ABRAnews Open the whole story. Sign in

Homeland Security chief says AI may be behind US outages, citing unnamed expert

Markwayne Mullin says he is 98% sure no cyberattack is involved, while commentator Megyn Kelly and Rep. Ted Lieu criticize his explanation.

Markwayne Mullin in 2022
Markwayne Mullin in 2022. Photo: United States Senate, Public domain, Wikimedia Commons
Published 1 min readMoney and daily life
Overview

Secretary Markwayne Mullin said on Fox News' Hannity on Monday, Nov. 16, that artificial intelligence could be behind a string of recent outages at airlines and banks. He cited an unnamed tech expert, who he said was not Elon Musk. Mullin said the idea "kind of makes sense" to him.

As he relayed it, the expert's view is that AI programs that rewrite their own code can overrun older systems. Mullin said he is 98% certain no cyberattack is involved, and that the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency told him it saw no sign of one. The outages include a Microsoft disruption on Thursday and Friday, a nationwide ground stop on Friday, Nov. 13, that lasted more than four hours, and problems at United Airlines and major banks on Monday.

Technicians have linked the ground stop to a newly installed router in El Dorado, Arkansas. Chase blamed its problem on a software bug. Secretary of State Marco Rubio said Tuesday officials have no evidence the incidents are related.

Rep. Ted Lieu, a California Democrat, asked for facts before such claims. Commentator Megyn Kelly said she has "zero faith" in Mullin.

Key figures
  • 98%Mullin's stated certainty that the outages are not cyberattacksNew York Post
  • more than four hourslength of the nationwide FAA ground stop on Nov. 13Newsweek
  • more than 90 minutesflight delays from United Airlines' Monday outageNewsweek
  • $875 millioncost of the FAA's SMART AI system, launched nationwide Nov. 10The New Republic

Three sides of the story

14 news outlets reported this · Little coverage from liberal outlets

Tap a color or swipe sideways to switch sides.

Liberal4 outlets

Mullin's anonymous-expert theory and the backlash to it

The Daily Beast, The New Republic, The Independent and HuffPost focus on Mullin's theory and the reaction to it. HuffPost calls it a "bizarre moment" built on "one guy that's very smart with tech." The Independent says Mullin was "mocked" and quotes Rep. Ted Lieu, Nate Silver, CNN's Brian Stelter and journalist Laura Rozen.

The New Republic says he is "facing backlash" for spreading "conspiracy theories" and adds that the FAA rolled out its $875 million SMART AI system three days before the ground stop. It says senior officials deny any connection. The Independent also reports Chase's software-bug statement and says the ground stop came after a contractor swapped copper lines for fiber-optic cabling at a radio site in El Dorado, Arkansas.

It notes Trump blamed the Biden administration. The Daily Beast leads with Megyn Kelly saying she has "zero faith" in Mullin, and notes he replaced Kristi Noem in March after Trump fired her. It adds that Mullin gave a press conference with Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy where the two seemed at odds and confused about the causes.

Center2 outlets

Kelly's rebuke set against a timeline of outages

Newsweek leads with Megyn Kelly taking aim at Mullin, quoting her: "This is a very serious agency." It then lays out his Hannity appearance, including that he asked the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency about a cyberattack, then turned to an unnamed expert. Newsweek says Kelly saw a moment of honesty in the interview but questioned sharing a poorly sourced explanation on cable news.

A "What To Know" section runs through the outages: Microsoft, the FAA ground stop on Nov. 13 and the router in El Dorado, Arkansas, United Airlines, Chase and other banks, and NSANet reportedly going offline Tuesday. It quotes Secretary of State Marco Rubio: "We have no indication, no evidence" that the incidents are related. A cybersecurity expert, Sean Connery, warns that scammers could exploit confusion over the banking outage.

Newsweek says it asked Mullin's office for comment.

Conservative8 outlets

Mullin's explanation and his assurance the homeland is secure

The New York Post, The Epoch Times, The Daily Wire and Breitbart News report Mullin's Hannity remarks at length, with his "change order on a house" analogy in his own words. The Daily Wire stresses that he urged Americans to take a deep breath and said the country is "secure." The Epoch Times quotes him saying "Breathe" and says an investigation into the root cause is ongoing.

It adds that Democrats want a probe while Mike Johnson called one unnecessary. The New York Post and The Daily Wire report his 98% certainty that no cyberattack is involved, and the Post adds that industry experts told it holiday-season pressure to update systems with AI could worsen problems. Marva Bailer of Qualaix is quoted on this.

The Daily Wire adds Trump's remark that "it's life" and Chase's software-bug statement. Breitbart quotes Mullin on backup systems being overwhelmed.

What a side did not mention
  • Conservative outlets did not mentionMegyn Kelly's on-air criticism of Mullin Reported by The Daily Beast, Newsweek
  • Liberal outlets did not mentionMullin saying the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency told him it saw no sign of a cyberattack Reported by Newsweek, The Epoch Times, Breitbart News
Money and daily life

Cybersecurity expert Sean Connery told Newsweek that scammers could exploit confusion over the bank outage by sending customers fake messages saying their accounts were affected. He urges people to avoid clicking links in unexpected messages that request account verification, warning such a scam "could cost you real money." Chase said Monday's disruption stemmed from a software glitch, and customers can still reach their accounts and funds.

All sources: 25 articles from 14 outlets

Liberal (14)

Center (2)

Conservative (9)

DHS (Department of Homeland Security)

The federal ministry in charge of borders and immigration enforcement. ICE, CBP and USCIS belong to it, as do the Coast Guard, the Secret Service and the disaster agency FEMA.

All terms →
FAA

Federal Aviation Administration: the federal agency that runs air traffic control and sets safety rules for airlines, pilots and airports.

All terms →
Speaker of the House

The leader of the House of Representatives, chosen by its members, usually from the majority party. Second in line to the presidency after the vice president.

All terms →