. The Journal reports that administration officials are debating next steps in Iran, with some arguing for more military strikes.
- 34% U.S. House voters who said the Iran war was crucial to their vote, ABC News Voter Poll — ABC News
- 49% House voters who said the cost of living was crucial, ABC News Voter Poll — ABC News
- 55% House voters who said government corruption was crucial, ABC News Voter Poll — ABC News
- About 6 in 10 voters who said the US made the wrong decision on Iran, AP Voter Poll — The Boston Globe
Three sides of the story
Liberal4 outlets
Vance distances himself as Trump defends the war
The Boston Globe leads with Vance publicly breaking from Trump's defense of the war and frames his post as an attempt to distance himself from voters' rebuke as he weighs a 2028 run. It quotes spokesperson Rosemary Boeglin asking "Why didn't he resign?" and former Pence chief of staff Marc Short saying the result "certainly doesn't help his case." ABC News headlines both men, Vance blaming the war and Trump saying he would "do it again," and builds on its Voter Poll, where 34% of House voters called the war "crucial" against 55% for government corruption.
Semafor describes "heated recriminations," with Trump insisting he "wasn't on the ticket" and a White House that blamed the losing candidates. Al Jazeera English's live headline says Trump admits the war "largely" caused the wipeout but says he "had to do it."
- The Boston Globe: Vance tries to distance himself from Iran war after GOP’s deep losses in midterm elections
- ABC News: Vance blames Iran war for GOP's midterms defeat. Trump says he would 'do it again'
- Semafor: Republicans trade blame for historic midterm loss
- Al Jazeera English: Iran war live: Trump says war caused election wipeout but he ‘had to do it’
Center3 outlets
Trump concedes war hurt Republicans but stands by it
Deutsche Welle's roundup headlines Trump saying it is "largely true" that the war led to the loss, and carries Vance's line "The reason we lost is the war." It adds Trump backing Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth, saying "I think he's doing a very good job," and notes the war has cost US taxpayers "tens of billions of dollars." It also reports German Chancellor Friedrich Merz expecting Trump to keep bypassing .
The Hill's defense newsletter runs under "The blame game," saying Trump and Vance both pointed at the war. The Wall Street Journal's news item calls Vance's statement a "rare public rebuke" of a campaign his boss still supports and says officials are debating next steps, some favoring more strikes. A Wall Street Journal opinion piece, titled "JD Vance's Theory of Election Defeat," says he blames only the war: "Never mind corruption, or ICE raids."
- Deutsche Welle: Trump says 'largely true' Iran war led to Republicans midterm loss
- The Hill: The blame game: Administration points finger at Iran after major GOP midterm loss
- The Wall Street Journal (news): Vice President JD Vance blamed the war in Iran for the Republicans’ stunning midterms losses and issued a rare public rebuke of the ongoing military campaign his boss still supports
- The Wall Street Journal (news): Opinion | JD Vance’s Theory of Election Defeat (opinion)
Conservative0 outlets
Outlets on this side gave the story little coverage.
Which side made the stronger case?
For drivers and households, ABC News reports the Iran war has led to rising gas prices and says Trump's tariffs have cost the typical American household almost $1,000 a year. Trump said the war drove gasoline up "a little bit short term." Deutsche Welle reports that US taxpayers have paid "tens of billions of dollars" for the war.
All sources: 9 articles from 7 outlets
Liberal (5)
- ABC News: Vance blames Iran war for GOP's midterms defeat. Trump says he would 'do it again'
- Al Jazeera English: Iran war live: Trump says war caused election wipeout but he ‘had to do it’
- Al Jazeera English: Trump blames Iran war for midterms losses
- Semafor: Republicans trade blame for historic midterm loss
- The Boston Globe: Vance tries to distance himself from Iran war after GOP’s deep losses in midterm elections
Center (4)
- Deutsche Welle: Trump says 'largely true' Iran war led to Republicans midterm loss
- The Hill: The blame game: Administration points finger at Iran after major GOP midterm loss
- The Wall Street Journal (news): Opinion | JD Vance’s Theory of Election Defeat (opinion)
- The Wall Street Journal (news): Vice President JD Vance blamed the war in Iran for the Republicans’ stunning midterms losses and issued a rare public rebuke of the ongoing military campaign his boss still supports
The morning edition by email
One email a day: the three main stories, each with its three sides. No ads. Unsubscribe with one tap.
A Telegram channel is coming soon.