ABRAnews Three sides to every story.
Courts & Justice

Federal judge rules Justice Department unlawfully fired prosecutor Maurene Comey, ex-FBI director's daughter

Judge Jesse Furman orders her reinstated with back pay through Dec. 20, 2025. The Justice Department disagrees and says it will appeal in due course.

10 news outlets reported this
Liberal4 outletsCenter2 outletsConservative4 outlets
Published 3 min read
Overview

On Monday, U.S. District Judge Jesse Furman ruled that the unlawfully fired Maurene Comey, a federal prosecutor in the Southern District of New York. She is the daughter of former Director James Comey. She was fired in July 2025 after nearly a decade in the office.

Furman found the firing violated the separation of powers and federal civil service law. He reinstated her retroactively and ordered back pay through Dec. 20, 2025, when she took another job. The Justice Department had argued that Article II of the Constitution lets the executive remove prosecutors at will.

Furman rejected that, saying it conflicts with nearly two centuries of precedent. Court filings say then- Pam Bondi directed the firing. A Justice Department spokesperson said the department disagrees and will appeal "in due course."

Comey's lawyers called the ruling a "hard-earned victory." She had worked on cases involving Sean Combs, Jeffrey Epstein and Ghislaine Maxwell. Outlets differ on how much they say about the judge's background, the wider pattern of firings and her father's cases.

Only the Daily Caller addresses whether the ruling can be appealed now.

Three sides of the story

Liberal4 outlets

CBS, NBC and The Guardian focus on the ruling's legal reasoning and its place in a wider pattern. They quote Furman's phrase "sweeping and unprecedented theory of executive authority" and his finding that the firing broke civil service law. CBS reports that the Justice Department admitted Comey's strong performance reviews and relied partly on a recent Supreme Court decision about removing independent agency members.

NBC and The Guardian place the case alongside other firings of career prosecutors and FBI staff, especially people tied to investigations of Trump. NBC and The Guardian also describe the case against James Comey over the seashell photo. The Guardian adds that an earlier case against him was dismissed.

All three give Comey's lawyers' statement, including that "the President is not above the law." NPR's short summary says the ruling adds to concerns about politically motivated firings at the Justice Department. These outlets do not mention the judge's appointing president.

Center2 outlets

BBC News gives a compact account of the ruling. It reports that Furman ordered reinstatement and back pay, and that the attorney general may fire prosecutors only "in a particular manner and only for certain reasons." It cites Comey's complaint alleging she was fired because of her father or her perceived political views.

It notes the Justice Department's attribution of the decision to Bondi and its pledge to appeal. It also summarizes the two prosecutions of James Comey, including the seashell "86 47" case, and says he denies wrongdoing. It explains "86" as slang for "get rid of" and reports prosecutors' allegation that the post encourages violence against Trump.

The Journal's short description says Comey accused the administration of improperly targeting her. Centrist coverage here is mostly descriptive. It does not stress the judge's background or dwell on the wider pattern of firings.

Conservative4 outlets

Fox News, the Daily Caller and the Daily Wire report the ruling and quote Furman's key lines. Their headlines and text note that he was appointed by President Obama. Fox and the Daily Caller add that his brother served in the Obama administration.

Fox also mentions his earlier rulings against the administration in the Mahmoud Khalil case. They stress that the Justice Department conceded the firing was not for cause or performance. The Daily Wire quotes Furman warning of a return to the "spoils system."

The Daily Caller reports Comey joined a law firm in February and is not seeking to return, citing Reuters. It says an appeal may have to wait until the court resolves her remaining claim. It notes the firing came as Trump faced pressure to release Epstein-related information, citing NBC.

Fox says critics read the seashell post as a threat. These outlets say little about the wider pattern of firings of staff tied to Trump investigations.

All sources: 10 articles from 10 outlets

Liberal (4)

Center (2)

Conservative (4)

Related
Justice Department

The federal ministry that prosecutes federal crimes. The FBI is part of it, and its head is the Attorney General.

All terms →
FBI

The Federal Bureau of Investigation: the main federal police and counterintelligence agency, part of the Justice Department.

All terms →
Supreme Court

The highest US court: nine justices, appointed for life by the president with the Senate's approval. Its rulings bind every other court.

All terms →
Attorney General

The head of the Justice Department and the government's chief lawyer. Each state has its own attorney general too.

All terms →
Wall Street

A street in New York where the stock exchange stands. In the news it means US financial markets and the big banks and investment firms as a whole.

All terms →
First Amendment

The part of the US Constitution that bars the government from limiting speech, the press, religion, peaceful assembly and petitions. It restrains the government, not private companies or employers.

All terms →