ABRAnews Open the whole story. Sign in

Judge says NYT must face Trump's claims over book suggesting tax crimes

Judge Steven Merryday threw out two of Trump's claims, and a Times spokesman says the remaining claim against the paper has no legal merit.

Donald Trump in his official presidential portrait in 2025
Donald Trump in his official presidential portrait in 2025. Photo: Daniel Torok, Public domain, Wikimedia Commons
Published 1 min read
Overview

A federal judge in Tampa, Florida, ruled on Thursday, Nov. 19, that President Donald Trump's $15 billion defamation lawsuit against The New York Times and Penguin Random House may go forward. U.S. District Judge Steven Merryday, a George H.W. Bush appointee, threw out two of Trump's claims. He said the rest of the complaint plausibly alleged that statements accusing Trump of "planning and perpetrating complex crimes" were based on "incomplete, minimal information."

The surviving claims center on Lucky Loser, a 2024 book by Times reporters Susanne Craig and Russ Buettner that suggested Trump committed tax crimes. Merryday wrote that knowing such claims needed a qualified opinion but failing to obtain one is "purposeful avoidance of the truth." The ruling rests on the 1964 decision in New York Times v.

Sullivan, which requires a public figure to prove actual malice. It does not decide the case, which Trump filed in September 2025. The Times and Penguin deny defaming Trump and told the court his lawsuit is legally flawed and aimed at scoring political points.

A spokesman for Trump's legal team said the defendants "will now have to answer for intentionally and maliciously defaming President Trump." Times spokesman Charlie Stadtlander says the paper believes the remaining claim has no legal merit.

Key figures

Three sides of the story

9 news outlets reported this

Tap a color or swipe sideways to switch sides.

Liberal3 outlets

Trump's latest win in his media-lawsuit campaign

Al Jazeera English, The Guardian and The Independent all front the ruling as a win for Trump's legal fight with news outlets he says have treated him unfairly. Each reports that Judge Steven Merryday threw out two claims and found the rest of the complaint plausibly alleged that statements about "planning and perpetrating complex crimes" were based on "incomplete, minimal information." The Independent calls it "another win" and recalls that Trump hailed the BBC ruling as a "huge victory."

Al Jazeera places the case within a "wider pressure campaign" against the media, citing the Journal suit and the attempted White House ban on CNN, MS Now and Politico. It quotes Reporters Without Borders' Clayton Weimers on a "coordinated war on press freedom." The Guardian adds procedural detail, including an earlier 80-page complaint rejected for "vituperation and invective."

It also recalls the Times spokesman's earlier description of the suit as "meritless" and Penguin's statement that it "stands by the book and its authors."

Center2 outlets

The judge's order and its reasoning under Sullivan

Courthouse News opens with the ruling itself: a 12-page order in which Merryday declined to throw out the $15 billion suit, dismissed two claims and found the remaining statements, which accused Trump of tax evasion and possible ties to the Mafia, rested on "incomplete, minimal information." It quotes the judge at length, including his line that knowing a qualified opinion was needed but failing to get one is "purposeful avoidance of the truth." It also explains the Times' reliance on New York Times v.

Sullivan, which requires a public figure to show actual malice. The report quotes Trump's legal team on "a long pattern of defaming President Trump in service of its leftist political agenda." It notes that Trump's complaint called the Times a "full-throated mouthpiece of the Democratic Party."

It also recalls the BBC suit another federal judge in Florida allowed to proceed and the Wall Street Journal suit dismissed in 2026. The Hill reports that the case can proceed and calls the ruling "a win" in Trump's push to cast the Times' coverage as misinformation.

Conservative4 outlets

The judge's finding on the Times book's tax-crime claims

The Washington Examiner says the ruling handed Trump "a major boost," letting claims over the book Lucky Loser move toward a possible trial while claims over two articles were dismissed. The Daily Signal centers on the judge's reasoning, quoting his view that authors who publish such claims without a qualified source "know that they don't know, but they are undeterred," and stressing that the ruling did not settle the case. It carries Penguin Random House's confidence that evidence will lead to "a full dismissal" and Times spokesman Charlie Stadtlander's statement that the paper is encouraged by the dismissal of "almost all claims."

The Epoch Times details what survived, including the allegation that Trump received the equivalent of "more than $400 million" from his father, much of it through "fraudulent tax evasion schemes." It also covers one Mafia-related statement by Peter Baker, and quotes Stadtlander calling the suit a "baseless attack." The Daily Signal and The Epoch Times quote Trump's legal team on the Times' "leftist political agenda."

The Washington Times reports briefly that some of Trump's claims can proceed.

What a side did not mention
Where outlets disagree
All sources: 9 articles from 9 outlets

Liberal (3)

Center (2)

Conservative (4)

Supreme Court

The highest US court: nine justices, appointed for life by the president with the Senate's approval. Its rulings bind every other court.

All terms →
Wall Street

A street in New York where the stock exchange stands. In the news it means US financial markets and the big banks and investment firms as a whole.

All terms →