ABRAnews Open the whole story. Sign in

Italy fines Meta $887 million for accessing Android users' photos without specific consent

Italy's data protection authority gives Meta 60 days to disable the Facebook feature, and a Meta spokesperson told the BBC it plans to appeal.

Entrance to Meta Platforms headquarters in Menlo Park, California, in 2022
Entrance to Meta Platforms headquarters in Menlo Park, California, in 2022. Photo: LPS.1, CC0, Wikimedia Commons
Published 1 min read
Overview

Italy's data protection authority, the Garante, announced on Saturday a fine of €805 million ($887 million) on Meta. It says the Facebook app on Android phones accessed Italian users' photos, videos and related metadata without specific consent and without properly informing them. The feature at issue, called "Get suggestions from gallery when browsing Facebook," suggests gallery photos for posts.

The authority says it was enabled by default and that Facebook asked for gallery access through a single permission covering several functions. It says this violates the Italian law that implements the EU's ePrivacy directive. Meta has 60 days to disable the feature and ask users for separate consent.

The authority puts Italy's Android users at about 20 million. It says Meta's "lack of cooperation" weighed in the penalty, which is about 0.47% of the group's global turnover. Meta Platforms Ireland Limited, which disputed Italy's jurisdiction, was handed the fine.

Italian regulators rejected that argument, according to Deutsche Welle. Meta has denied using the feature to train artificial intelligence models, a matter the proceedings left unexamined. A Meta spokesperson told the BBC the company plans to appeal and strongly disagrees with the assessment.

Key figures
  • €805 million ($887 million)fine on Meta announced by Italy's data protection authorityABC News
  • 60 daystime Meta has to disable the feature and seek separate consentABC News
  • about 20 million Android usersin Italy, by the authority's figureABC News
  • approximately 0.47%share of the group's global turnover the fine representsABC News

Three sides of the story

8 news outlets reported this

Tap a color or swipe sideways to switch sides.

Liberal3 outlets

The fine, the consent violation and Italian precedent

Al Jazeera English leads with the fine and the Garante's statement that the Facebook app "accessed photos, videos and associated metadata" without specific consent. It adds that the consent process was too generic, the suggestions option was on by default, and an earlier violation that led to a 2019 fine counted in the decision. It calls the amount "by far the largest fine ever imposed by the Italian regulator" and says Meta has not publicly commented.

ABC News centers its report on the Android gallery photos and videos, with a subhead stating Meta broke a European privacy rule written into Italian law. It reports the 60-day deadline and that Meta Platforms Ireland Limited challenged Italy's jurisdiction. CBS News calls the penalty "among the largest" an Italian authority has imposed on a tech giant.

It sets it beside Amazon's 2021 fine, later cut to 752 million euros on appeal, and notes a $25 billion New Mexico order against Meta.

Center4 outlets

What we know, plus Meta's disagreement and jurisdiction dispute

BBC News leads with the fine and reports that a Meta spokesperson said the company planned to appeal. It quotes Meta: "We strongly disagree with the [regulator's] assessment of the facts." Meta calls the feature "straightforward" and says people must give permission on their device first.

The BBC also cites the regulator's "high number of people affected" and notes the $25bn New Mexico order. Deutsche Welle organizes its report under the heading "What do we know so far?" It says the investigation began in July 2025, that Meta has argued the case belongs under Irish jurisdiction, and that Italian regulators rejected this.

It adds that Meta has denied using the feature to train AI models, which Italy did not probe. The Hill describes the feature as on by default and requested through a single permission notice. NewsNation ties the fine to Meta's U.S. legal battles over children's use of its platforms.

Conservative1 outlet

Outlets on the right gave the story little coverage.

All sources: 8 articles from 8 outlets

Liberal (3)

Center (4)

Conservative (1)