New York Gov. Hochul demands answers from ICE on tent detention site for women
State agencies argue ICE failed to hold proper environmental consultations and public notifications before construction began on the Batavia site.

New York Gov. Kathy Hochul is demanding information from Immigration and Customs Enforcement and the construction firm Akima Infrastructure Protection about a new tent detention facility in Batavia, New York. It is set to house up to 100 women. Hochul's office released letters from the state Department of Environmental Conservation and Department of Health on Wednesday, Nov. 18.
The Hill reports the letter to Deputy Director Charles Wall was sent on Tuesday and concerns winter safety. The site is an addition to the Buffalo Service Processing Center, the largest immigration detention center in New York, which now holds only men. The agencies argue ICE neglected to properly coordinate or carry out environmental consultations and public notices before building began.
They are asking for answers on conditions, medical care, food and construction. Hochul told reporters the plan is "unconscionable" with winter approaching. Her office says ICE should not expand any of its facilities in New York.
Secretary Markwayne Mullin said in a letter that the facility is expected to cost about $8.7 million. State Sen. George Borrello, a Republican, said the expansion is a consequence of Hochul's own . A DHS spokesperson did not immediately respond to ABC News.
- up to 100 womenplanned capacity of the Batavia tent facility, per the letters Hochul releasedABC News
- about $8.7 millionexpected cost of the tent facility, per DHS Secretary Mullin's letterABC News
Three sides of the story
5 news outlets reported this
Tap a color or swipe sideways to switch sides.
Liberal1 outlet
State agencies press ICE for answers on conditions
ABC News leads with Hochul demanding information from ICE and the Virginia-based builder Akima Infrastructure Protection about a tent facility in Batavia set to house up to 100 women. It reports that two state agencies argue in letters that ICE failed to coordinate environmental consultations and public notifications before construction began. The agencies ask for answers on conditions, medical care, food and construction.
ABC adds the cost, about $8.7 million according to DHS Secretary Markwayne Mullin's letter, and places the site beside other soft-sided facilities. It recalls that Florida's "Alligator Alcatraz" closed earlier in 2026 after lawsuits and pressure, and that a September report found some detainees confined to small metal enclosures posing "significant risks." It notes lawsuits alleging medical neglect and poor conditions at Camp East Montana in Texas.
The two state commissioners are quoted writing that federal oversight agencies have "documented unsanitary conditions, gaps in medical services" at tent sites in Texas and Florida. ABC says a DHS spokesperson did not immediately respond.
Center2 outlets
Winter safety at the Batavia tent facility
The Hill reports that New York's Department of Health and Department of Environmental Conservation sent a letter on Tuesday to ICE Deputy Director Charles Wall about winter safety at the Batavia tent facility for women. The agencies say they are seeking information relating to Akima Infrastructure.
Conservative2 outlets
Hochul's outrage, and a Republican blaming her policies
The New York Post opens with Hochul having "fumed" at the Trump administration, and its headline says she "slams" ICE over a facility that "may be used" to detain female migrants. It quotes her calling a plan to put 100 women in a tent as winter approaches "unconscionable."
She said the administration gave no outreach about construction. Her spokesperson Alexia Nizhny says ICE should not expand any of its New York facilities and that the state will keep demanding "transparency and accountability." The Post sets this beside the 2023 Floyd Bennett Field tent shelter in Brooklyn, which it says cost taxpayers upwards of $41 million, and gives Hochul's office's answer that it avoided leaving vulnerable people "out in the cold."
The last word goes to State Sen. George Borrello, a Chautauqua Republican, who says Hochul "should start by looking in the mirror" and calls the expansion "a direct consequence of her own policies," tied to the state's sanctuary laws.
Which side made the stronger case?
We will email you when the story continues. At most one email a day.
All sources: 6 articles from 5 outlets
Liberal (2)
- ABC News: Auditors concerned about billions ICE is spending to expand immigration detention
- ABC News: Hochul demands information from ICE about new immigration tent facility for women
Center (2)
- Stateline: GAO prods ICE for new immigration detention plans
- The Hill: New York presses ICE on winter safety at tent facility for women
Conservative (2)
- New York Post: Hochul slams ICE for upstate NY facility that may be used to detain female migrants
- The Washington Times: Watchdog faults ICE over rush to build detention capacity
The evening briefing by email
One email a day, around 8:30 p.m. New York time: the seven main stories, each with its three sides, and the blind spot of the day. Unsubscribe with one tap.
A Telegram channel is coming soon.