China bars Bloomberg reporter from Trump-Xi-Putin summit after she shouted a question
She asked Trump whether Nvidia's former CEO Jensen Huang was disloyal to the US, and a White House official says Washington sought her readmission.
Chinese officials barred Bloomberg TV reporter Annmarie Hordern from the first-ever three-way meeting of President Donald Trump, Chinese President Xi Jinping and Russian President Vladimir Putin on Thursday, Nov. 19, in Shenzhen, China. Hordern had shouted a question during an earlier one-on-one meeting between Trump and Xi: "President Trump, has Jensen Huang been disloyal to the United States?" Huang resigned as Nvidia's chief executive after an extramarital affair with Alice Huang, a Chinese businesswoman.
U.S. intelligence officials reportedly suspect Alice Huang has ties to Chinese intelligence, and Beijing denies it. According to the White House press pool report, Chinese officials told reporters that yelling questions is extremely rude and that anyone who did so would be pulled from the room. A second reporter who tried to ask a question was shushed by Chinese officials.
A White House official said the U.S. side pushed to have Hordern reinstated, but Chinese officials refused. The agenda covered the wars in Ukraine and Iran, along with trade and nuclear arms control. The Boston Globe reports that Trump did not answer the question, that the Chinese Foreign Ministry did not immediately respond to its questions, and that a Bloomberg spokesperson declined to comment.
Three sides of the story
13 news outlets reported this
Tap a color or swipe sideways to switch sides.
Liberal4 outlets
China's tight control of press access at summits
The Boston Globe, carrying an article that first appeared in The New York Times, opens with the scene: Trump had just thanked Xi when the question came, he did not answer, and a security guard blocked a camera. It calls the exclusion "the latest example" of China's strict controls on news coverage and notes that Beijing has expelled many foreign reporters. It sets the episode against past visits, when Xi took a question from an American reporter in 2014 and again in 2015, and Trump refused questions in 2017.
It quotes Trump telling Xi, "It's too bad the media couldn't see some of it." The Daily Beast headlines its report "Kicked Out of Dictator Party," calls Xi and Putin "strongmen," and leans on the White House pool report, including that a second reporter was "shushed by Chinese officials." It recalls the May clashes over press access at the Temple of Heaven.
The New York Times presents the exclusion as a sign of how closely China manages events.
Center2 outlets
A Bloomberg reporter shut out over a question
NewsNation's headline says China barred a reporter from the trilateral summit after an Nvidia question, and it names the reporter as Annmarie Hordern, who asked Trump about the loyalty of Nvidia's former chief executive The Hill reports that China blocked a Bloomberg reporter from the room for the opening remarks of the three-way meeting, citing the White House press pool report that she was blocked because she asked a question during Trump's bilateral with Xi.
Conservative7 outlets
White House backed the reporter, but Beijing refused
Fox News leads with the bar itself: Chinese officials refused to admit Bloomberg's Annmarie Hordern despite a White House push. It then sets this beside the friendly tone Trump sought, noting Xi's "one-armed hug" on the tarmac and Trump calling Putin "my friend." RedState puts "Even After White House Intervenes" in its headline and repeats a Fox News post saying the question "touched a nerve" amid tensions over artificial intelligence.
Townhall's headline says the White House "defended" the reporter. It quotes Fox's Bill Melugin and, citing the Associated Press, adds that the three countries reached agreements on nuclear risks, U.N. reforms and increasing fuel supply, with Trump saying "We are really making history." The Washington Examiner quotes the pool report that she "will likely be prevented" from entering.
It also reports that pool reporters' phones were collected, and quotes Trump telling Fox News he "might have referred to it just briefly" with Xi.
- Fox News: China blocks Bloomberg reporter from Trump-Putin-Xi meeting over question to Trump
- RedState: China Boots American Reporter From Trump-Xi-Putin Summit, Even After White House Intervenes
- Townhall: The White House Defended a Bloomberg Reporter Who Upset Chinese Officials During Bilateral Meeting
- Washington Examiner: China kicks out reporter from summit after shouting question about Jensen Huang
Which side made the stronger case?
We will email you when the story continues. At most one email a day.
All sources: 15 articles from 13 outlets
Liberal (5)
- ABC News: China bars Bloomberg reporter from trilateral meeting after she shouted question at earlier event
- The Boston Globe: China bars Bloomberg reporter from trilateral meeting after she shouted question at earlier event
- The Boston Globe: China bars Bloomberg reporter from trilateral talks for asking a question
- The Daily Beast: American Reporter Kicked Out of Dictator Party for Asking Trump a Question
Center (2)
- NewsNation: China bars reporter from trilateral summit after Nvidia question
- The Hill: China shuts out Bloomberg reporter for shouting questions at Trump
Conservative (8)
- Fox News: China blocks Bloomberg reporter from Trump-Putin-Xi meeting over question to Trump
- New York Post: Reporter banned from summit after asking Trump about Jensen Huang in front of Chinese leader
- RedState: China Boots American Reporter From Trump-Xi-Putin Summit, Even After White House Intervenes
- The Epoch Times: Trump Meets Putin, Xi in 1st Trilateral Summit; Bloomberg Reporter Barred Over Jensen Huang Question
- The Epoch Times: China Bars US Reporter From Summit Over Nvidia Question
- The Washington Times: Journalists face restrictions, unusual security protocols while traveling with Trump in China
- Townhall: The White House Defended a Bloomberg Reporter Who Upset Chinese Officials During Bilateral Meeting
- Washington Examiner: China kicks out reporter from summit after shouting question about Jensen Huang
The evening briefing by email
One email a day, around 8:30 p.m. New York time: the seven main stories, each with its three sides, and the blind spot of the day. Unsubscribe with one tap.
A Telegram channel is coming soon.