Harvard study links strict school phone bans to modest gains in test scores
Researchers estimate gains of one to two extra weeks of learning a year, while an author of an earlier study questions projecting them forward.

Этот сюжет ещё не переведён — показан текст на английском.
A Harvard University study released on Tuesday, Nov. 17, links strict school phone bans to small gains in student learning. Harvard's Center for Education Policy Research looked at test scores for about 3.3 million students in third through 10th grade, as three outlets report, at 4,600 schools, from 2021 through the 2025-26 school year. Schools that locked phones away all day saw math and reading growth equal to one to two extra weeks of learning a year.
Researchers say that reverses about half of the yearly loss students had before the pandemic. Tom Kane, a Harvard professor and an author of the study, says he thinks earlier dismissals of the effect of in-school phone use are mistaken. An earlier national study, published through the National Bureau of Economic Research, found close to zero overall effect, though it saw gains in high school math.
Its co-author Thomas Dee of Stanford says he is not comfortable projecting the gains forward from small estimates based on a few years of bans. Brian Jacob of the University of Michigan, another author of that study, says the new results are quite similar to his team's and, while cautioning against too much optimism about modest gains, says they could matter if they accumulate. Researchers also found gains under less strict policies, with less confidence in them.
- 3.3 millionstudents analyzed in the Harvard studyThe Boston Globe
- 4,600US schools in the studyThe Boston Globe
- one to two weeksof extra learning a year linked to strict bans, per the Daily WireThe Daily Wire
- Forty-six stateswith school phone bans or restrictions, per the Daily WireThe Daily Wire
- $25 per studentKane's estimate of phone pouch cost, as the Daily Wire reportsThe Daily Wire
Три стороны истории
Об этом писали 7 изданий
Нажмите на цвет или листайте вбок, чтобы сменить сторону.
Либеральные4 издания
Small gains and open questions about them
The Boston Globe, running a New York Times text, leads with phone bans "gradually improving" scores and the first large national before-and-after analysis. It quotes Kane saying earlier studies were wrongly dismissed, and Brian Jacob saying that accumulated gains "could be really important." It also quotes David Figlio saying a major impact of phones is almost certainly out-of-school use.
The Independent says the research shows the reality is "considerably more complex." It gives Thomas Dee's doubt, "I'm not comfortable making that extrapolation," and psychologist Jean Twenge on weak enforcement and laptops. Time asks whether small gains are "worth it," quoting Kane, who calls bans one of the most cost-effective ways to "plug" a leak, and advocate Kim Whitman, who says she is "thrilled."
Time adds survey figures on parents' emergency-access worries.
- The Boston Globe: New evidence shows school phone bans are gradually improving test scores (на английском)
- The Independent: Schools are banning phones in the classroom and it’s paying off in higher test scores (на английском)
- Time: School Phone Bans Show Small Learning Gains. Are They Worth It? (на английском)
- NPR: Do school cellphone bans work? New study says yes – but it's complicated (на английском)
Центр1 издание
A big Harvard study suggests bans boost learning
The Journal's news report headlines that the Harvard study suggests school cellphone bans boost students' learning. It calls the work one of the first big looks at the effect of such restrictions. A Journal opinion piece, labelled as opinion, says a nationwide study shows learning gains, which it says makes sense.
- The Wall Street Journal: School Cellphone Bans Boost Students’ Learning, Study Suggests (на английском)
- The Wall Street Journal: Opinion | What Happens When Schools Ban Phones (мнение, на английском)
Консервативные2 издания
Bans are paying off, with caveats on size
The Daily Wire headlines that strict bans are "paying off for students" and leads with measurable gains of one to two extra weeks of learning. It quotes Kane from the New York Times saying earlier dismissals were "mistaken," adds Kane's estimate of about $25 per student for pouches, and notes the Harvard study used a smaller subset of schools on the NWEA testing system. It also reports Brian Jacob's caution against placing too much weight on small gains and his view that their cumulative effect could become meaningful if they persist.
The Epoch Times headlines that the Harvard study says bans "are working," quoting a Nov. 17 statement from Kane that restrictions "seem to plug about half of that leak." It quotes Dartmouth's Douglas Staiger on storing phones as cost-effective, and notes the study did not examine use outside school. It also covers a 2025 Florida district study that found a slight rise in test scores and a double-digit rise in suspension rates in the first year.
- The Daily Wire: Strict School Phone Bans Are Paying Off For Students (на английском)
- The Epoch Times: School Phone Bans Are Working, New Harvard Study Says (на английском)
Какая сторона убедительнее?
Напишем, когда у сюжета будет продолжение. Не больше одного письма в день.
- Grades covered by the Harvard study
- The Independent: grades four to 10
- The Boston Globe, The Daily Wire, The Epoch Times: third through 10th grade
The Daily Wire reports Kane estimates phone pouches cost about $25 per student. The study links strict bans to gains equal to one to two extra weeks of learning a year. Time reports that in a 2024 Pew Research Center survey, 6 in 10 opponents of classroom bans cited parents' ability to reach their children.
Все источники: 9 статей из 7 изданий
Либеральные (5)
- NPR: Do school cellphone bans work? New study says yes – but it's complicated (на английском)
- The Boston Globe: New evidence shows school phone bans are gradually improving test scores (на английском)
- The Boston Globe: Do school phone bans help students learn? So far, gains are ‘modest.’ (на английском)
- The Independent: Schools are banning phones in the classroom and it’s paying off in higher test scores (на английском)
- Time: School Phone Bans Show Small Learning Gains. Are They Worth It? (на английском)
Центр (2)
- The Wall Street Journal: School Cellphone Bans Boost Students’ Learning, Study Suggests (на английском)
- The Wall Street Journal: Opinion | What Happens When Schools Ban Phones (мнение, на английском)
Консервативные (2)
- The Daily Wire: Strict School Phone Bans Are Paying Off For Students (на английском)
- The Epoch Times: School Phone Bans Are Working, New Harvard Study Says (на английском)
Вечерняя сводка на почту
Одно письмо в день, около 20:30 по Нью-Йорку: семь главных сюжетов, у каждого три стороны, и слепое пятно дня. Отписка одним нажатием.