Judge signals parts of the search warrant for Rep. Ilhan Omar's home will be unsealed
Chief Judge James Boasberg says most of the sworn affidavit should stay sealed for now, and Omar has not been charged with a crime.
Chief Judge James Boasberg of the federal court in Washington indicated Tuesday, Nov. 17, that parts of the search warrant for Rep. Ilhan Omar's home will likely be unsealed. Federal agents searched the Minnesota Democrat's Washington home on Oct. 12 in an immigration-related investigation. Omar has not been charged.
Boasberg agreed with the that the "vast majority" of the warrant affidavit, a sworn statement of the evidence, should stay sealed, and called releasing it "premature." He said the legal debate over the constitutional speech and debate protections for lawmakers should not be redacted. Fox News and the New York Post report that he gave prosecutors until Friday to propose redactions and plans to unseal material Monday.
The New York Post says that includes the partly redacted warrant and at least 12 other files, unless prosecutors object. Boasberg noted that Vice President JD Vance and other officials have publicly discussed the probe. Justice Department attorney Alessandra Serano answered that she had "zero control" over what they said.
Omar has called the search an attempt to target political enemies. Her attorney calls the investigation politically motivated, according to Newsweek.
- 67 pageslength of the sealed affidavit, according to the New York PostNew York Post
- at least 12 other filesdocket files Boasberg said he would unseal with the warrant, per the New York PostNew York Post
Three sides of the story
14 news outlets reported this · Little coverage from liberal outlets
Tap a color or swipe sideways to switch sides.
Liberal3 outlets
Boasberg's split stance on what stays sealed
NBC News leads with Boasberg agreeing that the "vast majority" of the affidavit should stay sealed while saying the back-and-forth over speech and debate rights should come out. It builds the piece around the courtroom exchange. Boasberg asks Justice Department attorney Alessandra Serano, "Why can't a bunch of this be unsealed now?" and notes that Vance and Trump have already named the type of investigation.
Serano says she had "zero control over what was said." NBC reports that the department wants the nature of any potential charges kept sealed, and that people familiar with the probe describe it as about potential immigration-related crimes. It quotes Omar calling the search "an attempt to target political enemies and weaponize federal law enforcement."
NBC also notes NBCUniversal News Group is in a coalition of media outlets asking to view the sealed search warrants.
Center3 outlets
What the hearing could decide, with background
Newsweek's piece, headlined "Judge Weighs Unsealing of Ilhan Omar Search Warrant," previews the hearing. It lays out Boasberg's Nov. 12 order asking the government to explain "why materials beyond the Affidavit itself cannot be unsealed." It lists what the news organizations want released and notes the Justice Department filed some arguments under seal.
Citing Reuters, Newsweek notes that the sealed warrant lists possible crimes: conspiracy, making false statements in immigration forms, and immigration fraud. It recounts the allegations about Omar's marriage, which she has denied, and the New York Times report on a 2016 and inquiry that ended over the statute of limitations. Trump and conservative critics made the claims "without providing evidence," it says.
Newsweek says the investigation's full scope remains unclear and sets out three options for the judge: keep records sealed, release some with redactions, or ask for more justification.
Conservative8 outlets
A setback for Trump's DOJ, with Obama-era probe
Fox News leads with an "Obama-appointed judge" who has often ruled against the Trump administration paving the way to unseal the warrant "in blow to Trump's DOJ." It reports the Friday deadline for redactions and the Monday release, and lists items seized, including Omar's phone, computer and passport. Fox adds that Omar's DNA was obtained and her sister was questioned.
It stresses that the DOJ under Obama opened a probe into her marriage in 2016, which it says suggests the nonpartisan nature of some inquiries into her. The New York Post says the "secrets" of the probe are set to be revealed. It reports the 67-page affidavit stays sealed and quotes Vance saying Omar "definitely committed immigration fraud."
It also quotes Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin and notes that Tom Homan has indicated the feds are building a "strong" case. The Post gives Serano's "zero control" answer to Boasberg.
Which side made the stronger case?
We will email you when the story continues. At most one email a day.
All sources: 15 articles from 14 outlets
Liberal (3)
- ABC News: Should court filings related to the search of Ilhan Omar's home be released? A judge will decide
- MS NOW: Federal judge orders release of some documents tied to search of Ilhan Omar’s home
- NBC News: Judge to order release of some records in federal search of Ilhan Omar’s home
Center (4)
- Newsweek: Judge Weighs Unsealing of Ilhan Omar Search Warrant
- Roll Call: Some records in Ilhan Omar case will be released, judge says
- Roll Call: Some records in Ilhan Omar case will be released, judge says
- The Hill: Judge agrees 'vast majority' of Omar investigation should remain sealed
Conservative (8)
- Daily Mail: Bombshell secrets collected on Ilhan Omar during FBI raid of her home to be made public
- Fox News: Obama-appointed judge paves way to unseal Ilhan Omar search warrant in blow to Trump's DOJ
- Just the News: Judge to order release of some records in feds search of Rep. Omar’s home, but not warrant affidavit
- New York Post: Ilhan Omar probe secrets set to be revealed after search warrant ordered released
- The Daily Wire: Judge Moves To Lift Secrecy Around Raid On Ilhan Omar’s Home
- The Washington Times: Should court filings related to the search of Ilhan Omar's home be released? A judge will decide
- Townhall: A Federal Judge Seals Most of the Ilhan Omar Affidavit, but It's Not a Judicial Coup Move
- Washington Examiner: Ilhan Omar search warrant records to be partially released
The evening briefing by email
One email a day, around 8:30 p.m. New York time: the seven main stories, each with its three sides, and the blind spot of the day. Unsubscribe with one tap.
A Telegram channel is coming soon.