House Republicans pick Jim Jordan as leader and block impeaching Defense Secretary Hegseth
Senate Republicans keep John Thune as leader, and lawmakers admit failure after their midterm losses but mostly avoid blaming President Trump.

Republicans returned to the Capitol for the first time since their losses, in which Democrats flipped more than 40 Republican-held House seats. Democrats will take control of and the in January. House Republicans chose Ohio Rep. Jim Jordan, a co-founder of the House Freedom Caucus and a Trump ally, as their next leader.
In the Senate, Republicans kept John Thune as leader without even a voice vote. Sen. Josh Hawley had unsuccessfully pushed to delay that election, but no rival came forward. Sen. Bernie Moreno was picked to head the party's push to reclaim seats in 2028.
House Republicans also voted down an attempt to Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth by a wide margin. Kentucky Rep. Thomas Massie, who pushed for it with Democrats, was the only Republican to split from the rest. Rep. Richard Hudson said voters wanted to send a message because gas was too high and things were too expensive.
Rep. Lauren Boebert said, "We collectively failed." Thune said the results came from "a combination of things" and did not directly blame Trump. NBC News reports that Sen. Thom Tillis said the administration treated the 2024 result as a mandate, adding, "We went too far."
HuffPost reports Trump named Stephen Miller as his chief of staff.
- more than 40Republican-held House seats Democrats flippedThe Seattle Times
- at least sevenSenate seats Republicans lost, by NBC News' countNBC News
- 74%voters who ranked the Iran war crucial or a major factor, NBC exit pollNBC News
- Sixty-four percentvoters who said Trump's tariffs hurt the economy in their areas, NBC exit pollNBC News
Three sides of the story
8 news outlets reported this · Little coverage from conservative outlets
Tap a color or swipe sideways to switch sides.
Liberal5 outlets
Republicans admit defeat but stay loyal to Trump
NBC News opens with Sen. Jim Justice saying Republicans "forgot those people out there are hurting," then shows lawmakers hesitating to blame Trump for the Iran war or . It cites NBC exit polls, with 74% of voters calling the Iran war crucial or a major factor. Sen. Thom Tillis is the one Republican it quotes saying "We went too far."
HuffPost's headline says voters rejected Trump and Republicans responded by "Lurching To The Right." It points to Jordan's election and Stephen Miller's appointment as chief of staff, and quotes Rep. Tom Emmer telling Democrats to "enjoy this honeymoon phase." It also gives Reps. Tim Burchett and Eric Burlison defending Jordan.
The Independent runs the wire report headlined "Republicans admit 'we failed'." It describes Republicans meeting behind closed doors, quotes Rep. Richard Hudson on high gas prices and quotes Massie saying Trump "still controls this conference." Yahoo News headlines its piece as saying the setback leaves some longtime supporters "questioning 's future."
- NBC News: Republicans tiptoe around Trump as they process defeat in the 2026 elections
- HuffPost: Voters Rejected Trump. Republicans Responded By Lurching To The Right.
- The Independent: Republicans admit ‘we failed’ but show little appetite for breaking with Trump after midterm losses
- Yahoo News: Trump's midterm setback leaves some longtime supporters questioning MAGA's future
Center2 outlets
Dazed Republicans regroup but won't break with Trump
The Seattle Times runs the AP report "Republicans dazed by midterm election defeats grapple with what went wrong." It opens with Rep. Richard Hudson saying voters came out to send a message about gas prices and costs. Under subheads, it covers little appetite for a full break with Trump, different approaches in the House and Senate, and Republicans uniting to protect Hegseth.
It quotes Sen. Bernie Moreno, "We're going to let our leader be the leader," and Massie, who says Trump "still controls this conference." It also lists signs of limits to Trump's influence. Few echoed his social media argument that there were problems with the election, Sen. Cindy Hyde-Smith said she would "respect the decision" of voters, and Rep. James Comer pushed back on White House warnings that planned Democratic probes of the administration could amount to "blatant criminality."
A Journal opinion piece, headlined "A Chance for the to Move Past Trumpism," argues the defeat offers a chance to return to the party's roots.
- The Seattle Times: Republicans dazed by midterm election defeats grapple with what went wrong
- The Wall Street Journal: Opinion | A Chance for the GOP to Move Past Trumpism (opinion)
Conservative1 outlet
An unpopular president and a lost message war
The Daily Wire's "The Good The Bad And The Ugly: 'Everybody Lost'" is a Punch interview. Ben Domenech talks with Curt Anderson, a consultant who worked in Reagan's White House and later founded OnMessage. The piece calls the result a sweeping loss and a "bloodbath."
Anderson says he expected "bad or really bad" and it was "really bad." On candidate quality, he says "the good, the bad, and the ugly candidates all lost," naming John James as good, Vivek Ramaswamy as bad and Ken Paxton as ugly. He says that with almost two-thirds of the public viewing the president unfavorably, a party "is going to get smoked."
He adds that money and tactics cannot beat a lost message war. Domenech says the cost of living is too high, but points to a stat that people rated the economy lower than during the financial crisis. The two also preview what comes next in 2028.
- The Daily Wire: The Good The Bad And The Ugly: “Everybody Lost”
Which side made the stronger case?
We will email you when the story continues. At most one email a day.
All sources: 8 articles from 8 outlets
Liberal (5)
- ABC News: Republicans dazed by midterm election defeats grapple with what went wrong
- HuffPost: Voters Rejected Trump. Republicans Responded By Lurching To The Right.
- NBC News: Republicans tiptoe around Trump as they process defeat in the 2026 elections
- The Independent: Republicans admit ‘we failed’ but show little appetite for breaking with Trump after midterm losses
- Yahoo News: Trump's midterm setback leaves some longtime supporters questioning MAGA's future
Center (2)
- The Seattle Times: Republicans dazed by midterm election defeats grapple with what went wrong
- The Wall Street Journal: Opinion | A Chance for the GOP to Move Past Trumpism (opinion)
Conservative (1)
- The Daily Wire: The Good The Bad And The Ugly: “Everybody Lost”
The evening briefing by email
One email a day, around 8:30 p.m. New York time: the seven main stories, each with its three sides, and the blind spot of the day. Unsubscribe with one tap.
A Telegram channel is coming soon.