White House pulls FDA nominee Heidi Overton a day before Senate committee vote
A senior White House official says she lacks the support to be confirmed, while committee chairman Sen. Bill Cassidy had said he was undecided.
The White House withdrew its nomination of Dr. Heidi Overton to lead the Food and Drug Administration on Tuesday, Nov. 17, a day before the health committee was to vote. Overton, a physician and White House domestic policy adviser, was nominated by President Trump in August. A senior White House official told Axios she "lacks the support on the Hill" to be confirmed.
According to the Associated Press, she needed all 12 Republicans on the committee, since Democrats hold 11 seats. Committee chairman Sen. Bill Cassidy, a Louisiana Republican, had said he was undecided. He earlier called her support for Trump's plan to split combination vaccines "almost disqualifying."
The has had no Senate-confirmed leader since Marty Makary left the post in May. Kyle Diamantas leads it as acting commissioner. Democrats will take control of the Senate in January.
CBS News, citing two sources, says Sen. Roger Marshall, a Kansas Republican and doctor who lost his reelection bid in November, is making a play for the job. MS NOW, citing Semafor, says the administration was considering him. Whether the White House would name another nominee, and when, was not immediately known.
- 12 RepublicansRepublican votes Overton needed on the committee, by the Associated Press's accountThe Seattle Times
- 11 seatsheld by Democrats on the Senate health committee, by the Associated Press's accountThe Seattle Times
Three sides of the story
26 news outlets reported this
Tap a color or swipe sideways to switch sides.
Liberal12 outlets
Cassidy's vaccine doubts and abortion-access stakes
The Boston Globe runs an Associated Press report that opens with the White House saying it pulled the nomination "amid growing indications" Overton lacked Senate votes. It stresses Cassidy's doubts on vaccines and opposition from influential figures in the Make America Healthy Again movement.
CBS News, citing a senior administration official and others familiar with the decision, reports the pullout and adds that Cassidy told the network late Tuesday he saw a possible route for her. Two sources tell CBS News that efforts to win enough Republican votes were still under way when the White House shared its decision. The Guardian quotes Mini Timmaraju of Reproductive Freedom for All, who says Overton "posed a serious threat to the future of medication abortion access."
It also cites her 2023 policy brief on mifepristone. MS NOW reports that the official gave no reason and recalls Makary telling Politico he witnessed and rejected "government corruption." CBS News says two sources indicate Sen. Roger Marshall is making a play for the job, and MS NOW, citing Semafor, says the administration was considering him.
- The Boston Globe: Overton window slams shut: White House withdraws Heidi Overton’s nomination to lead FDA
- CBS News: White House drops Heidi Overton's nomination for FDA commissioner
- The Guardian: White House withdraws nomination of Heidi Overton to lead FDA
- MS NOW: White House withdraws FDA nominee Heidi Overton amid GOP opposition
Center4 outlets
Hill opposition and her sidestepped hearing answers
UPI heads its piece "Reports:" and says Axios, CNN and NBC News reported the move, quoting the senior White House official's line that Overton "lacks the support on the Hill." It recounts her September hearing, where she sidestepped questions on vaccines, mifepristone and vapes, and notes Sen. Susan Collins was undecided. The Seattle Times runs the same Associated Press text as the Boston Globe, which opens with the White House saying it pulled the nomination amid indications she lacked the votes.
The Hill reports that the White House confirmed the withdrawal to it, and that Overton faced a key committee vote Wednesday where Republicans hold only a one-vote majority. The Journal's headline says officials had weighed pulling the nomination as senators raised concerns over vaccines, vaping and abortion.
- UPI: Reports: White House drops Overton as FDA leader nominee
- The Seattle Times: White House pulls FDA nominee Heidi Overton after wavering support from Senate Republicans
- The Hill: White House pulls nomination of Heidi Overton to lead FDA
- The Wall Street Journal: Trump officials has weighed whether to pull Heidi Overton’s FDA nomination as GOP senators raise concerns over her positions on vaccines, vaping and abortion
Conservative10 outlets
Her hearing answers and abortion-pill pressure
Townhall headlines "Window Closes on Overton" and opens with Axios's report quoting a senior administration official, then replays Cassidy's questioning on the MMR vaccine, which Overton called "safe and effective." It quotes Susan B. Anthony Pro-Life America: "Confirmation is not a coronation." Fox News opens with a White House official's confirmation and recalls Trump calling her a "ROCKSTAR" in August, her clash with Sen. Bernie Sanders, and questions from Democratic Sens. Maggie Hassan and Ed Markey.
It quotes Pro-Life America's Erik Baptist on mail-order abortion drugs. The Washington Examiner quotes a White House official, "Can confirm nomination pulled," and says MAHA supporters and anti-abortion activists had criticized her. Just the News, headlined "Report," quotes the official saying "We need to go in a new direction at FDA."
- Townhall: Window Closes on Overton: White House Pulls FDA Nominee
- Fox News: White House pulls Trump’s FDA pick Heidi Overton on eve of Senate panel vote
- Washington Examiner: White House withdraws Heidi Overton’s nomination to become next FDA commissioner
- Just the News: White House pulls Heidi Overton's nomination to lead Food and Drug Administration: Report
Which side made the stronger case?
We will email you when the story continues. At most one email a day.
- Votes Overton needed on the Senate health committee
- The Seattle Times, The Boston Globe, The Guardian: all 12 Republicans, with Democrats holding 11 seats
- UPI: 11 votes from a 21-member committee
All sources: 30 articles from 26 outlets
Liberal (15)
- ABC News: Trump's pick Heidi Overton dropped as nominee for FDA commissioner
- Axios: Scoop: White House drops Heidi Overton's FDA nomination
- CBS News: White House drops Heidi Overton's nomination for FDA commissioner
- CBS News: Trump FDA nominee Heidi Overton struggling to win GOP support
- MS NOW: As the window closes on Heidi Overton’s FDA nomination, she joins an unfortunate club
- MS NOW: White House withdraws FDA nominee Heidi Overton amid GOP opposition
- NBC News: White House drops Heidi Overton’s FDA nomination after Republicans raise concerns
- Semafor: FDA's long-term vacancy
- Semafor: White House pulls Overton's FDA nomination
- The Boston Globe: Overton window slams shut: White House withdraws Heidi Overton’s nomination to lead FDA
- The Daily Beast: Trump Forced Into Humiliating U-Turn Over FDA Pick
- The Guardian: White House withdraws nomination of Heidi Overton to lead FDA
- The Independent: White House pulls Trump’s FDA nominee on eve of key Senate vote
- Yahoo News: White House pulls Trump's pick to lead FDA as Republican support falters
Center (5)
- The Hill: Overton's confirmation over
- The Hill: White House pulls nomination of Heidi Overton to lead FDA
- The Seattle Times: White House pulls FDA nominee Heidi Overton after wavering support from Senate Republicans
- The Wall Street Journal: Trump officials has weighed whether to pull Heidi Overton’s FDA nomination as GOP senators raise concerns over her positions on vaccines, vaping and abortion
- UPI: Reports: White House drops Overton as FDA leader nominee
Conservative (10)
- Breitbart News: Report: White House Drops Heidi Overton's FDA Nomination as Roger Marshall Emerges as Potential Replacement
- Daily Caller: MAHA Rejoices After White House Drops Controversial FDA Nomination
- Fox News: White House pulls Trump’s FDA pick Heidi Overton on eve of Senate panel vote
- Just the News: White House pulls Heidi Overton's nomination to lead Food and Drug Administration: Report
- New York Post: White House withdraws Heidi Overton’s FDA nomination after Trump pick received bipartisan pushback
- The Daily Signal: ‘MAHA Won’: White House Withdraws FDA Commissioner Nomination
- The Epoch Times: White House Pulls Heidi Overton’s Nomination to Lead FDA
- The Washington Times: White House pulls FDA nominee Heidi Overton after wavering support from Senate Republicans
- Townhall: Window Closes on Overton: White House Pulls FDA Nominee
- Washington Examiner: White House withdraws Heidi Overton’s nomination to become next FDA commissioner
The evening briefing by email
One email a day, around 8:30 p.m. New York time: the seven main stories, each with its three sides, and the blind spot of the day. Unsubscribe with one tap.
A Telegram channel is coming soon.