Democrat Mary Peltola ousts Alaska Sen. Dan Sullivan, giving Democrats 56 Senate seats
The New York Times reported her staffers helped recruit a second Dan Sullivan, which her team denies, and Trump called for her prosecution.
Democrat Mary Peltola, a former member of the US House, won Alaska's seat, ousting Republican Sen. Dan Sullivan. The Associated Press called the race on Tuesday, according to a New York Times report run by The Philadelphia Inquirer. The win gives Democrats 56 Senate seats, The Guardian reports.
The Daily Wire reports she led Sullivan 50.1% to 45.8% with the count nearly complete. The New York Times report run by the Inquirer says Peltola gained from frustration over the cost of living, especially fuel prices that many voters blamed on Trump's and his war with Iran. The race was clouded by a second candidate named Dan J. Sullivan.
The New York Times reported that Peltola's staffers helped recruit him, and her team denied involvement. The Inquirer's text says the Times found no evidence of illegal activity, and that Republicans had called the candidacy a Democratic plot. The Guardian says Trump called for Peltola's prosecution and that the episode triggered federal and state investigations.
- 50.1% to 45.8%Peltola's lead over Sullivan with over 99% counted, per The Daily WireThe Daily Wire
- 12,458 votesPeltola's margin over Sullivan, per The Daily WireThe Daily Wire
- 56 seatsDemocrats' total in the Senate after the final race was calledThe Guardian
- 4,760votes for the second Dan Sullivan, per The Daily WireThe Daily Wire
- 6,105votes for candidate Gerald Heikes, per The Daily WireThe Daily Wire
Three sides of the story
25 news outlets reported this
Tap a color or swipe sideways to switch sides.
Liberal11 outlets
An underdog's win on Alaska's cost of living
The Guardian's First Thing newsletter starts with the Senate math: Peltola's win brings Democrats to 56 seats after gaining nine in the , and she becomes Alaska's first Democrat sent to the Senate since 2008. It then turns to her campaign, which it says was "dogged by controversy" after the New York Times reported her staffers helped recruit a second Dan Sullivan. Her team denied involvement, it says, and Trump called for her prosecution.
The Philadelphia Inquirer runs a New York Times report that describes her as an underdog against a two-term incumbent. It credits her focus on Alaskans' cost of living, especially fuel prices many blamed on Trump's tariffs and the Iran war, and describes a cautious campaign that kept to her "Fish, Family, Freedom" slogan. It says the Times found no evidence of illegal activity in the ballot recruitment and that the extra candidates may not have changed the outcome.
NBC News titles its video segment "Major Upset." A separate New York Times piece says high fuel costs and worry about overfishing drew Alaskans to her "hyperlocal pitch."
- The Guardian: Peltola’s Alaska victory secures 56th Democratic seat in Senate | First Thing
- The Philadelphia Inquirer: Mary Peltola flips Alaska senate seat for Democrats
- NBC News: Democrat Mary Peltola Wins Alaska Senate Race in Major Upset
Center5 outlets
Outlets in the center gave the story little coverage.
Conservative9 outlets
The 'Decoy Dan' scheme and the vote count
The Daily Wire pairs the result with what its headline calls a "Dirty Dem" scheme involving "Decoy Dan." It gives the count in detail: Peltola 50.1%, Sullivan 45.8%, a 12,458-vote margin, and 4,760 votes for the second Sullivan, a retired teacher whom Republicans dubbed "Decoy Dan." Citing a New York Times investigation, it reports that Democratic operatives worked to recruit him in an apparent effort to undercut the incumbent, and that Peltola's campaign denied participation.
Trump argued on Truth Social that the second Sullivan ran "solely for the purpose of fraud and confusion." Sullivan's campaign said "D.C. lawyers" had conspired with Peltola's campaign to deceive voters. The outlet also sets Peltola's moderate campaign image against her House record, including a vote against a 2023 sports bill.
It cites leaked messages about Planned Parenthood and mentions headlines about her treatment of staff.
- Liberal outlets did not mentionLeaked messages in which Peltola made hostile remarks about Planned Parenthood Reported by The Daily Wire
Which side made the stronger case?
We will email you when the story continues. At most one email a day.
All sources: 32 articles from 25 outlets
Liberal (14)
- HuffPost: Democrat Mary Peltola Pulls Out A Win In Alaska Senate Race
- NBC News: Democrat Mary Peltola Wins Alaska Senate Race in Major Upset
- NPR: Mary Peltola flips Alaska's Senate seat. And, Nvidia won't reinstate Jensen Huang
- PBS NewsHour: Democrats flipped 9 U.S. Senate seats — the most in almost 70 years
- PBS NewsHour: Democrat Mary Peltola wins Alaska Senate seat, beating Republican incumbent Dan Sullivan
- The Boston Globe: Fish and high prices: How Mary Peltola triumphed in Alaska’s Senate race
- The Daily Beast: Trump Humiliated as Wild Demand Backfires Spectacularly
- The Guardian: Peltola’s Alaska victory secures 56th Democratic seat in Senate | First Thing
- The New Republic: Turns Out, Second Dan Sullivan Made No Difference in Alaska Race
- The New Republic: Democrats Flip Alaska and Send Second Native Woman to Senate
- The Philadelphia Inquirer: Mary Peltola flips Alaska senate seat for Democrats
- Yahoo News: Peltola win doesn't end DOJ scrutiny of Alaska Senate race, officials say
Center (7)
- Deseret News: Mary Peltola overcomes same-name fight to flip Alaska’s Senate seat
- Newsweek: DOJ’s ‘Other Dan Sullivan’ Criminal Probe Widens After Peltola Win
- Newsweek: Alaska Senate Lawsuit Update As Court Urged To Sanction DOJ Lawyers
- Reason: Trump Justice Department Drops Attempt to Block Certification of Alaska Senate Election Result in "Voter Confusion" Case
- The Hill: Jeffries moves closer to Speaker
- The Hill: Peltola victory in Alaska completes sweeping Senate wins for Democrats
- The Seattle Times: Peltola says Alaska voters want relief from high prices and did not elect her to be partisan
Conservative (11)
- Daily Caller: Mary Peltola Wins Alaska Senate Race After Campaign Allegedly Recruited Another Dan Sullivan
- Just the News: Justice Dept. issues hundreds of subpoenas in Alaska 'Decoy Dan' probe as Peltola declared winner
- The Blaze: Winner declared in Alaska’s Senate race despite alleged cheating scandal
- The Center Square: Peltola flips Alaska U.S. Senate, Democrats take 56 seats
- The Daily Signal: Peltola Unseats Sullivan in Alaska, Giving Democrats 56 Senate Seats
- The Daily Wire: Democrat Mary Peltola Flips Alaska Senate Seat After Dirty Dem ‘Decoy Dan’ Scheme
- The Post Millennial: Alaska GOP Senator Dan Sullivan loses seat to Mary Peltola, giving Dems 56-44 majority
- The Washington Times: Peltola says Alaska voters want relief from high prices and did not elect her to be partisan
- The Washington Times: Democrats finish off GOP rout with Alaska flip
- Washington Examiner: Dan Sullivan’s loss is an indictment of Trump’s tariffs (opinion)
- Washington Examiner: DOJ issues more than 200 subpoenas in Alaska ‘Decoy Dan’ investigation as Peltola wins
The evening briefing by email
One email a day, around 8:30 p.m. New York time: the seven main stories, each with its three sides, and the blind spot of the day. Unsubscribe with one tap.
A Telegram channel is coming soon.