Federal prosecutor orders Sen. Blumenthal to preserve records of his White House ballroom donor probe
U.S. Attorney Aaron Reitz warns the Connecticut Democrat of "significant legal consequences" if he misses a Nov. 18 deadline, and Blumenthal says he "will not be intimidated."
Aaron Reitz, the for the Southern District of Texas, sent Sen. Richard Blumenthal, a Connecticut Democrat, a letter on Wednesday, Nov. 11. It demands that he preserve all records tied to his investigation of donors to the White House ballroom. Reitz accuses Blumenthal of threatening citizens for associating with President Trump and other public officials.
He warns of "significant legal consequences" and gives the senator until 6 p.m. ET on Nov. 18 to confirm he has complied. According to the Daily Beast, the letter cites two federal statutes but does not say Blumenthal is under criminal investigation. Reitz posted the letter on X. Acting Deputy Trent McCotter backed him, writing that the "will defend against threats to those rights."
Blumenthal is the top Democrat on the Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations and has asked ballroom donors about their gifts. He says he "will not be intimidated" and accuses the administration of weaponizing the Justice Department. NBC News reports that a department spokesperson said it routinely asks that records be preserved when public officials take "such extreme actions."
The letter follows a warning from White House counsel Will Scharf to Rep. Robert Garcia that Democratic investigations could be criminal.
- $400 millioncost of the White House ballroom, as the Daily Beast gives itThe Daily Beast
- 6 p.m. ET on Nov. 18deadline for Blumenthal to confirm he preserved recordsThe Daily Beast
- $600 millioncontractor's internal estimate of the ballroom price, per UPI citing the Washington PostUPI
- nearly 60 letterssent by Blumenthal to known ballroom donors, per the New York PostNew York Post
Three sides of the story
13 news outlets reported this
Tap a color or swipe sideways to switch sides.
Liberal5 outlets
A Trump loyalist's threat against congressional oversight
MS NOW opens with a Justice Department official, Aakash Singh, telling U.S. attorneys to get on a "wartime footing" or consider leaving the department, then presents Reitz's letter as evidence that at least one prosecutor heeded that message. It reviews Reitz's career, including his failed run for Texas attorney general, and says the administration "appears terrified of reasonable questions." The Daily Beast calls Reitz a "Trump loyalist" who threatened Blumenthal over a probe into whether donors got favorable treatment.
It notes the letter cited two federal statutes but did not say Blumenthal is under criminal investigation, and lists donor pledges, including $25 million each from Nvidia and Apple. NBC News reports Reitz's letter and McCotter's reply, then adds that such a step against a sitting member of would typically go through the Public Integrity Office, which NBC says has been reduced and pushed aside in Trump's second term. It quotes a Justice Department spokesperson saying the agency regularly asks for files to be kept when officials take such drastic measures.
All three quote Blumenthal saying he "will not be intimidated."
Center2 outlets
The preservation demand and the wider fight over investigations
UPI leads with the demand itself and gives room to Reitz's letter, quoting him calling it "extraordinary" for an elected official to intimidate citizens over philanthropy. It then sets out Blumenthal's announcement on Oct. 21 of letters to more than a dozen donors, the questions he asked them, and his reply, "I will not be intimidated." UPI adds the ballroom's cost history, from an initial $200 million to a contractor's internal estimate of $600 million obtained by The Washington Post, and links the letter to Scharf's warning to Rep. Robert Garcia, who said "It appears Donald Trump has something to hide."
It places the episode after Democrats won both chambers of Congress. The Hill's headline says DOJ "threatens" Blumenthal with "significant legal consequences" over the probe.
It reports that Reitz, in a letter dated Nov. 11, warned him to preserve records and accused him of using oversight to harass private citizens.
Conservative6 outlets
Justice Department defends donors' right to associate
The New York Post begins with Blumenthal's own letters, nearly 60 of them, to donors including Amazon, Apple and Nvidia, asking for records by Jan. 4 or facing . It quotes him warning of "possible conflicts of interest and even corruption." It then gives Reitz's reply, McCotter's backing on X, and Scharf's line that Trump officials "will not be extorted and will not be cowed."
The Washington Examiner's headline says DOJ "frames" the probe as a threat against Trump supporters. It reports a top Justice Department attorney expressing concern that Blumenthal seeks to intimidate them, and quotes Reitz on "aggressive, harassing government action." It also notes Blumenthal's stated concern that undisclosed donors benefited from "favorable government actions," the 's August ruling for Trump, and DOJ's request that the court throw out the ballroom lawsuit or hear the case.
Which side made the stronger case?
We will email you when the story continues. At most one email a day.
All sources: 15 articles from 13 outlets
Liberal (6)
- MS NOW: Key Democrat isn’t backing down on ballroom probe, setting up clash with Trump’s DOJ
- MS NOW: Federal prosecutor issues unusual warning to Democratic senator over ballroom inquiry
- NBC News: Sen. Richard Blumenthal ordered to preserve documents from inquiry into Trump ballroom
- The Daily Beast: Trump District-Attorney Makes Ballroom Threat to Dems
- The Independent: Trump DOJ threatens senator with ‘significant consequences’ over White House ballroom probe
- The New Republic: DOJ to Democratic Senator: Stop Your Ballroom Investigation or Else!
Center (2)
- The Hill: DOJ threatens Blumenthal with ‘significant legal consequences’ over ballroom probe
- UPI: U.S. attorney demands Blumenthal preserve ballroom probe documents
Conservative (7)
- Fox News: US attorney and Senate Dem spar in dueling letters demanding records preservation: 'I will not be intimidated'
- New York Post: Justice Department warns Democratic Sen. Richard Blumenthal over probe of Trump ballroom donors
- The Daily Wire: Trump DOJ And Top Dem Draw Battle Lines Over Exposing Anonymous Ballroom Donors
- The Epoch Times: Federal Prosecutor Demands Blumenthal Preserve Documents in Ballroom Probe
- The Washington Times: Texas U.S. attorney warns Blumenthal that his White House ballroom probe is an illegal threat
- Washington Examiner: Richard Blumenthal ‘will not be intimidated’ by DOJ over Trump ballroom investigation
- Washington Examiner: DOJ frames Blumenthal ballroom investigation as threat against Trump supporters
The evening briefing by email
One email a day, around 8:30 p.m. New York time: the seven main stories, each with its three sides, and the blind spot of the day. Unsubscribe with one tap.
A Telegram channel is coming soon.