Sen. Ron Johnson says Social Security should be shut down, then calls remark imprecise
The Wisconsin Republican, who chairs the Senate Budget Committee, called the program a Ponzi scheme on Fox Business, and Democrats condemned the remark.
Sen. Ron Johnson, a Wisconsin Republican who chairs the Budget Committee, said on Fox Business on Wednesday, Nov. 18, that there is "no way to fix ." He called it a Ponzi scheme and said it should be shut down. On Newsmax he said the program fits the Securities and Exchange Commission's definition of a Ponzi scheme.
Johnson had written a report titled "Social Security: The Reality… a Legal Ponzi Scheme" ahead of a Budget Committee hearing that day. It projects that the program becomes insolvent in 2032, with a roughly $511 billion shortfall. Fox News reports the report calls for repealing the part of the law that reduces benefits.
According to Washington Examiner, Johnson told the hearing he made an "imprecise statement" and is not proposing to shut down Social Security. The Hill also reports he called his comments "imprecise." Sen. Ron Wyden, an Oregon Democrat, said it was the first time in decades that the Budget Committee chairman said he would rather shut down the program than fix it.
Sen. Tammy Baldwin, a Wisconsin Democrat, said Social Security is not a Ponzi scheme. Johnson is up for reelection in 2028. The Daily Beast says he has not said whether he will run.
- $511 billionprojected Social Security shortfall in 2032, per Johnson's reportFox News
- 2032year Social Security is expected to become insolvent, per Johnson's reportJust the News
- 6.2%share of each paycheck deducted for Social Security, per Johnson's reportJust the News
- $184,500income above which Americans would pay tax on their entire income under the Moreno-Warren proposalHuffPost
- 93%Americans who called Social Security a valuable program in a Bipartisan Policy Center poll, per MS NOWMS NOW
Three sides of the story
15 news outlets reported this
Tap a color or swipe sideways to switch sides.
Liberal4 outlets
Johnson's remark as a gift to Democrats
The Daily Beast says Johnson "sparked an uproar" and builds the piece on reactions. Jon Favreau of Pod Save America sarcastically cheers a "strong start" to the 2028 campaign, Democratic strategist Donna Brazile says he "has lost his mind," and Sen. Tammy Baldwin answers that Social Security is not a Ponzi scheme. HuffPost's headline carries Johnson's "just shut it down" and sets it against a coming fight over the program's funds.
It recalls his past push to make Social Security and funding "discretionary" and the Moreno-Warren plan to remove the cap on taxed income. MS NOW looks ahead to 2028, noting Johnson won in 2022 by 1 percentage point and that a Bipartisan Policy Center poll found 93% of Americans call the program valuable. It says his quotes "seem practically engineered" for campaign attack ads.
Center7 outlets
Johnson's call to shut down Social Security
According to The Hill, Johnson, who chairs the Senate Budget Committee, said there is "no way to fix" Social Security and called for it to be shut down, then later described his comments as "imprecise." A MarketWatch headline says a Republican senator contends Social Security "should be shut down," and adds that Social Security's trust funds are projected to be depleted within the next six years.
Conservative4 outlets
Johnson's report on how Social Security works
Washington Examiner says Johnson "faces heat" after Democrats accused him of "throwing in the towel." It gives his answer at the hearing, an "imprecise statement," and his words that he is not proposing to shut the program down. It quotes Sens. Ron Wyden and Catherine Cortez Masto and cites a Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget analysis of possible benefit cuts.
Fox News opens with "First on Fox" and Johnson's report, which says Americans are being "scammed," that a collapsing Ponzi scheme "can't be fixed," and that the part of the law that reduces benefits should be repealed. Just the News headlines the $511 billion shortfall and 2032 insolvency. A second piece quotes Johnson's memo calling Social Security a "legal Ponzi scheme" and reports his warning that some Democratic proposals would do more harm than good.
- Washington Examiner: Ron Johnson faces heat for saying ‘no way to fix Social Security’
- Fox News: Americans misled on Social Security for decades as clock counts down on benefits, explosive report reveals
- Just the News: Social Security will be insolvent in 6 years, with a $511 billion shortfall: report
- Just the News: Sen. Ron Johnson blasts Social Security as 'legal Ponzi scheme'
- Liberal outlets did not mentionJohnson called his remark imprecise and said he is not proposing to shut down Social Security Reported by The Hill, Washington Examiner
- Liberal outlets did not mentionJohnson's report titled "Social Security: The Reality… a Legal Ponzi Scheme" and its $511 billion shortfall projection Reported by Fox News, Washington Examiner, Just the News, Just the News
Which side made the stronger case?
We will email you when the story continues. At most one email a day.
The Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget, cited by Washington Examiner, found that Social Security recipients could see monthly checks cut by $500 by 2032. Washington Examiner quotes the same group saying the Congressional Budget Office projects a 26% benefit cut upon insolvency. Under the bipartisan Moreno-Warren proposal, HuffPost says anyone earning more than $184,500 would have all their income taxed.
All sources: 19 articles from 15 outlets
Liberal (6)
- CNBC: What Ron Johnson's 'Ponzi scheme' label gets wrong about Social Security, experts say
- HuffPost: GOP Senator Calls Social Security A 'Ponzi Scheme': 'Just Shut It Down'
- MS NOW: Voters were loud and clear on Election Day. Ron Johnson wasn’t listening. (opinion)
- MS NOW: The problem(s) with Ron Johnson trying to walk back his call for Social Security’s elimination
- MS NOW: GOP’s Ron Johnson condemns Social Security, says he wants to ‘shut it down’
- The Daily Beast: Vulnerable MAGA Senator Says Beloved Service Should Be ‘Shut Down’
Center (8)
- MarketWatch: Ron Johnson’s Social Security gaffe buried important news
- MarketWatch: Social Security should be shut down, this Republican senator says
- NewsNation: Sen. Ron Johnson calls Social Security a 'Ponzi scheme'
- Newsweek: Ron Johnson in Hot Water for Social Security 'Legal Ponzi Scheme' Remark
- Roll Call: Tempers flare as future of Social Security debated
- The Hill: Ron Johnson: Remark about shutting down Social Security was 'imprecise'
- The Wall Street Journal: Opinion | Ron Johnson Tells the Social Security Truth (opinion)
- UPI: Senators struggle over future of Social Security retirement benefits
Conservative (5)
- Fox News: Americans misled on Social Security for decades as clock counts down on benefits, explosive report reveals
- Just the News: Sen. Ron Johnson blasts Social Security as 'legal Ponzi scheme'
- Just the News: Social Security will be insolvent in 6 years, with a $511 billion shortfall: report
- The Post Millennial: Senator Ron Johnson calls Social Security a ‘Legal Ponzi Scheme,’ warns of coming $511 BILLION shortfall
- Washington Examiner: Ron Johnson faces heat for saying ‘no way to fix Social Security’
The evening briefing by email
One email a day, around 8:30 p.m. New York time: the seven main stories, each with its three sides, and the blind spot of the day. Unsubscribe with one tap.
A Telegram channel is coming soon.