Republican Sen. Cornyn blocks Trump's pick for a Dallas federal judgeship
Cornyn says Justice Department official Elliot Gaiser is not from Texas and was not vetted, while Sen. Ted Cruz warns Democrats would get the seat.

Sen. John Cornyn, a Texas Republican who lost his primary and is leaving office, said on Wednesday, Nov. 18, that he will not return his blue slip for T. Elliot Gaiser, President Trump's nominee for a federal judgeship in the Dallas area. Gaiser heads the 's Office of Legal Counsel. Under custom, a home-state senator can effectively veto a district court nominee this way.
Cornyn says Gaiser is not from Texas and was not vetted, and that the White House did not consult the Senate. CBS News reports Gaiser was not among the seven nominees at Wednesday's Judiciary Committee hearing. Cornyn is urging the White House to pick Fort Worth lawyer Steve Fahey instead.
Sen. Ted Cruz, also a Texas Republican, supports Gaiser. He says that if the committee does not move him forward, the seat would effectively go to Democrats, who he says would keep it vacant. Democrats take control of the Senate on January 3.
A White House official said the administration anticipates that all of Trump's judicial picks will be confirmed by year-end. The Independent reports the Justice Department said Cornyn's "political antics" hurt the public and the rule of law.
- sevencandidates for federal judgeships who testified at Wednesday's Judiciary Committee hearing, per CBS NewsCBS News
- January 3date Democrats take control of the SenateYahoo News
- Nov. 4day Cruz's staff first contacted Gaiser about the vacancy, per his questionnaireThe Independent
Three sides of the story
17 news outlets reported this
Tap a color or swipe sideways to switch sides.
Liberal6 outlets
Cornyn's blue-slip veto and the Cornyn-Cruz clash
CBS News leads with Cornyn blocking Gaiser and has him say, "I think his nomination is no longer viable." It adds that Gaiser was not among the seven nominees at the hearing and lists criticized legal opinions he wrote at the Office of Legal Counsel. The Independent leads with the block and gives the Justice Department's statement that Cornyn's "political antics only hurt the American public and the rule of law."
It also quotes Cruz calling Gaiser the "only nominee who could actually be confirmed" by the end of 2026. The New Republic frames it as a shouting match on the Senate floor, quoting Cornyn telling Cruz, "I'm mad at you!" A Reuters report carried by Yahoo News calls the block a setback for Trump's push to confirm judges before Democrats take over, and ties it to the withdrawn Rudofsky nomination in Arkansas.
- CBS News: Cornyn blocks Trump's nominee to federal district court in Texas
- The Independent: GOP senator blocks Trump’s pick for court vacancy in Texas by withholding ‘blue slip’
- The New Republic: “That’s Bullsh*t”: John Cornyn and Ted Cruz Get Into Shouting Match
- Yahoo News: Republican senator blocks Trump's judicial nominee as Democrats prepare to take over
Center4 outlets
Fresh intraparty resistance to Trump's judicial push
Newsweek opens with Trump's judge-confirmation drive meeting "fresh resistance" from his own party. It says the move drew backlash from Republicans including Cruz, and it explains the blue slip in a section headed "Why Did Cornyn Block Trump's Nominee?" It ends with what happens next as the window before Democrats take the Senate narrows.
The Seattle Times runs an Associated Press report that leads with Cornyn saying he will block one of Trump's final judicial picks. It quotes him: "He's a very bright young man," but he feels Gaiser has been "used basically as a pawn." It gives Fahey's career and notes Cornyn's complaint that no bipartisan Texas panel vetted Gaiser.
A Journal opinion piece titled "John Cornyn's Blue Slip Decision" asks whether Gaiser will get a Senate vote.
- Newsweek: Fury as Republican Senator Blocks Trump's Conservative Judge Nomination
- The Seattle Times: Cornyn blocks top Justice Department official nominated for judicial vacancy in Texas
- The Wall Street Journal: Opinion | John Cornyn’s Blue Slip Decision (opinion)
Conservative7 outlets
Cruz defends Gaiser while Cornyn is faulted
The Federalist leads with the charge that Cornyn "threatens to sink" Gaiser. It says he is punishing the Trump administration for his primary loss and sets this against his past votes for Biden-era nominees such as Merrick Garland.
The Washington Examiner leads with Cruz urging Cornyn to advance Gaiser, whom he calls "exceptionally well qualified." It adds a source calling the Fahey proposal a "red herring" and a Cornyn aide saying he wanted a Texan with trial experience. It also notes that Sen.-elect James Talarico could use the blue slip himself.
The Daily Caller places the block among other Republican pushback, with Sens. Alan Armstrong and Thom Tillis, and the Arkansas senators on Rudofsky. The Washington Times opens with Cornyn's vow to block a late Trump court pick while the Republican-led Senate hurries to fill court vacancies before Democrats take over.
- The Federalist: After Voting For Biden Cronies Like Merrick Garland, Cornyn Threatens To Sink Trump Judicial Nominee
- Washington Examiner: Cruz and Cornyn at odds over judicial vacancy in Texas
- Daily Caller: Sen. Cornyn Uses Final Months In Office To Block Trump Judicial Nominee
- The Washington Times: Cornyn blocks top Justice Department official nominated for judicial vacancy in Texas
Which side made the stronger case?
We will email you when the story continues. At most one email a day.
All sources: 19 articles from 17 outlets
Liberal (6)
- CBS News: Cornyn blocks Trump's nominee to federal district court in Texas
- PBS NewsHour: Cornyn blocks top Justice Department official nominated for judicial vacancy in Texas
- The Guardian: John Cornyn blocks Trump judicial nominee after Senate shouting match with Ted Cruz
- The Independent: GOP senator blocks Trump’s pick for court vacancy in Texas by withholding ‘blue slip’
- The New Republic: “That’s Bullsh*t”: John Cornyn and Ted Cruz Get Into Shouting Match
- Yahoo News: Republican senator blocks Trump's judicial nominee as Democrats prepare to take over
Center (5)
- Newsweek: Ted Cruz Says Democrats Are in 'Civil War' After Cornyn Clash
- Newsweek: Fury as Republican Senator Blocks Trump's Conservative Judge Nomination
- The Hill: Cornyn blocks Trump's nomination to federal district court because he didn't choose a Texan
- The Seattle Times: Cornyn blocks top Justice Department official nominated for judicial vacancy in Texas
- The Wall Street Journal: Opinion | John Cornyn’s Blue Slip Decision (opinion)
Conservative (8)
- Breitbart News: Cornyn Refuses Blue Slip for Trump’s Dallas Judicial Pick: ‘Not a Texan’
- Daily Caller: Sen. Cornyn Uses Final Months In Office To Block Trump Judicial Nominee
- RedState: Cornyn Pulls One Final Bad Move With a Trump Judicial Nominee
- The Epoch Times: Cornyn Blocks Trump’s Nominee for Texas Federal Judgeship
- The Federalist: After Voting For Biden Cronies Like Merrick Garland, Cornyn Threatens To Sink Trump Judicial Nominee
- The Federalist: John Cornyn’s Vendetta Against Trump Could Cost Texas An Excellent Judge
- The Washington Times: Cornyn blocks top Justice Department official nominated for judicial vacancy in Texas
- Washington Examiner: Cruz and Cornyn at odds over judicial vacancy in Texas
The evening briefing by email
One email a day, around 8:30 p.m. New York time: the seven main stories, each with its three sides, and the blind spot of the day. Unsubscribe with one tap.
A Telegram channel is coming soon.