Pregnant US citizen says ICE agents pepper-sprayed her and threw her down in California
Her attorney shared video of the Nov. 15 arrest in Modesto and says she was released without charges.
Lizbeth Vargas Andrade, a 23-year-old US citizen who is 12 weeks pregnant, says Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents pepper-sprayed her, threw her to the ground and handcuffed her on Sunday, Nov. 15, outside the Stanislaus Jail in Modesto, California. Her attorney, Patrick Kolasinski, shared video filmed by her husband, Adolfo Talavera, in which he shouts that she is pregnant. Vargas Andrade says she monitors activity and was protesting as agents moved to detain a man who had just left the jail.
She says she and an agent bumped into each other and denies assaulting him, as she says agents accused her of doing. She was taken to an ICE office in Stockton and held for several hours, then released without charges, according to Kolasinski. Doctors at a hospital found her baby unharmed, she says.
The Department of did not immediately respond to requests for comment. A spokesperson for the Stanislaus sheriff's office said its deputies were not involved in the arrest. Kolasinski said the family is weighing its next legal steps.
- over 500 citizensheld by immigration agents since Trump's return to office, per a ProPublica investigation published in OctoberNewsweek
Three sides of the story
10 news outlets reported this · Little coverage from conservative outlets
Tap a color or swipe sideways to switch sides.
Liberal6 outlets
A citizen's account and video of ICE force
The Daily Beast leads with ICE agents "accused of" pepper-spraying a pregnant citizen and forcing her face-down, quoting Vargas Andrade's line "I was using all my rights to protest." It links the case to earlier allegations in Minneapolis. ABC News centers on Kolasinski's account and says the video does not show where the spray landed.
The Guardian walks through the footage in detail, notes the sound cuts out and the man's arrest is unexplained, and adds that the sheriff's office says its deputies were not involved. It also says many DHS and assault prosecutions of protesters in California have fallen apart in court. La Opinión, in Spanish, reports her account that she bumped an agent by accident and was held about five hours, and that DHS had issued no statement.
The Daily Beast and ABC News say they contacted DHS for comment.
- The Daily Beast: ICE Goons Accused of Throwing Pregnant Woman to the Ground
- ABC News: ICE agents accused of throwing pregnant US citizen to ground, pepper-spraying her
- The Guardian: ICE agents pepper spray pregnant US citizen in California, video shows
- La Opinión: Estadounidense embarazada sometida por agentes de ICE en California
Center4 outlets
Her attorney's claim and video of the arrest
Newsweek's headline, "Video Shows ICE Agent Pepper Spray Pregnant US Citizen: Lawyer," attributes the claim to her attorney and the footage. Its first paragraph repeats that attribution, and it then quotes Kolasinski's statement to Newsweek. It describes the video in detail: plainclothes agents in vests marked "POLICE," the spray canister, an agent pouring water over her face.
Newsweek sets the case within mounting scrutiny of Trump's campaign and points to an October ProPublica count of more than 500 citizens held by immigration agents since his return to office. It reports that it remains unclear who agents first sought to detain. It adds Vargas Andrade's account that she denies assaulting an agent, is diabetic, and that two agents stayed with her at the hospital and denied her access to an attorney.
Newsweek says it has contacted DHS and ICE.
Conservative0 outlets
Outlets on the right gave the story little coverage.
Which side made the stronger case?
We will email you when the story continues. At most one email a day.
All sources: 10 articles from 10 outlets
Liberal (6)
- ABC News: ICE agents accused of throwing pregnant US citizen to ground, pepper-spraying her
- Al Jazeera English: ICE agents shove and pepper-spray pregnant woman
- La Opinión: Estadounidense embarazada sometida por agentes de ICE en California
- The Daily Beast: ICE Goons Accused of Throwing Pregnant Woman to the Ground
- The Guardian: ICE agents pepper spray pregnant US citizen in California, video shows
- The New Republic: ICE Agents Pepper-Spray Pregnant Woman and Throw Her on the Ground
Center (4)
The evening briefing by email
One email a day, around 8:30 p.m. New York time: the seven main stories, each with its three sides, and the blind spot of the day. Unsubscribe with one tap.
A Telegram channel is coming soon.