Prosecutors expected to say Monday how they will proceed against Lindsay Clancy
The Massachusetts mother is accused of killing her three children, and it is unclear whether prosecutors will seek first-degree murder again or lesser charges.
Lindsay Clancy, the Massachusetts mother accused over the January 2023 deaths of her three young children, is scheduled to appear in Plymouth Superior Court on Monday, Nov. 16. Prosecutors may say then whether they will retry her on three first-degree murder counts or pursue lesser charges, such as second-degree murder or manslaughter. Her first trial ended in a mistrial in September when jurors deadlocked 11-1, with most favoring not guilty by lack of criminal responsibility.
Plymouth Timothy Cruz said his office expected to decide by the hearing. Judge William Sullivan has since rejected defense motions to dismiss the charges, including an argument that a retrial would amount to double jeopardy. Defense lawyers say they intend to appeal but do not want that to delay a new trial.
Sullivan has said he hopes a retrial can begin in March 2027, or earlier if possible. First-degree murder carries life without . Second-degree carries life with parole eligibility after at least 15 years.
A lesser charge could allow a bench trial, with a judge deciding instead of a jury. Clancy has admitted through counsel that she strangled the children but says she is not guilty by lack of criminal responsibility.
- 11-1jury split in the September deadlockThe Boston Globe
- at least 15 yearstime before parole eligibility on a second-degree murder life termThe Boston Globe
Three sides of the story
27 news outlets reported this
Tap a color or swipe sideways to switch sides.
Liberal7 outlets
What each charging path would mean for Clancy
The Boston Globe opens with Clancy's Monday hearing and what prosecutors may announce: a retrial on three first-degree murder counts or lesser charges. It spells out what each path means. First-degree carries life without parole, second-degree life with parole eligibility after at least 15 years, and a lesser charge could let her choose a bench trial.
The Globe recounts that Clancy admitted through counsel to strangling Cora, Dawson and Callan on Jan. 24, 2023, and that she asserts she was suffering from postpartum psychosis. Prosecutors, it reports, maintain she knew her actions were wrong. It notes she is paralyzed below the waist and kept at Tewksbury Hospital, and that an acquittal based on lack of criminal responsibility would have led to an open-ended stay in a state mental hospital.
The New York Times headline says the judge "could set" a new trial date and describes Sullivan as holding a hearing to decide how to proceed.
Center9 outlets
Prosecutors set to reveal retrial plans
Newsweek leads with prosecutors expected to reveal their plans when Clancy returns to court Monday. It lays out the path to the hearing. Eleven of 12 jurors favored not guilty by reason of insanity, Sullivan rejected the defense's dismissal and double jeopardy motions, and he hopes for a retrial in March 2027.
It quotes the judge's finding of "manifest necessity" for the mistrial and reports that District Attorney Timothy Cruz described his decision process as methodical. Assistant District Attorney Jennifer Sprague earlier confirmed prosecutors intend to retry the case. Defense attorney Kevin Reddington has voiced frustration with the uncertainty, and the defense plans to appeal without delaying a new trial.
NewsNation's headline calls the hearing pivotal and states that Clancy is charged with first-degree murder in the deaths of Cora, Dawson and Callan.
Conservative11 outlets
A final retrial decision and trial scheduling
Just the News headlines Clancy back in court with a "final decision on retrial expected." It says the Monday hearing is meant to formally schedule a trial date. In November, it reports, Sullivan dismissed the defense bid to throw out the three murder and to question the lone holdout juror.
It cites ABC News for Cruz's statement that his office plans to decide by Monday. The outlet says it remains open whether prosecutors will seek first-degree murder again or a lesser charge, which a judge could decide in a bench trial. It adds that Sullivan wants a trial to begin sometime in March and faces the mandatory retirement age for Massachusetts judges in 2026.
It also says the defense did not deny Clancy committed the killings but argued mental illness left her not criminally liable.
Which side made the stronger case?
We will email you when the story continues. At most one email a day.
All sources: 36 articles from 27 outlets
Liberal (8)
- ABC News: Lindsay Clancy gets new trial date
- NPR: Lindsay Clancy to face a new trial in spring of 2027 over children's killing
- The Boston Globe: How will Lindsay Clancy’s retrial be different?
- The Boston Globe: Lindsay Clancy due in court as prosecutors weigh whether to retry her for first-degree murder in deaths of her children
- The Guardian: Judge sets Lindsay Clancy retrial for March in killings of her three children
- The Independent: Lindsay Clancy gets a retrial date after first trial over children’s murders ended in deadlock
- Yahoo News: Lindsay Clancy to face retrial in March over killing of her children
Center (14)
- BBC News: Lindsay Clancy to face retrial next year for deaths of her three children
- BBC News: Watch: Date announced for Lindsay Clancy retrial
- Courthouse News: Judge sets 2027 date for Lindsay Clancy murder retrial
- Forbes: Why Lindsay Clancy’s Spring Retrial Could Be ‘Déjà Vu’: Massachusetts Reporter
- NewsNation: 'Stealth juror' could shape Lindsay Clancy retrial
- NewsNation: Lindsay Clancy retrial could favor defense, Ashleigh Banfield says
- NewsNation: Lindsay Clancy retrial could favor defense, Ashleigh Banfield says
- NewsNation: Lindsay Clancy likely to face same murder charges in second trial
- NewsNation: Lindsay Clancy to appear in court for pivotal hearing
- Newsweek: Lindsay Clancy Hearing: Prosecutors Set to Reveal Plans for Retrial
- The Hill: Judge sets retrial date for Lindsay Clancy
- The Seattle Times: Lindsay Clancy to face March retrial in deaths of her 3 children
- The Wall Street Journal: Lindsay Clancy Faces Retrial in Deaths of Her Three Children
- UPI: Judge schedules Lindsay Clancy retrial for March
Conservative (14)
- Daily Caller: Judge Reveals New Trial Date For Lindsay Clancy Case
- Fox News: Lindsay Clancy to be retried for murder in killing of three children
- Just the News: Lindsay Clancy back in court, final decision on retrial expected
- Just the News: Lindsay Clancy retrial set for March 29
- New York Post: What Lindsay Clancy prosecutors should change for her new trial — and why they face an uphill battle: experts
- New York Post: Holdout Lindsay Clancy juror’s surprising new career plan after mistrial ‘changed his life’
- New York Post: Lindsay Clancy to face first-degree murder trial again as lawyer rules out plea deal: ‘The die has been cast’
- RedState: Lindsay Clancy's Defense Suffers a Crushing Defeat As Murder Case Takes Major Turn
- The Blaze: Lindsay Clancy's new trial for the killings of her 3 children has been set
- The Daily Wire: Lindsay Clancy Is Headed Back To Court As Judge Sets Retrial Date
- The Epoch Times: Lindsay Clancy Retrial Date Set for March 29
- The Post Millennial: BREAKING: Lindsay Clancy retrial set for March 2027
- Townhall: Lindsay Clancy Isn't Escaping Justice. A New Trial Has Been Set.
- Washington Examiner: March 2027 date set for Lindsay Clancy retrial
The evening briefing by email
One email a day, around 8:30 p.m. New York time: the seven main stories, each with its three sides, and the blind spot of the day. Unsubscribe with one tap.
A Telegram channel is coming soon.