Judge rules Meghan's father mentally fit to face child abuse images charge
Thomas Markle's lawyer did not contest a psychiatrist's finding, and his next hearing is Dec. 1 unless a grand jury indicts him first.
On Thursday, a federal judge in Tampa, Florida, decided that Thomas Markle, 82, the estranged father of Meghan, Duchess of Sussex, is mentally competent to answer a charge of possessing child sexual abuse material. The ruling rests on a report by Dr. Amie Gerodimos, a psychiatrist, who found he understands the charge against him and can help his lawyer. Markle's defense lawyer did not contest the finding.
In a 90-minute interview, Markle denied the allegations and blamed his son. The psychiatrist said he was at times exaggerating in his responses. Markle was arrested in Florida on Nov. 6.
The said in a court filing that a search of two Los Angeles-area storage units Markle rented turned up about 78 items, from slides and film negatives to books, with suspected child sexual abuse images. He was released, then jailed again on Nov. 10 after authorities accused him of cutting off his ankle monitor. In the Philippines, police filed a formal complaint on Monday, and prosecutors there will assess possible charges.
Markle has called the allegations "sick lies." His next court date is a preliminary hearing on Dec. 1 unless a him before then, and a trial is expected in California.
- approximately 78items seized from storage units in the Los Angeles area, per the FBIThe Independent
- 15-pagepsychiatrist's competency reportHuffPost
- 90-minuteinterview between Markle and the psychiatristHuffPost
- Dec. 1date of Markle's preliminary hearingCourthouse News
Three sides of the story
9 news outlets reported this · Little coverage from conservative outlets
Tap a color or swipe sideways to switch sides.
Liberal4 outlets
The competency ruling and Markle's own words
HuffPost ran an Associated Press report that opens on an expert's finding that Markle is mentally competent to face the charges. It quotes Markle from the psychiatrist's report, "I don't have any child porn," along with "My son hates me," and says the expert found he was "malingering" at times. The Independent's headline says the judge ruled him competent, and it uses the same quote from Markle.
It adds the prosecutor's voice, quoting First Assistant Bill Essayli saying the allegations are "extremely serious," and reports the Nov. 10 return to jail over the ankle monitor. Both give the FBI's account of the approximately 78 seized items and the Philippine police complaint, and both note The Sun's report that Meghan's half brother found the images in the Philippines home. The Boston Globe ran an Associated Press text, headlined on the competency question, that previews the hearing.
Center4 outlets
The ruling, with medical and legal detail
Courthouse News centers its account on the hearing and the psychiatrist's report. It quotes the psychiatrist's finding that Markle has "sufficient ability to understand the nature and consequences" of the charges. It reports the psychiatrist's finding of a mild neurocognitive disorder, most likely caused by a stroke, and presents his interview remarks, including "I am not an evil person."
BBC News reports that witnesses "positively identified" him in two images and says it understands Meghan broke contact with him. Newsweek, published ahead of the hearing, quotes lawyer Neama Rahmani on what a finding of incompetence would mean: "It's not a free pass." The Seattle Times ran an Associated Press text that previews the hearing and recounts the arrest and the FBI's seizure account.
- Courthouse News: Meghan Markle’s dad deemed competent in child abuse materials case
- BBC News: Judge finds Thomas Markle mentally fit to stand trial on child abuse charges
- Newsweek: Thomas Markle's Health: What To Know Ahead of Child Abuse Images Hearing
- The Seattle Times: Mental competency at issue in US criminal case against Meghan’s father
Conservative1 outlet
Courtroom scene and the family at the hearing
The New York Post's headline says Markle was "deemed competent to face child porn charges." It describes him in an orange jumpsuit and a wheelchair at the hearing. It reports that prosecutors accepted the report and that his lawyer, Mary Wolf, will not contest it now but may challenge his fitness for trial once the case moves to California.
It says the defense "vehemently denies" the allegations. The Post also reports that his daughter Samantha Markle attended with her partner, Mark Phillips, and quotes her saying he was "doing great, thanks." Phillips told the paper on his way into court it was "just another day in paradise."
It adds that Markle was arrested at the care home where he had been staying and was also hit with additional charges in the Philippines. It recaps the prosecutors' claims about two images and notes Markle has yet to enter a plea.
Which side made the stronger case?
We will email you when the story continues. At most one email a day.
All sources: 10 articles from 9 outlets
Liberal (5)
- HuffPost: Thomas Markle Competent To Face Child Sex Abuse Images Case, Expert Says
- The Boston Globe: Mental competency at issue in US criminal case against Meghan’s father
- The Guardian: Thomas Markle, Meghan’s father, is competent to face child sex abuse images case
- The Independent: Thomas Markle is competent to face child sexual abuse material charges, judge rules
- The Independent: Thomas Markle faces mental competency hearing in US criminal case
Center (4)
- BBC News: Judge finds Thomas Markle mentally fit to stand trial on child abuse charges
- Courthouse News: Meghan Markle’s dad deemed competent in child abuse materials case
- Newsweek: Thomas Markle's Health: What To Know Ahead of Child Abuse Images Hearing
- The Seattle Times: Mental competency at issue in US criminal case against Meghan’s father
Conservative (1)
The evening briefing by email
One email a day, around 8:30 p.m. New York time: the seven main stories, each with its three sides, and the blind spot of the day. Unsubscribe with one tap.
A Telegram channel is coming soon.