Australian lawmaker Helen Haines leaves hospital a month after alleged car attack
The independent MP, who lost both legs, says she will continue rehabilitation in Melbourne. A man has been charged over the Oct. 19 attack.

Helen Haines, an independent Australian lawmaker, left Melbourne's Alfred hospital on Monday, Nov. 16, about four weeks after she was struck by a vehicle outside her electorate office in Wangaratta, Victoria, on Oct. 19. Both of her legs were amputated. In her first public statement since the attack, the 65-year-old said she had moved into the rehabilitation stage of her recovery, which will continue in Melbourne.
Police say the attack was deliberate, and Prime Minister Anthony Albanese said within hours that her injuries were not an accident. Brendan Nugent, 43, faces charges of causing harm to a Commonwealth public official, intentionally causing serious injury and dangerous driving causing serious injury. Police have not disclosed a motive, and the investigation continues.
Haines's family asked well-wishers to give to Save the Children instead of sending flowers, and the appeal has drawn donations from many Australians. Haines said she was "overwhelmed" by the generosity of Australians. In a statement, Albanese said "we continue to provide support" to Haines, her family, community and staff.
- more than 1.4 million Australian dollars, $950,000raised for Save the Children, by Save the Children Australia's countABC News
Three sides of the story
Liberal2 outlets
Her recovery and the climate of political anger
ABC News carries the same text as The Seattle Times and opens with Haines thanking well-wishers after leaving hospital, describing her as "almost killed" in an allegedly deliberate attack. It adds that witnesses said she was repeatedly rammed, that security at several lawmakers' offices has been enhanced and that public incitement against officials is growing. The Guardian's headline links her discharge to the "double leg amputation" and states police will allege she was beside the boot of her car when a vehicle made a U-turn and hit her repeatedly.
It lists Nugent's charges, including two cannabis offences, notes her leave of absence until 26 November and quotes Albanese warning of "rage and aggression increasing." It also quotes independent MP Allegra Spender calling the news "wonderful."
Center4 outlets
Her discharge and what the attack revealed nationally
UPI leads with Haines's statement that she is out of hospital and will continue her recovery in Melbourne. It quotes Health Minister Mark Butler saying her road to recovery "is going to be a long one." Euronews opens on the "soul-searching" the attack has set off, noting that political violence is uncommon in Australia while police have tracked growing threats to elected officials.
BBC News calls it an alleged attack "which horrified Australia," says Nugent has yet to enter pleas, and notes that his father described a long friendship with Haines and that his lawyer has cited mental health concerns. BBC also reports that Victoria Police's investigation continues, that a motive is yet to be established, and that the incident prompted a reckoning over the tone of public debate. Euronews and BBC both note her 2019 entry to parliament after work as a nurse and midwife.
The Seattle Times ran the same text as ABC News.
- UPI: Australian MP Helen Haines discharged from hospital after attack
- Euronews: Australian MP Helen Haines leaves hospital after losing both legs in alleged car attack
- BBC News: Australian MP who lost both legs in alleged car attack discharged from hospital
- The Seattle Times: Injured Australian lawmaker Helen Haines leaves hospital after alleged SUV attack
Conservative0 outlets
Outlets on this side gave the story little coverage.
Which side made the stronger case?
We will email you when the story continues. At most one email a day.
All sources: 6 articles from 6 outlets
Liberal (2)
- ABC News: Injured Australian lawmaker Helen Haines leaves hospital after alleged SUV attack
- The Guardian: MP Helen Haines leaves hospital four weeks after alleged attack and double leg amputation
Center (4)
- BBC News: Australian MP who lost both legs in alleged car attack discharged from hospital
- Euronews: Australian MP Helen Haines leaves hospital after losing both legs in alleged car attack
- The Seattle Times: Injured Australian lawmaker Helen Haines leaves hospital after alleged SUV attack
- UPI: Australian MP Helen Haines discharged from hospital after attack
The evening briefing by email
One email a day, around 8:30 p.m. New York time: the seven main stories, each with its three sides, and the blind spot of the day. Unsubscribe with one tap.
A Telegram channel is coming soon.