Senate Republicans reelect Thune as leader and reject a push to delay the vote
Sen. Ron Johnson and a handful of colleagues sought a delay after the midterm losses, but Thune ran unopposed and will lead the minority.
Republicans reelected John Thune of South Dakota as their leader on Tuesday, after elections on Nov. 3 that cost the party at least seven Senate seats and the majority. Thune ran unopposed and takes over as Senate minority leader once the new begins in January. A handful of senators, led by Wisconsin Sen. Ron Johnson, had pushed to delay the leadership elections.
The conference voted to go ahead, and Johnson walked out as voting began. Johnson said his objection was not to Thune, whom he said the party's base has unfairly attacked. Fox News reports the vote to proceed was 31 to 15.
Several senators described the closed-door talks as frank, and no challenger to Thune emerged. The rest of the leadership team was also reelected, and Sen. Bernie Moreno of Ohio was chosen to head the party's Senate campaign arm. Two Senate races, in Alaska and Mississippi, remain uncalled.
Some Republicans have criticized Thune for declining to change rules to pass the SAVE America Act, a voter ID bill. Trump said Thune is "a very fine man" and that the choice was up to the Senate.
- at least sevenSenate seats Republicans lost in the midtermsCBS News
- 31 to 15vote to proceed with the election, by Fox News's accountFox News
- no more than 46senators in the GOP minority when Congress convenes, per New York PostNew York Post
- at least 54Senate seats Democrats will hold, per The Center SquareThe Center Square
Three sides of the story
23 news outlets reported this · Little coverage from liberal outlets
Tap a color or swipe sideways to switch sides.
Liberal5 outlets
Thune keeps his job as frustrated colleagues vent
The Philadelphia Inquirer and PBS NewsHour say senators vented in three separate meetings after an "election wipeout." The Inquirer quotes West Virginia Sen. Jim Justice on the "legitimate argument" against keeping the same leaders, and Missouri Sen. Josh Hawley asking what message ratifying them sends. CBS News stresses that Johnson secured signatures from four colleagues but that the delay effort fell short, and it quotes him saying "that kind of defeat demands change" while adding it was never against Thune.
Semafor says Republicans voted to proceed despite delay requests from a handful of members and that most opted against a "period of purgatory." CBS also notes Thune's tenure included two record-breaking and tension with the White House. The Inquirer quotes Thune's floor speech saying Americans are not seeking "socialist government and leftist fantasies."
- The Philadelphia Inquirer: Senate Republicans vote to keep Thune as leader after steep election losses
- CBS News: Thune wins reelection as Senate GOP leader after midterms losses
- Semafor: Senate Republicans defeat push for delays, reelect Thune leader
- PBS NewsHour: Senate Republicans vote to keep Thune as leader after election wipeout
Center4 outlets
Thune wins uncontested despite a push to delay
Roll Call reports that Thune and the other leaders were elected by voice vote after the elections were pushed back by a few hours. It describes a morning conference meeting held at the request of five senators led by Ron Johnson. Several senators called that meeting "frank," and it pushed the elections back by a few hours.
Roll Call gives space to Johnson, who says "This has never been anything against John Thune," and to Josh Hawley. It also quotes Rand Paul, who says voters were reacting to gas prices, the Iran war and the cost of living, and Bernie Moreno, the new chair of the Senate campaign arm. Newsweek leads with what Trump has said of Thune, quoting him calling Thune "a very fine man."
It adds Thune's statement on X and House Republicans' choice of Jim Jordan over Steve Scalise as minority leader. The Hill reports that Thune won by acclamation after a "bruising showdown" with conservative critics. The Journal reports that Thune won re-election as head of the GOP conference and that Trump had pressed him for months over the SAVE America Act.
- Roll Call: Thune will lead Republicans through the minority
- Newsweek: What Trump Has Said of John Thune as Senate Minority Leader Elected by GOP
- The Hill: Thune elected Senate GOP leader after bruising showdown with critics
- The Wall Street Journal: Senate Majority Leader John Thune (R., S.D.) won re-election Tuesday as the head of the GOP conference next year
Conservative14 outlets
Rebellion fizzles and Thune keeps power
Fox News heads its report that the Senate GOP "rebellion fizzles." It reports that Johnson's attempt to delay failed on a 31 to 15 vote and that the closed-door talks lasted more than seven hours. It quotes Johnson saying "This has never been anything against John Thune" and gives Hawley space to criticize the party's record.
The New York Post opens with a "contentious hours-long meeting." It says Thune will lead a minority of no more than 46 senators, quotes Rand Paul describing "mostly dissent" and Jim Justice on the case for new leadership, and recalls the 37-10 vote by which McConnell beat Rick Scott in 2022. The Blaze calls the episode a "mini-revolt," says the effort "petered out" and describes Thune's "quasi-coronation."
The Center Square reports the reelection together with the other leadership results, Thune's statement, and Democrats holding at least 54 Senate seats. Thune's statement about holding the line against Democrats' "far-left, liberal agenda" appears in The Blaze and The Center Square.
- Fox News: Senate GOP rebellion fizzles as Thune keeps power despite historic midterm massacre
- New York Post: Senate Republicans re-elect John Thune as leader after midterm shellacking
- The Blaze: John Thune will continue leading Senate Republicans despite mini-revolt against him
- The Center Square: Thune reelected as Senate Republican leader
Which side made the stronger case?
We will email you when the story continues. At most one email a day.
All sources: 38 articles from 23 outlets
Liberal (6)
- Al Jazeera English: John Thune re-elected as US Senate Republican leader after midterm losses
- CBS News: Thune wins reelection as Senate GOP leader after midterms losses
- PBS NewsHour: Senate Republicans vote to keep Thune as leader after election wipeout
- PBS NewsHour: WATCH LIVE: Senate considers bills on permitting, survivor justice as GOP mulls future leadership
- Semafor: Senate Republicans defeat push for delays, reelect Thune leader
- The Philadelphia Inquirer: Senate Republicans vote to keep Thune as leader after steep election losses
Center (9)
- Newsweek: What Trump Has Said of John Thune as Senate Minority Leader Elected by GOP
- Roll Call: Thune will lead Republicans through the minority
- Roll Call: Senate Republicans lament midterms, weigh leadership election delay
- The Hill: Thune elected Senate GOP leader after bruising showdown with critics
- The Hill: Ron Johnson threatens walkout of Senate GOP leadership election
- The Hill: Johnson, staunch Trump ally, seeks to delay Senate GOP leadership election after big losses
- The Wall Street Journal: “The ass-kicking we needed.” South Carolina Republicans assess the damage and weigh their prospects. “That party we built? That party doesn’t exist anymore,” says a former GOP governor.
- The Wall Street Journal: ‘The Ass-Kicking We Needed’: A Loss in GOP Heartland Exposes a Party in Pieces
- The Wall Street Journal: Senate Majority Leader John Thune (R., S.D.) won re-election Tuesday as the head of the GOP conference next year
Conservative (23)
- Breitbart News: 'We Got Thumped in the Election': McCormick Says Republicans Have to Seek Accountability for Midterm Losses
- Breitbart News: Senate Republicans Elect John Thune Minority Leader Despite Historic Electoral Losses
- Fox News: Senate GOP rebellion fizzles as Thune keeps power despite historic midterm massacre
- Just the News: Senate Republicans pauses leadership votes to hear demands from members about lame duck strategy
- Just the News: You Vote: GOP in the House picked Jim Jordan as its leader, Senate picked John Thune. What say you?
- Just the News: Ron Johnson seeks delay in Senate Republican leadership election after big losses in the midterms
- New York Post: Senate Republicans re-elect John Thune as leader after midterm shellacking
- RedState: Not So Fast: Republicans Seek to Slow Down Any Vote for Senate Minority Leader
- The American Conservative: Thune Keeps Job as Senate GOP Leader
- The Blaze: John Thune will continue leading Senate Republicans despite mini-revolt against him
- The Center Square: Thune reelected as Senate Republican leader
- The Daily Signal: Scott Jennings, Spencer Pratt Break Down GOP Midterm Losses
- The Daily Signal: Scott Jennings, Spencer Pratt Break Down GOP Midterm Losses
- The Daily Signal: Roberts Blames GOP Communication for Blue Wave, Calls Thune ‘Feckless’
- The Daily Signal: Senate Republican Walks Out as GOP Leadership Fight Comes to a Head
- The Daily Signal: Senators Try to Slow GOP Leadership Vote
- The Daily Wire: GOP Senators Stick With Thune Despite Calls For Post-Election Reckoning
- The Federalist: Senate Republicans Double Down On John Thune’s Failed Leadership
- The Washington Times: Senate Republicans reelect Thune as top leader, rejecting push to delay internal election
- The Washington Times: Republicans leave closed-door meeting without a decision on whether to reelect John Thune as leader
- Townhall: Sen. Ron Johnson Moves to Postpone Senate Leadership Elections
- Washington Examiner: Thune reelected as Senate GOP leader after failed push to delay vote
- Washington Examiner: Ron Johnson presses to delay Senate GOP leadership elections: ‘Political malpractice’
The evening briefing by email
One email a day, around 8:30 p.m. New York time: the seven main stories, each with its three sides, and the blind spot of the day. Unsubscribe with one tap.
A Telegram channel is coming soon.