Vance blames Iran war for GOP midterm defeat as Republicans reassess 2028 field
Democrats won both chambers of Congress, former House Speaker Newt Gingrich says the nomination race is "wide open," and DeSantis gains in prediction markets.

Democrats won control of both and the in Tuesday's elections, and Republicans are now debating who could lead the party in 2028. On Wednesday, Vice President JD Vance wrote on X that "The reason we lost is the war," referring to the war with Iran. Former Newt Gingrich wrote that the scale of the defeat makes the nomination race "wide open."
Vance remains the front-runner in prediction markets, but Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis has gained. Kalshi has DeSantis at 19 percent, up 14.6 points, and Vance at 27 percent, according to Townhall. Secretary of State Marco Rubio denied reports that he would resign to prepare a run, telling the New York Times he will not talk about 2028.
DeSantis told CNN he will "be a free man" in January. Asked about Vance's plans, Trump said "Maybe he won't run." On Wednesday, CNN reported that Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth, who faces criticism over the war, could face an vote in the House.
- at least 54Democratic Senate seats, per the Washington ExaminerWashington Examiner
- north of 250Democratic House seats, per the Washington ExaminerWashington Examiner
- 27 percentVance's nomination odds on Kalshi, per TownhallTownhall
- 19 percentDeSantis's nomination odds on Kalshi, up 14.6 points, per TownhallTownhall
- 34 percentVance's nomination odds on Polymarket, per The IndependentThe Independent
Three sides of the story
15 news outlets reported this
Tap a color or swipe sideways to switch sides.
Liberal8 outlets
Vance's path murkier, 2028 field wide open
The Daily Beast leads with Republican fear that the scale of the defeat means looking beyond Trump's circle for a 2028 candidate, citing Semafor's talks with half a dozen Republicans. One strategist calls Vance "the biggest loser Tuesday night." The Independent leads with DeSantis as an "unlikely" leading candidate after a Polymarket surge, then profiles contenders, putting Vance at 34 percent and Rubio at 17 percent.
It adds that Axios reports Vance warned Trump the war was "highly unpopular and could cost Republicans the election." Yahoo News says Vance's path now looks "much murkier." It quotes Gingrich on a wide-open race and Iowa conservative leader Bob Vander Plaats, who expects a field that could rival 2016.
It still calls Vance the clear front-runner, citing donor ties and Turning Point USA backing. The Daily Beast says some Republicans are said to be seeking to impeach Hegseth over the war, and Yahoo cites a CNN report that he could face a House impeachment vote.
Center3 outlets
Defeat complicates Vance's decision on running
The Journal says the Republicans' heavy midterm loss makes Vice President JD Vance's choice on whether to run in 2028 harder. It says some people close to him fear any candidate would struggle to prevail in a presidential race two years out.
Conservative4 outlets
Who blames whom, and how 2028 hopefuls react
The Washington Examiner opens with a "shockwave" through the party that could upend the 2028 field, then goes hopeful by hopeful. It reports pundits blaming Trump's focus on ballroom and Reflecting Pool renovations over gas and diesel prices tied to the Iran war. It quotes Vance's post, then replies from Ari Fleischer, who blames the cease-fire, Marjorie Taylor Greene, who says "Good start JD," and Chris Christie, who says Vance "has no credibility."
Cruz calls the result "a blue tsunami." Rubio tells the New York Times, "I literally will not talk about 2028 anymore." Townhall leads with DeSantis's rise on Kalshi and Polymarket, with Vance still ahead at 27 percent on Kalshi.
It quotes DeSantis saying gas is "higher because of this conflict." Townhall adds that prices keep shifting and the election is two years away.
- Conservative outlets did not mentionSome Republicans reportedly seek to impeach Hegseth over the Iran war, and CNN reported a possible House vote Reported by The Daily Beast, Yahoo News
Which side made the stronger case?
We will email you when the story continues. At most one email a day.
All sources: 24 articles from 15 outlets
Liberal (13)
- HuffPost: OUCH! Trump’s 2028 Endorsement Plans Could Be Bad News For JD Vance
- HuffPost: After Midterm Rout, Vance Tries To Build His Own 2028 Brand
- NPR: Midterm results could complicate JD Vance's political future
- The Daily Beast: Vance's Allies Float Return to Ohio After Midterm Flop
- The Daily Beast: Republicans Confronted With Grim New Fear After Trump Rout
- The Guardian: JD Vance’s first 2028 pitch reveals his profound weakness as a candidate | Moira Donegan
- The Independent: Rubio gets short when asked about a potential 2028 run
- The Independent: Unlikely candidate sees huge surge in race to become US president in 2028
- The Independent: DeSantis in unlikely surge as Republican maneuvers begin over presidential runs in 2028
- The New Republic: Republicans Pull Huge 180 on JD Vance for 2028 After Elections Loss
- The Philadelphia Inquirer: Jeff Van Drew weighs a 2028 run after shocking loss to Zack Mullock: ‘Just see what people are thinking’
- The Philadelphia Inquirer: Potential Vance challengers smell blood in the water after brutal GOP losses
- Yahoo News: Vance and DeSantis make quick moves to jumpstart 2028 race after tough GOP midterms
Center (4)
- Newsweek: Does JD Vance Have a Shot in 2028? John Bolton Doubts the VP’s Chances
- Newsweek: Trump Asked Who Should Succeed Him. Here’s What He Said
- The Hill: Vance’s 2028 stock drops: Ranking top 5 presidential GOP contenders post-midterms
- The Wall Street Journal: A major Republican defeat in the midterm elections has complicated Vice President JD Vance’s decision on whether to run for president in 2028
Conservative (7)
- Fox News: MAGA voters reveal who they want to see lead GOP in 2028
- The Daily Signal: GOP Insiders Look Past Trump’s Kingmaking Toward 2028
- Townhall: Ron DeSantis Surges in Prediction Markets As 2028 Presidential Contender
- Washington Examiner: An early ‘Rubio 2028’ poll bounce (opinion)
- Washington Examiner: MAGA insiders believe Vance WILL run, but aren’t sure if he SHOULD run
- Washington Examiner: Democrats’ big win creates a 2028 problem (opinion)
- Washington Examiner: How potential Republican 2028 candidates are reacting to the midterm elections
The evening briefing by email
One email a day, around 8:30 p.m. New York time: the seven main stories, each with its three sides, and the blind spot of the day. Unsubscribe with one tap.
A Telegram channel is coming soon.