Houston mayor orders police to limit contact with ICE on minor offenses
Mayor John Whitmire says 'elections matter' after Democrats won Texas races, while a Homeland Security spokesperson says the department is disappointed by limits on ICE cooperation.
Houston Mayor John Whitmire, a Democrat, signed an on Friday limiting how city police cooperate with federal immigration authorities. He heralded "a new model" of enforcement. The Associated Press reports that under the directive, police should contact Immigration and Customs Enforcement, or , only if a person they stop is arrested on a jailable charge or if ICE issues an administrative warrant.
The Center Square reports that after the signing, Police Chief Noe Diaz sent a department-wide memo, and that Diaz said, "ICE will only be contacted if someone commits a jailable offense." Whitmire said a traffic stop would end with a citation or a warning, with no ICE contact over nonviolent offenses. The move follows Tuesday's elections, in which Republican Gov. Greg Abbott lost to Democrat Gina Hinojosa.
Whitmire said "elections matter." The Center Square reports that Abbott had threatened to cut state funding over police policies in Democratic-run cities, and Houston revised its rules. A Department of spokesperson told Fox News Digital the department is disappointed by politicians who limit cooperation with ICE.
ICE spokespersons did not immediately respond to an email seeking comment.
- $75 billion one-time infusion for ICE from Congress — The Seattle Times
- about 2,600 agreements deputizing local police and other agencies to enforce immigration laws — The Seattle Times
- more than $100 million state funding Abbott threatened to withhold, per Fox News — Fox News
Three sides of the story
Liberal8 outlets
Whitmire's shift, set against Houston's ICE incidents
The Guardian's version of the Associated Press report opens with Whitmire's promise of "a new model" of enforcement after Democrats won power in Texas. It adds Houston context: ICE agents shot and killed Lorenzo Salgado Araujo during a July traffic stop, and a neighbor told the paper, "We feel it on a level we can't even describe." It also reports the of ICE officer Mario Alberto Morales and quotes Cesar Espinosa of Fiel Houston saying, "Today Houston won."
PBS NewsHour headlines the mayor's "Elections matter" and calls the change one of the first actions to restrict ICE since Democrats' "rout" in Tuesday's midterms. The New York Times headline says Houston police will stop alerting ICE during traffic stops. The Times reports that Whitmire has told officers not to alert immigration agents to people without legal status met in ordinary street stops.
Center5 outlets
The signed order and its exact terms
The Seattle Times runs the AP report under a headline saying Whitmire signs an order limiting ICE cooperation and says "elections matter" after Democrats win. It sets out the terms: contact with ICE only after a jailable arrest or with an administrative warrant, which it defines as an order signed by a senior ICE official. It quotes the order's line that suspected immigration status "shall not, by itself, be a basis to contact ICE."
The report adds that ICE did not immediately respond, notes the indictment of officer Mario Alberto Morales and ICE's competing account of the incident, and describes ICE's reliance on local police under about 2,600 agreements. Border Report carries the same headline. It reports that the mayor directed police on Friday to limit cooperation with federal immigration authorities, in an order he described as a direct outcome of the Democratic return to power in Texas.
Conservative8 outlets
Democratic sweep prompts Whitmire's early anti-ICE directive
The Center Square calls it an "anti-ICE directive" issued days after Democrats swept state government leadership. It quotes Whitmire on reducing "fear and anxiety" and reports that Police Chief Noe Diaz sent a department-wide memo after the signing, with Diaz saying, "ICE will only be contacted if someone commits a jailable offense." It also reports Abbott's earlier funding threat and says Democratic-led cities are expected to adopt similar policies.
Fox News says Whitmire "bolts early" from ICE cooperation after a "blue wave" and notes that Gov.-elect Gina Hinojosa does not take office until January. It quotes a DHS spokesperson, who says the department is disappointed by "sanctuary politicians" and names convicted people ICE arrested in Houston. Just the News, citing the AP, reports that Whitmire "vows" to limit cooperation after the state flipped blue.
It also reports that the Harris 's Office indicted an ICE agent in a separate incident.
- The Center Square: Days after Democrats sweep state government leadership, Houston mayor issues anti-ICE directive
- Fox News: Houston mayor bolts early from ICE cooperation after blue wave crashes in Texas
- Just the News: Democratic Houston Mayor vows to limit the city's cooperation with federal immigration authorities
Which side made the stronger case?
- Centrist outlets did not mentionIn April, Gov. Abbott threatened to withhold more than $100 million in state grants and Houston revised its ICE policy. Reported by MS NOW, Fox News, RedState, The Center Square, The Daily Wire
- Liberal outlets did not mentionGov.-elect Gina Hinojosa does not take office until January, so Abbott remains governor for about two more months. Reported by Fox News, RedState, The Center Square, The Daily Wire
- Centrist outlets did not mentionGov.-elect Gina Hinojosa does not take office until January, so Abbott remains governor for about two more months. Reported by Fox News, RedState, The Center Square, The Daily Wire
The order changes what Houston police do when they stop someone. Whitmire said a traffic stop would end with a citation or warning and no contact with ICE. Under the order, as AP reports it, police would still contact ICE if the person is arrested on a jailable charge or if ICE has an administrative warrant.
All sources: 21 articles from 21 outlets
Liberal (8)
- Al Jazeera English: Houston mayor curbs cooperation of US city’s police with ICE
- HuffPost: Houston Mayor Signs Order To Limit Cooperation With ICE
- MS NOW: ‘Elections matter’: Houston mayor rolls back police cooperation with ICE
- PBS NewsHour: WATCH: 'Elections matter.' Houston mayor limits police cooperation with ICE
- The Boston Globe: Houston mayor signs order to limit cooperation with ICE, says ‘elections matter’ after Democrats win
- The Guardian (US): Houston to limit police cooperation with federal immigration authorities
- Yahoo News: Houston mayor says 'elections matter' as he moves to curb city's cooperation with ICE
Center (5)
- BBC News: Texas mayor instructs police to limit cooperation with ICE
- Border Report: Houston mayor signs order to limit cooperation with ICE, says 'elections matter' after Democrats win
- NewsNation: Houston mayor narrows ICE cooperation after midterms: 'Elections matter'
- The Hill: Houston mayor looks to limit city's cooperation with ICE after Democrats' wins in Texas
- The Seattle Times: Houston mayor signs order to limit cooperation with ICE, says ‘elections matter’ after Democrats win
Conservative (8)
- Fox News: Houston mayor bolts early from ICE cooperation after blue wave crashes in Texas
- Just the News: Democratic Houston Mayor vows to limit the city's cooperation with federal immigration authorities
- New York Post: Houston mayor John Whitmire reverses course on ICE cooperation after blue wave crashes in Texas
- RedState: That Was Fast: Houston Mayor Kneecaps Police Department's Cooperation With ICE
- The Center Square: Days after Democrats sweep state government leadership, Houston mayor issues anti-ICE directive
- The Daily Wire: Texas Mayor Rolls Back ICE Cooperation After Blue Wave
- The Post Millennial: Houston mayor ENDS cooperation with ICE for illegal aliens with non-jailable infractions
- Washington Examiner: Houston mayor limits police cooperation with ICE after blue wave
The morning edition by email
One email a day: the three main stories, each with its three sides. No ads. Unsubscribe with one tap.
A Telegram channel is coming soon.